28
edits
Gecko:Border collapse: Difference between revisions
→Winning corners
(→Winning corners: +no compromise argument) |
|||
| Line 71: | Line 71: | ||
Notes: | Notes: | ||
# '''Border sharing''': Several times above, sharing between two or three borders ''with different widths'' was proposed. I think it would be an interesting feature (especially in the case of two borders), but that we should provide a way to defeat it. The way I see it is that we should share the corner between <b>1</b> and the other candidate(s) if – and only if – it(they) has(have) the same style as <b>1</b>. Then the web designer could be able to easily obtain what he wants, in a supposedly logical and non-akward way. | # '''Border sharing''': Several times above, sharing between two or three borders ''with different widths'' was proposed. I think it would be an interesting feature (especially in the case of two borders), but that we should provide a way to defeat it. The way I see it is that we should share the corner between <b>1</b> and the other candidate(s) if – and only if – it(they) has(have) the same style as <b>1</b>. Then the web designer could be able to easily obtain what he wants, in a supposedly logical and non-akward way. --[[User:frnchfrgg|FrnchFrgg]] | ||
# .. | # An interesting case: when 3 or 4 borders have the same width, there is a way to determine a winner if there is a majority of borders of the same color. Then only between them the sharing could be done. That would go a bit further towards the idea of non-compromise --[[User:frnchfrgg|FrnchFrgg]] | ||
=== Alternative: No compromise on corners === | === Alternative: No compromise on corners === | ||
| Line 84: | Line 84: | ||
exists in opposition to this, and if edges compete rather than compromise, so | exists in opposition to this, and if edges compete rather than compromise, so | ||
should corners. --[[User:Lucent|Lucent]] | should corners. --[[User:Lucent|Lucent]] | ||
I think too that corners should compete rather than compromise, but when there is no correct way to decide which border wins the corner, we shouldn't arbitrarily give the corner to one of the candidates. Such behaviour leads to https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=325074 or https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=192031 which isn't expected. Yet we may share the corner between the fewest borders possible. I tried hard to find and present the most cases and possible rendering decisions possible, but we'll have to choose. ([[User:frnchfrgg|_FrnchFrgg_]]) | |||
== Who paints what == | == Who paints what == | ||