Add-ons/Reviewers/Guide/Unlisted: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(Updating to new system.) |
(Adding note on info requests and other resolutions) |
||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
# Pick an add-on to review. They should be prioritized by two factors: whether they have been reviewed before (see the Last Review column), and the percentage of sideloaded installs (this hasn't been implemented yet). | # Pick an add-on to review. They should be prioritized by two factors: whether they have been reviewed before (see the Last Review column), and the percentage of sideloaded installs (this hasn't been implemented yet). | ||
# Review the add-on. | # Review the add-on. | ||
# If there are no problems with the add-on, add a Comment indicating it's okay. This will update the Last Review column, telling other reviewers to pick something else. If there are problems, [https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/enter_bug.cgi?product=Toolkit&component=Blocklisting file a blocklist bug] or contact the amo-admins team. | # If there are no problems with the add-on, add a Comment indicating it's okay. This will update the Last Review column, telling other reviewers to pick something else. If there are problems, [https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/enter_bug.cgi?product=Toolkit&component=Blocklisting file a blocklist bug] or contact the amo-admins team. An Info Request can be sent if there are questions for the developer. The other resolutions aren't useful in this context. | ||
== What to look for == | == What to look for == | ||
Revision as of 17:33, 22 April 2016
Unlisted add-ons have Full or Preliminary approval levels, as explained here. However, an upcoming change will make that distinction pointless, after which all unlisted add-ons will get Full Review.
Post-review
All unlisted submissions are automatically approved. Our role is to go over the list of pre-approved add-ons and verify they are safe.
The review process works as follows:
- Go to the All Unlisted Add-ons list.
- Pick an add-on to review. They should be prioritized by two factors: whether they have been reviewed before (see the Last Review column), and the percentage of sideloaded installs (this hasn't been implemented yet).
- Review the add-on.
- If there are no problems with the add-on, add a Comment indicating it's okay. This will update the Last Review column, telling other reviewers to pick something else. If there are problems, file a blocklist bug or contact the amo-admins team. An Info Request can be sent if there are questions for the developer. The other resolutions aren't useful in this context.
What to look for
- Potentially malicious code or serious security problems.
- Remote code may be okay for content (coupon extensions) but definitely not for chrome (unless it's an iframe with type=content).
- CSP manipulation on sites like Facebook or online banking.
- Content policies don't apply to Unlisted add-ons. Adult material, gambling, copyrighted media downloads, etc. are not prohibited. There are also many unlisted add-ons that are forks or very close copies of other add-ons. They are allowed as well.