CA:GovernmentCAs: Difference between revisions

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 64: Line 64:


== Suggestions about what to do about Government CAs ==
== Suggestions about what to do about Government CAs ==
Suggestions to consider...
* Require CAs to use separate root certificates for the CA hierarchies that are for issuing certs to governments.


* Treat Government CAs like other CAs that provide the necessary documentation and audit statements to show compliance with Mozilla's CA Certificate Policy.
** Make a clear statement about what it means to have a root certificate in Mozilla's program.
*** What statements can truly be made about CAs in Mozilla's program.
*** Are we trying to protect users from being spied on by their governments?
*** Is inclusion in Mozilla's CA Certificate program an indicator that the CA is not evil?
*** What is out-of-scope; e.g. what are unreasonable assumptions for people to make about CAs in Mozilla's program.
*** Cannot protect anyone from governments using their power on their citizens, whether it is a government-owned CA or not.


* Restrict government roots to their TLDs
* Restrict government roots to their TLDs
Line 80: Line 77:
** {{bug|555701}}
** {{bug|555701}}


* Treat Government CAs like other CAs that provide the necessary documentation and audit statements to show compliance with Mozilla's CA Certificate Policy.
** Make a clear statement about what it means to have a root certificate in Mozilla's program.
*** What statements can truly be made about CAs in Mozilla's program.
*** Are we trying to protect users from being spied on by their governments?
*** Is inclusion in Mozilla's CA Certificate program an indicator that the CA is not evil?
*** What is out-of-scope; e.g. what are unreasonable assumptions for people to make about CAs in Mozilla's program.
*** Cannot protect anyone from governments using their power on their citizens, whether it is a government-owned CA or not.


== What Inclusion of a CA in Mozilla's Program Means ==
== What Inclusion of a CA in Mozilla's Program Means ==
Confirmed users, Administrators
5,526

edits

Navigation menu