1,107
edits
| Line 46: | Line 46: | ||
In Q3 2009 we discussed three options: Upgrade, Fork, or Port (see [[https://wiki.mozilla.org/Support/TikiWikiUpgrade]]). | In Q3 2009 we discussed three options: Upgrade, Fork, or Port (see [[https://wiki.mozilla.org/Support/TikiWikiUpgrade]]). | ||
Having | == Forking == | ||
Having upstreamed the vast majority of our changes, the Fork option differs from Upgrade in the following respects: | |||
* No need to work out complex build and deployment process | |||
* No need to support two code repositories | |||
If we have reached this point by giving the TikiWiki 5.1 codebase a negative evaluation, then the Fork option is less attractive than it once was. The main advantages are | |||
* User and contributor experience would remain the same | |||
* We have working code and would not need to invest time reimplementing features | |||
== Porting == | |||
The outcome of the Porting options matrix we developed in Q3 2009 ([[https://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?key=0Ao5KB_TZOvbVdDgtSEdRNnNyeDBvWUtJOUZYZnU0Rnc&hl=en]]) was that none of the other existing platforms look significantly better than TikiWiki. That means that this option represents reimplementing the platform from scratch. | |||
When considering this option we should remember the pros and cons of porting to a new platform that [https://wiki.mozilla.org/Support/TikiWikiUpgrade#Port we analyzed previously]. | When considering this option we should remember the pros and cons of porting to a new platform that [https://wiki.mozilla.org/Support/TikiWikiUpgrade#Port we analyzed previously]. | ||
If we were to implement from scratch we would use a modern web framework such as Zend Framework, Kohana, or Django. For this application I would recommend one of the more full featured frameworks (ie probably not Kohana) for the ready availability of reusable components, which would reduce implementation time. | |||
We would need to work up an SRS of features that require/actually use and prioritize these. It may be possible to move parts of the code over before the new system is complete. For example, we have discussed reimplementing forums. We could implement forums in the new system and then migrate them over. | |||
edits