Reps/Council/Elections: Difference between revisions

From MozillaWiki
< Reps‎ | Council
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Warning added)
 
(32 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Admon/note | Note | This page is currently being updated - stay tuned!}}
{{Warning |1= With effect from 1st September 2023, the Mozilla Reps program was closed and activities ended.|title= With effect from 1st September 2023, the Mozilla Reps program was closed and activities ended.}}  


== Overview ==
= Overview =


Every 6 months, 3 or 4 Mozilla Reps (depending on the election cycle) are elected to sit on the Mozilla Reps Council (aka ReMo Council or aka the "Jedi Council") for a 1 year term. The elections ensure that the program stays true to its core values of participation, accountability and transparency.  
Every 6 months, 3 or 4 Mozilla Reps (depending on the election cycle) are elected to sit on the Mozilla Reps Council (aka ReMo Council or aka the "Jedi Council") for a 1 year term. The elections ensure that the program stays true to its core values of participation, accountability and transparency.  


All Mozilla Reps Council members who are elected to the council agree to [[ReMo/Structure_Governance#Council|the following responsibilities]].
All Mozilla Reps Council members who are elected to the council agree to [[Reps/Council#Tasks_and_Responsibilities_of_Council_Members|the following responsibilities]] and to be hold accountable by [[Reps/Council#Peers_holding_Council_accountable|these criteria]].


== Election Rules ==
= Election Rules =


===Voters===
== Voters ==


* All active Mozilla Reps who have a profile page on the [http://reps.mozilla.org Mozilla Reps Portal] are eligible to exercise their right to vote.  
* All active Mozilla Reps are eligible to exercise their right to vote.  


=== Voting ===
== Voting ==


* Voting is done via a special page on the the Portal and each Rep can cast a vote only once per election.
* Voting is done via (to be defined after decommissioning the Reps Portal) and each Rep can cast a vote only once per election.


* The elections shall utilize [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Range_voting Range Voting], where each voter will assign a score from 0 to N to each candidate (where N is the number of candidates). A voter abstains from voting by assigning a score of 0 to any number of candidates. (More information on how to cast a ballot [[ReMo/Council/Elections/Ballot_casting|here]])
* The elections shall utilize [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Range_voting Range Voting], where each voter will assign a score from 0 to N to each candidate (where N is the number of candidates). A voter abstains from voting by assigning a score of 0 to any number of candidates.


* With the exception of the system administrators, no one shall be able to associate a Rep to a vote, thus voting is anonymous.
* With the exception of the system administrators, no one shall be able to associate a Rep to a vote, thus voting is anonymous.
Line 23: Line 23:
* A Rep cannot, under any circumstance, use another Rep's account to vote. Any Rep found undermining the sanctity of the elections shall be removed from the program, after investigation by the Council.
* A Rep cannot, under any circumstance, use another Rep's account to vote. Any Rep found undermining the sanctity of the elections shall be removed from the program, after investigation by the Council.


* Reps shall be given 72 hours to cast their vote after the elections have commenced. Voting beging at 12pm UTC on Day 0 and closed at 12pm UTC on Day 3.   
* Reps shall be given at least 72 hours to cast their vote after the elections have commenced. The length of the voting period is up to the Reps Peers to decide.   


* No vote shall be counted after the prescribed voting period.
* No vote shall be counted after the prescribed voting period.


=== Candidates ===
== Candidates ==


Only Mozilla Reps who have had experience mentoring (ie. being a Mentor) are eligible to self-nominate themselves as candidates for a Council seat. After self-nomination, the Council will review the Mentor's eligibility based on the following criteria:
Only Mozilla Reps who have had experience mentoring (ie. being a Mentor or attended one of the [https://wiki.mozilla.org/Participation/Community_Gatherings Participation/Open innovation as invitees to Cohort's events] are eligible to self-nominate themselves as candidates for a Council seat. After self-nomination, the Reps Peers will review the nominees' eligibility based on the following criteria:


