Confirmed users
1,090
edits
Dajbelshaw (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
Dajbelshaw (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| Line 33: | Line 33: | ||
We’re talking about the web, the world’s largest public resource, the operating system of the future, and (we believe) one of the greatest drivers of happiness and human flourishing the world has ever seen.<sup>[[#Foot1|1]]</sup> | We’re talking about the web, the world’s largest public resource, the operating system of the future, and (we believe) one of the greatest drivers of happiness and human flourishing the world has ever seen.<sup>[[#Foot1|1]]</sup> | ||
The web is a system of interlinked documents and resources accessed via the internet. The internet can also be used to access email, Internet Relay Chat (IRC) and other non-web services, but for the purposes of this white paper we’re interested in the things that can be accessed and created via modern web browsers. Taking Leo, Martha and Abdullah as our examples, no matter what devices they choose to use, the web is accessible to them all. | <strong>The web is a system of interlinked documents and resources accessed via the internet.</strong> The internet can also be used to access email, Internet Relay Chat (IRC) and other non-web services, but for the purposes of this white paper we’re interested in the things that can be accessed and created via modern web browsers. Taking Leo, Martha and Abdullah as our examples, no matter what devices they choose to use, the web is accessible to them all. | ||
Literacy isn’t just about reading, but about writing too. When we think about literacies on the web it’s important to go beyond just the differences between paper and screen. Those differences, like the hypertextuality of the web, are certainly important. But mastering these differences does not automatically lead to ‘web literacies’. Being web literate means not only being able to read the web but also having the | Literacy isn’t just about reading, but about writing too. When we think about literacies on the web it’s important to go beyond just the differences between paper and screen. Those differences, like the <em>hypertextuality</em> of the web, are certainly important. But mastering these differences does not automatically lead to ‘web literacies’. <strong>Being web literate means not only being able to read the web but also having the ability to ‘write’ it.</strong> | ||
ability to ‘write’ it. | |||
Writing the web - creating pages, documents and multimedia assets - means understanding the building blocks of the web. As Mitchell Baker (Chairperson of Mozilla) says, we want to move beyond ‘elegant | Writing the web - creating pages, documents and multimedia assets - means understanding the building blocks of the web. As Mitchell Baker (Chairperson of Mozilla) says, we want to move beyond ‘elegant | ||
consumption’ towards creating a generation of Webmakers. We’re not talking about everyone becoming a fully-fledged programmer, but we do believe that everyone should have the skills, competencies and literacies to be able to tinker and | consumption’ towards creating a generation of <em>Webmakers</em>. <strong>We’re not talking about everyone becoming a fully-fledged programmer, but we do believe that everyone should have the skills, competencies and literacies to be able to tinker and make things with and on the web.</strong> This is what Martha, the teacher in our example above, wants to help her students learn. She wants them to be able to make parts of the web as well as consume them. | ||
Although a knowledge of the physical makeup of the internet is necessary at some level, we’re primarily interested in the web as accessed through a browser. We recognise that there are ‘Pre-Beginner’ skills such as | Although a knowledge of the physical makeup of the internet is necessary at some level, we’re primarily interested in the web as accessed through a browser. We recognise that there are ‘Pre-Beginner’ skills such as | ||
identifying a web browser’s address bar, using copy/paste functions, and entering the URL of a site directly (rather than searching). Likewise, there’s ‘Advanced’ skills such as code workflows and server-side technologies that go beyond what we’re talking about here. Both ‘Pre-Beginner’ and ‘Advanced’ skills are currently out of scope for this white paper. We’re focusing on the kinds of skills that Abdullah might | identifying a web browser’s address bar, using copy/paste functions, and entering the URL of a site directly (rather than searching). Likewise, there’s ‘Advanced’ skills such as code workflows and server-side technologies that go beyond what we’re talking about here. <strong>Both ‘Pre-Beginner’ and ‘Advanced’ skills are currently out of scope for this white paper.</strong> We’re focusing on the kinds of skills that Abdullah might | ||
