Accessibility/Video a11y Study08: Difference between revisions

Jump to navigation Jump to search
m
Line 113: Line 113:
One concern that has been raised with TDHT is that HTML may be too comprehensive a format for the needs of time-aligned text. Time-aligned text is predominantly text that should be stylable by the Website that is using it. HTML however is notoriously bad at separating data from styling, unless CSS is used exclusively. It may be better to create a format that is simlar to RSS than to HTML in its simplicity.
One concern that has been raised with TDHT is that HTML may be too comprehensive a format for the needs of time-aligned text. Time-aligned text is predominantly text that should be stylable by the Website that is using it. HTML however is notoriously bad at separating data from styling, unless CSS is used exclusively. It may be better to create a format that is simlar to RSS than to HTML in its simplicity.


TDHT and DFXP are the current solutions for out-of-band time-aligned text. Other options for such comprehensive time-aligned text solutions need to be analysed and experimented with.
TDHT and DFXP are solutions for out-of-band time-aligned text. Other options for such comprehensive time-aligned text solutions need to be analysed and experimented with.


'''Recommendation 4:''' WRT DFXP: analyse whether DFXP is capable of supporting all the identified text categories by creating a collection of test files. This will help understand the capabilities and limitations of DFXP better.
'''Recommendation 4:''' WRT DFXP: analyse whether DFXP is capable of supporting all the identified text categories by creating a collection of test files. This will help understand the capabilities and limitations of DFXP better.


'''Recommendation 5:''' WRT TDHT: create a collection of test files that show how to support the different text categories. Based on the requirements determined from creating this collection, decide upon a comprehensive format (e.g. TDHT) and implement support for it.
'''Recommendation 5:''' WRT TDHT: create a collection of test files that show how to support the different text categories. Based on the requirements determined from creating this collection, decide upon a comprehensive format (e.g. TDHT) and implement support for it.


=== 5. Dealing with In-line Time-aligned Text Codecs ===
=== 5. Dealing with In-line Time-aligned Text Codecs ===

Navigation menu