* Proficiency in English
* '' '''General skills: ''' ''
* Responsiveness to address issues/bugs
** Proficiency in English
* Availability for extra Council duties (eg. chairing, staff meetings, work weeks etc...)
** Availability for extra Council duties (eg. chairing, staff meetings, work weeks etc...)
* Experience and past performance as a Rep and as a Mentor
** Ability to travel (once or twice per term)
* Ability to travel
** Take initiative on leading projects inside Reps
** Be critical to help shape the volunteer strategy
** Have a clear understanding of Mozilla’s current direction and goals
** Have strategic thinking
** Be able to communicate Reps mission and vision to the rest of the org and volunteers
** Understand and be able to communicate Reps as the leading mobilizers program
** Be able to articulate his/her opinion in strategic meetings
** Have a strong background around the open web (and free software) movement
** Expertise on the ground with local communities and grassroots efforts
** Be recognized as a supportive leader inside the Mozilla community
** Have existing relationships across the organization with both volunteers and employees


If, after the review of self-nominations period is finished, and there are as many candidates as there are seats available on the Council, each candidate will be assigned a seat and no election will be held.
* '' '''Nice to have:''' ''
** Geographically spread


After the self-nominated Rep is cleared by the Council, (s)he will be officially declared as an  candidate by the Council.  
If, after the review of self-nominations period is finished, there are as many candidates as there are seats available on the Council, each candidate will be assigned a seat and no election will be held.  


If a self-nominated Rep is not cleared by the Council to run for election, (s)he cannot appeal that decision.
After the self-nominated Rep is cleared by the Peers, they will be officially announced as a candidate by the Reps Peers.  


=== Campaigning ===
If a self-nominated Rep is not cleared by the Peers to run for election, they cannot appeal that decision.


* Candidates are given '''10 days''' to campaign and communicate their agenda, plans, achievements as a Rep/Mentor, and personal strengths, to the Mozilla Reps voting body.
== Campaigning ==


* Candidates can use their personal Mozilla Reps profile page, personal website/blog, Mozilla wiki page or any other channel to post information regarding their candidacy.
* Candidates are given '''7 days''' to campaign and communicate their agenda, plans, achievements as a Rep/Mentor, and personal strengths, to the Mozilla Reps voting body.


The set of questions that each candidate is required to answer can be found [[ReMo/Council/Elections/Questions|here]].  
* Candidates can use Discourse, the public Reps communication channels, personal website/blog, a Mozilla Wiki page or any other public channel to post information regarding their candidacy. Messages in private are discouraged.


==== Questions moderation ====
* The set of questions that each candidate is required to answer can be found [[ReMo/Council/Elections/Questions|here]]. The Reps Peers create a Discourse topic to hold all candidate's answers in one place.
Using mozmoderator.org we will be gathering questions during the campaign period. After finalizing the top 10 questions each candidate is required to answer a set of questions that will be posted on their official wiki page.


* Use of social media and email shall be acceptable, provided posts are not deemed as spam, negative, nor detrimental to the election process and the Mozilla Reps program in general.
* Use of Social Media shall be acceptable, provided posts are not private or targeted, deemed as spam, negative, nor detrimental to the election process and the Mozilla Reps program in general.  


* Any Candidate found campaigning in violation of aforementioned guidelines shall be disqualified after investigation by the Council if elections have not yet started. If the candidate won a seat and is found to have violated the guidelines, the candidate will be be removed from the Council and replace with the candidate who was ranked just below after the range voting.
* Any Candidate found campaigning in violation of aforementioned guidelines shall be disqualified after investigation by the Peers if elections have not yet started. If the candidate won a seat and is found to have violated the guidelines, the candidate will be be removed from the Council and replace with the candidate who was ranked just below after the range voting.


* Mozilla Reps Council members cannot make public endorsements of candidates during the campaign period.
* Mozilla Reps Council members cannot make public endorsements of candidates during the campaign period.


=== Results ===
=== Campaign video ===
 
All candidates can produce a short campaign video if they wish to do so. This video can be uploaded to any online service and then be linked in the Discourse Q&A answer post every candidate needs to post.
 
Video is a great format to help give a human face to the election process. It also helps candidates tap into their creative side and connect with Reps on another level that's direct, genuine and a lot of fun. Through the video medium, Reps can get to know the candidates better, understand what they stand for and have a more personal connection with the candidates. There are no specific requirements as to what equipment or software you need to use, as long as the video is good enough quality so that your face is recognizable and your voice is understandable.
 