teach at his weekend sessions, or Leo might learn at his weekly HTML classes. | teach at his weekend sessions, or Leo might learn at his weekly HTML classes. | ||
| Line 53: | Line 52: | ||
<cite>(Davidson, 2012)</cite></blockquote> | <cite>(Davidson, 2012)</cite></blockquote> | ||
As set out in the [https://www.mozilla.org/about/manifesto.en.html Mozilla Manifesto] we believe that the web is a resource to be protected; one to be co-created not merely co-consumed. To create things with and on the web means being able to both read and write it. In other words, to be web literate, “we must learn not just how to use programs but how to make them” (Rushkoff, 2010). | <strong>As set out in the [https://www.mozilla.org/about/manifesto.en.html Mozilla Manifesto] we believe that the web is a resource to be protected; one to be co-created not merely co-consumed.</strong> To create things with and on the web means being able to both read and write it. In other words, to be web literate, “we must learn not just how to use programs but how to make them” (Rushkoff, 2010). | ||
The web is becoming the world’s second language, and a vital 21st century skill. Digital literacy today is as important as reading, writing and arithmetic. Mozilla believes it’s crucial that people develop the skills they need to understand, shape and actively participate in that world, instead of just passively consuming it. | <strong>The web is becoming the world’s second language, and a vital 21st century skill.</strong> Digital literacy today is as important as reading, writing and arithmetic. Mozilla believes it’s crucial that people develop the skills they need to understand, shape and actively participate in that world, instead of just passively consuming it. | ||
We want to help create a web literate planet. We want to teach people about the web through the web, moving them from consuming it to making it as a means of self-expression. We want to create a generation of people who know how the web works and can remix it. We also want to empower educators, those who want to teach other people about the web. | <strong>We want to help create a web literate planet.</strong> We want to teach people about the web through the web, moving them from consuming it to making it as a means of self-expression. We want to create a generation of people who know how the web works and can remix it. We also want to empower educators, those who want to teach other people about the web. | ||
Mozilla’s work is underpinned by a philosophy that we learn best through doing and making. While our work is underpinned by the works of academics in related fields, we’re interested in practical action. We’re focused upon encouraging people to become experienced in writing parts of the web and participating in online communities. | <strong>Mozilla’s work is underpinned by a philosophy that we learn best through doing and making.</strong> While our work is underpinned by the works of academics in related fields, we’re interested in <em>practical action</em>. We’re focused upon encouraging people to become experienced in writing parts of the web and participating in online communities. | ||
Learning by making and tinkering is not a new idea, nor is our belief in interest-based pathways for learning. Both of these concepts are fundamental to the work of foundational thinkers such as Froebel, Montessori, Dewey, Thorndike, Vygotsky, Papert and Csikszentmihalyi (amongst many others). Learning theories such as Constructivism<span id="Foot2"><sup>2</sup> and Connectivism,<span id="Foot3"><sup>3</sup> influence our work around Web Literacies along with notions such as | Learning by making and tinkering is not a new idea, nor is our belief in interest-based pathways for learning. Both of these concepts are fundamental to the work of foundational thinkers such as Froebel, Montessori, Dewey, Thorndike, Vygotsky, Papert and Csikszentmihalyi (amongst many others). Learning theories such as Constructivism<span id="Foot2"><sup>2</sup> and Connectivism,<span id="Foot3"><sup>3</sup> influence our work around Web Literacies along with notions such as <em>Flow</em> states<span id="Foot4"><sup>4</sup> and the importance of a sense of play. | ||
We’re putting these learning theories into action through the Webmaker tools we’re creating but also through the badge system design accompanying our work in this area. Interest-based pathways through a series of (badged) challenges promote flow states through clear goals and immediate feedback. More about this can be found in the Webmaker badges section below. | We’re putting these learning theories into action through the Webmaker tools we’re creating but also through the badge system design accompanying our work in this area. Interest-based pathways through a series of (badged) challenges promote flow states through clear goals and immediate feedback. More about this can be found in the <strong>Webmaker badges</em> section below. | ||
