Update:Remora Feedback

Alpha Feedback - http://preview.addons.mozilla.org

This page is for consolidation of the feedback on the new AMO Alpha. If you're more comfortable filing bugs, you're welcome to do that instead.

fligtar's comments

I like the overall look, but I have a few comments about certain aspects:

• Having the search box at the bottom is too annoying. I don't want to have to scroll down to search. I also think there should be a search box somewhere on every page, as before the reskinning. AMO search doesn't suck now (hopefully) so we should make sure it's used instead Google on site:addons.mozilla.org which is how I currently find things.
• Home is listed on both the top menu and the side menu. It seems a little strange and would be more appropriate to only be on the top menu.
• The sidebar still doesn't show the active page with a gray background (li class="selected")
• The discussion header/footer is noticeably different.
• This may be a vanilla bug, not sure: "Comment by made 1 day ago days ago"
• Discussions show a CakePHP favicon for me

clouserw's comments

• Old URLs should redirect into the new format so we don't get 404s
• If there are no addons in a category, an unfriendly/unstyled message is flashed, and the user is redirected to the front page.
• Pages should validate
• the language list in the footer should select the language I'm currently browsing in, not always "English (US)" -- will fix. wenzel
• on the /addons/display page, the "bad trip" link does nothing
• on /addons/display, there is no way to see a single review without clicking "see all reviews" -- will fix. wenzel
• when adding a review, the "rating" can be any positive number -- will fix. wenzel
• Discussions can be started that aren't related to an addon (just click "discussions" in the header, then start a new topic)
• When a user creates an account, they only see a "created successfully" flash. When they try to login, it says they have to confirm their account first, but it never says how. -- will fix. wenzel
• The "More..." link under "Popular Extensions" on the browse page goes nowhere.

wenzel's comments

• Browse Add-ons page is kind of unfriendly and doesn't quite say what it is/does.
• Browse Category page has a "more" link for new and updated add-ons which leads to the new add-ons RSS feed (atm it's even a 404); it should maybe lead to a new page showing the new add-ons for this category only.
• Brows Add-ons page could use category specific RSS feeds.
• Add-on lists (like search) don't say "version" before the number, while featured add-ons while browsing a single category do.