The video can last up to 2 minutes (120 seconds). If you submit a video that is longer, then the Peers reserve the right to remove it from your post until it fulfills this requirement.
 
=== Town Halls ===
 
During the Spring 2020 Council Elections we will experiment with running a full-day chat-based Ask-me-anything. You can find more information on [https://discourse.mozilla.org/t/council-elections-chat-instead-of-video-town-hall/55564/7 Discourse].
 
== Results ==


* The three (or four) candidates (depending on the election cycle) who get highest number of votes shall be declared newly elected Council members.   
* The three (or four) candidates (depending on the election cycle) who get highest number of votes shall be declared newly elected Council members.   


* If there are fewer elected candidates than the available number of Council seats, the Council will assign a provisional Council member who will sit on the Council for six months (ie. until the next election).   The provisional Council member's seat will be vacated after the next elections.
* If there are fewer elected candidates than the available number of Council seats, the Council will assign a provisional Council member who will sit on the Council for six months (ie. until the next election). The provisional Council member's seat will be vacated after the next elections.


* In case of a tie that affects the outcome of the elections, the tie shall be broken by the following criteria:
* In case of a tie that affects the outcome of the elections, the tie shall be broken by the following criteria:
Line 70: Line 92:
** The Rep with the least number of days spent as part of the Council shall be declared the winner. This is to ensure a good representation for the Council and giving all Mentors a chance to be part of the Council.
** The Rep with the least number of days spent as part of the Council shall be declared the winner. This is to ensure a good representation for the Council and giving all Mentors a chance to be part of the Council.


** If there is a tie with the first criterion, the Council shall deliberate based on the Candidate's track record as a Mentor, and the Council shall break the tie by vote.
** If there is a tie with the first criterion, the Peers shall deliberate based on the Candidate's track record as a Mentor, and the Peers shall break the tie by vote.


====<u>Appeals</u>====
== Appeals ==


A Candidate has 48 hours after elections results are made public to file an appeal to contest the results of the elections.
A Candidate has 48 hours after elections results are made public to file an appeal to contest the results of the elections.


=== Election Schedule ===
== Election Schedule ==
 
==== 1st election cycle (spring 2013) ====
 
* '''February 11th''': election announcement and call for self-nominations
* '''February 18th''': candidates announced by council and campaign is officially open  at 12pm UTC
* '''February 24th''': [[ReMo/Council/Elections/Town_hall|Town hall]] organized in #remo at 3pm UTC (to be confirmed)
* '''March 1st''': voting begins at 12pm UTC
* '''March 4th''': voting ends at 12pm UTC and results are announced publicly
 
==== 2nd election cycle (fall 2013) ====


* '''September 4th''': election announcement and call for self-nominations
The Election Schedule is adapted for public holidays and other events, therefore it is custom to every single election. You can find an example here: https://github.com/mozilla/Reps/issues/327
* '''September 21st''': candidates announced by council and campaign is officially open  at 12pm UTC
* '''September 28th''' - '''September 30th''': Questions are gathered in mozmoderator.org
* '''October 5th''': all questions answered and voting begins at 00:00 UTC
* '''October 8th''': voting ends at 00:00 UTC and results are announced publicly


==== 3rd election cycle (spring 2014) ====
General template:


* '''March 21''': call for candidates (eligible Mozilla Reps Mentors only - call closes on March 27
<pre>
* '''March 28''': start of campaign period
- [ ] DATE - Timeline presentation and announcement in Reps Call / Discourse / Mailing list (@ioana-chiorean)
**candidates are given 7 days to answer the top 10 questions asked by Reps on mozmoderator and post them on their profile page
- [ ] DATE - Call for Nominees starts (1 week) (@ioana-chiorean)
**candidates are given 7 days to publish a 30-120 seconds campaign video
- [ ] DATE - Call for Nominees closes (@ioana-chiorean)
* '''April 4''': campaign ends
- [ ] DATE - Call with Nominees & Peers to make sure they understand accountability (Peers)
**Reps are given a week to read through candidate replies and watch their videos
- [ ] DATE - Q&A starts on Discourse (1 week) (@ioana-chiorean)
* '''April 11''': voting by all Reps who are eligible to vote begins - (voting closes after 72 hours)
- [ ] DATE - Deadline for answers in Discourse Q&A (@ioana-chiorean)
* '''April 15''': new elected members are announced and their term begins
- [ ] DATE - Voting starts (1 week) (@ioana-chiorean)
- [ ] DATE - Voting closes (@ioana-chiorean)
- [ ] DATE - Wiki Pages are updated (@MichaelKohler)
- [ ] DATE - Onboarding begins (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - New Council members have write access to GitHub Reps repo (@MichaelKohler)
- [ ] DATE - New Council members are in the reps_leadership p.m.o group (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - New Council members are in the Matrix channel (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - New Council members are in the reps-council Google Group to have access for documents (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - New Council members have access to Slack (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - Onboarding is done and new Council is operational - new council members have confirmed they all have access to everything (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - Outgoing Council members are removed from Matrix channel (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - Outgoing Council members are removed from reps_leadership (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - Outgoing Council members are removed from reps-council Google group (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - Community Portal is updated with new Council members in Council group (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - Blog announcement for new members + outgoing members is published (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - Mozilla Leadership Page is updated (@MichaelKohler)
</pre>


[[Category:Elections]]
[[Category:Elections]]

Latest revision as of 19:35, 29 September 2023

Warning signWarning: With effect from 1st September 2023, the Mozilla Reps program was closed and activities ended.

Overview

Every 6 months, 3 or 4 Mozilla Reps (depending on the election cycle) are elected to sit on the Mozilla Reps Council (aka ReMo Council or aka the "Jedi Council") for a 1 year term. The elections ensure that the program stays true to its core values of participation, accountability and transparency.

All Mozilla Reps Council members who are elected to the council agree to the following responsibilities and to be hold accountable by these criteria.

Election Rules

Voters

  • All active Mozilla Reps are eligible to exercise their right to vote.

Voting

  • Voting is done via (to be defined after decommissioning the Reps Portal) and each Rep can cast a vote only once per election.
  • The elections shall utilize Range Voting, where each voter will assign a score from 0 to N to each candidate (where N is the number of candidates). A voter abstains from voting by assigning a score of 0 to any number of candidates.
  • With the exception of the system administrators, no one shall be able to associate a Rep to a vote, thus voting is anonymous.
  • A Rep cannot, under any circumstance, use another Rep's account to vote. Any Rep found undermining the sanctity of the elections shall be removed from the program, after investigation by the Council.
  • Reps shall be given at least 72 hours to cast their vote after the elections have commenced. The length of the voting period is up to the Reps Peers to decide.
  • No vote shall be counted after the prescribed voting period.

Candidates

Only Mozilla Reps who have had experience mentoring (ie. being a Mentor or attended one of the Participation/Open innovation as invitees to Cohort's events are eligible to self-nominate themselves as candidates for a Council seat. After self-nomination, the Reps Peers will review the nominees' eligibility based on the following criteria:

  • General skills:
    • Proficiency in English
    • Availability for extra Council duties (eg. chairing, staff meetings, work weeks etc...)
    • Ability to travel (once or twice per term)
    • Take initiative on leading projects inside Reps
    • Be critical to help shape the volunteer strategy
    • Have a clear understanding of Mozilla’s current direction and goals
    • Have strategic thinking
    • Be able to communicate Reps mission and vision to the rest of the org and volunteers
    • Understand and be able to communicate Reps as the leading mobilizers program
    • Be able to articulate his/her opinion in strategic meetings
    • Have a strong background around the open web (and free software) movement
    • Expertise on the ground with local communities and grassroots efforts
    • Be recognized as a supportive leader inside the Mozilla community
    • Have existing relationships across the organization with both volunteers and employees
  • Nice to have:
    • Geographically spread

If, after the review of self-nominations period is finished, there are as many candidates as there are seats available on the Council, each candidate will be assigned a seat and no election will be held.

After the self-nominated Rep is cleared by the Peers, they will be officially announced as a candidate by the Reps Peers.

If a self-nominated Rep is not cleared by the Peers to run for election, they cannot appeal that decision.

