canmove, Confirmed users
2,854
edits
VCard4: Difference between revisions
reviewed thru section 6.6.6
(reviewed thru section 6.5.2) |
(reviewed thru section 6.6.6) |
||
| Line 468: | Line 468: | ||
=== section 6.6. Organizational Properties === | |||
6.6. Organizational Properties | |||
Minor typo in intro sentence. should be: | |||
These properties are concerned with information associated with characteristics of the organization or organizational units of the object that the vCard represents. | |||
=== section 6.6.1. TITLE === | |||
6.6.1. TITLE | |||
=== in | Seems fine, compatible with vCard3. | ||
=== section 6.6.2. ROLE === | |||
6.6.2. ROLE | |||
Seems fine, compatible with vCard3. | |||
=== section 6.6.3. LOGO === | |||
6.6.3. LOGO | |||
In practice this property has caused confusion with respect to the PHOTO property. Which should you use when? | |||
Also, why is this included in the Organizational Properties section rather than alongside PHOTO? | |||
If there is a more specific semantic to be applied, e.g. this is the LOGO for the organization that the person the vCard object represents works for, then that specific semantic should be explicitly mentioned. | |||
Recommend also providing an example with both LOGO and PHOTO that clearly demonstrates the proper/intended use of each. | |||
=== section 6.6.4. ORG === | |||
6.6.4. ORG | |||
Seems fine, compatible with vCard3. | |||
=== section 6.6.5. MEMBER === | |||
6.6.5. MEMBER | |||
Groups should not be in vCard but rather should be in another spec/schema. | |||
Recommend drop this property. | |||
=== section 6.6.6. RELATED === | |||
6.6.6. RELATED | |||
This is an interesting idea that merits exploration as an extension, not part of vCard core. | |||
Also, rather than inventing another taxonomy of relationship, consider simply re-using by reference the XFN 1.1 taxonomy: | |||
http://gmpg.org/xfn/11 | |||
And then proposing or adding support for additional terms on the XFN brainstorming page. | |||
http://microformats.org/wiki/xfn-brainstorming | |||
=== in progress review continues here ... === | |||
== related == | == related == | ||
* [[Standards]] | * [[Standards]] | ||