Campaigning

  • Candidates are given 7 days to campaign and communicate their agenda, plans, achievements as a Rep/Mentor, and personal strengths, to the Mozilla Reps voting body.
  • Candidates can use Discourse, the public Reps communication channels, personal website/blog, a Mozilla Wiki page or any other public channel to post information regarding their candidacy. Messages in private are discouraged.
  • The set of questions that each candidate is required to answer can be found here. The Reps Peers create a Discourse topic to hold all candidate's answers in one place.
  • Use of Social Media shall be acceptable, provided posts are not private or targeted, deemed as spam, negative, nor detrimental to the election process and the Mozilla Reps program in general.
  • Any Candidate found campaigning in violation of aforementioned guidelines shall be disqualified after investigation by the Peers if elections have not yet started. If the candidate won a seat and is found to have violated the guidelines, the candidate will be be removed from the Council and replace with the candidate who was ranked just below after the range voting.
  • Mozilla Reps Council members cannot make public endorsements of candidates during the campaign period.

Campaign video

All candidates can produce a short campaign video if they wish to do so. This video can be uploaded to any online service and then be linked in the Discourse Q&A answer post every candidate needs to post.

Video is a great format to help give a human face to the election process. It also helps candidates tap into their creative side and connect with Reps on another level that's direct, genuine and a lot of fun. Through the video medium, Reps can get to know the candidates better, understand what they stand for and have a more personal connection with the candidates. There are no specific requirements as to what equipment or software you need to use, as long as the video is good enough quality so that your face is recognizable and your voice is understandable.

The video can last up to 2 minutes (120 seconds). If you submit a video that is longer, then the Peers reserve the right to remove it from your post until it fulfills this requirement.

Town Halls

During the Spring 2020 Council Elections we will experiment with running a full-day chat-based Ask-me-anything. You can find more information on Discourse.

Results

  • The three (or four) candidates (depending on the election cycle) who get highest number of votes shall be declared newly elected Council members.
  • If there are fewer elected candidates than the available number of Council seats, the Council will assign a provisional Council member who will sit on the Council for six months (ie. until the next election). The provisional Council member's seat will be vacated after the next elections.
  • In case of a tie that affects the outcome of the elections, the tie shall be broken by the following criteria:
    • The Rep with the least number of days spent as part of the Council shall be declared the winner. This is to ensure a good representation for the Council and giving all Mentors a chance to be part of the Council.
    • If there is a tie with the first criterion, the Peers shall deliberate based on the Candidate's track record as a Mentor, and the Peers shall break the tie by vote.

Appeals

A Candidate has 48 hours after elections results are made public to file an appeal to contest the results of the elections.

Election Schedule

The Election Schedule is adapted for public holidays and other events, therefore it is custom to every single election. You can find an example here: https://github.com/mozilla/Reps/issues/327

General template:

- [ ] DATE - Timeline presentation and announcement in Reps Call / Discourse / Mailing list (@ioana-chiorean)
- [ ] DATE - Call for Nominees starts (1 week) (@ioana-chiorean)
- [ ] DATE - Call for Nominees closes (@ioana-chiorean)
- [ ] DATE - Call with Nominees & Peers to make sure they understand accountability (Peers)
- [ ] DATE - Q&A starts on Discourse (1 week) (@ioana-chiorean)
- [ ] DATE - Deadline for answers in Discourse Q&A (@ioana-chiorean)
- [ ] DATE - Voting starts (1 week) (@ioana-chiorean)
- [ ] DATE - Voting closes (@ioana-chiorean)
- [ ] DATE - Wiki Pages are updated (@MichaelKohler)
- [ ] DATE - Onboarding begins (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - New Council members have write access to GitHub Reps repo (@MichaelKohler)
- [ ] DATE - New Council members are in the reps_leadership p.m.o group (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - New Council members are in the Matrix channel (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - New Council members are in the reps-council Google Group to have access for documents (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - New Council members have access to Slack (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - Onboarding is done and new Council is operational - new council members have confirmed they all have access to everything (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - Outgoing Council members are removed from Matrix channel (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - Outgoing Council members are removed from reps_leadership (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - Outgoing Council members are removed from reps-council Google group (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - Community Portal is updated with new Council members in Council group (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - Blog announcement for new members + outgoing members is published (@couci)
- [ ] DATE - Mozilla Leadership Page is updated (@MichaelKohler)