<h2>What are web literacies?</h2> | <h2>What are web literacies?</h2> | ||
We’re currently working towards defining web literacies as part of our work around Mozilla Webmaker. We understand web literacies to be comprised of parts of digital literacies, media literacies, computational/algorithmic thinking and computer science. We’re also interested in newly-defined and emerging areas such as 'Hacker Literacies' (Santo, 2012). | <strong>We’re currently working towards defining web literacies as part of our work around Mozilla Webmaker.</strong> We understand web literacies to be comprised of parts of digital literacies, media literacies, computational/algorithmic thinking and computer science. We’re also interested in newly-defined and emerging areas such as 'Hacker Literacies' (Santo, 2012). | ||
http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8043/8122740067_7c4aac76bb_z.jpg | http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8043/8122740067_7c4aac76bb_z.jpg | ||
| Line 73: | Line 72: | ||
point for those who want to help create a generation of Webmakers, people who can ‘write’ as well as ‘read’ the web. | point for those who want to help create a generation of Webmakers, people who can ‘write’ as well as ‘read’ the web. | ||
We see there being three steps to Web Literacies. First come Web Skills such as searching and using URLs appropriately. Two or more Web Skills combine into Web Competencies that we could call, for example, 'Browser basics' or 'Search Engine basics'. These are bundles of Web Skills for a particular purpose 'assessed' via a lightweight peer review system. | We see there being three steps to Web Literacies. First come <strong>Web Skills</strong> such as searching and using URLs appropriately. Two or more Web Skills combine into <strong>Web Competencies</strong> that we could call, for example, 'Browser basics' or 'Search Engine basics'. These are bundles of Web Skills for a particular purpose 'assessed' via a lightweight peer review system. | ||
Finally, Web Literacies consist of a range of these Web Competencies - for example, 'Browser basics,' 'Search engine basics,' and 'Web mechanics'. In addition, some element of self-reflection is required here to realise that you’re now able to ‘Explore’ the web at a beginner level. | Finally, <strong>Web Literacies</strong> consist of a range of these Web Competencies - for example, 'Browser basics,' 'Search engine basics,' and 'Web mechanics'. In addition, some element of self-reflection is required here to realise that you’re now able to ‘Explore’ the web at a beginner level. | ||
http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8471/8122757190_f5b763b4e3_z.jpg | http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8471/8122757190_f5b763b4e3_z.jpg | ||
| Line 82: | Line 81: | ||
<h3>Web Skills</h3> | <h3>Web Skills</h3> | ||
By ‘skills’ we mean learned capacities to perform specific actions. Skills can be generic (transferable) or domain-specific. In terms of Web Skills the following may be helpful by way of illustration: a generic skill is understanding how code is structured; a domain-specific skill is how to use various elements of HTML (e.g. <p> and <h1> tags). In our earlier example, Leo learns both generic and domain-specific skills in his HTML classes. | <strong>By ‘skills’ we mean learned capacities to perform specific actions.</strong> Skills can be generic (transferable) or domain-specific. In terms of Web Skills the following may be helpful by way of illustration: a generic skill is understanding how code is structured; a domain-specific skill is how to use various elements of HTML (e.g. <p> and <h1> tags). In our earlier example, Leo learns both generic and domain-specific skills in his HTML classes. | ||
Teachers in formal education are well aware that skills have objective thresholds. That’s to say the skills they teach young people are assessed by third parties (such as exam boards) against some kind of rubric. In a similar way to Scouting badges, the learner has to prove they have particular learned capacities in a given area. Likewise, the Mozilla Webmaker badges we’re developing require learners to demonstrate such capacities as they ‘level-up’. | Teachers in formal education are well aware that skills have objective thresholds. That’s to say the skills they teach young people are assessed by third parties (such as exam boards) against some kind of rubric. In a similar way to Scouting badges, the learner has to prove they have particular learned capacities in a given area. Likewise, the Mozilla Webmaker badges we’re developing require learners to demonstrate such capacities as they ‘level-up’. | ||
| Line 89: | Line 88: | ||
<h3>Web Competencies</h3> | <h3>Web Competencies</h3> | ||
By ‘competencies’ we mean collections of skills for pre-defined purposes. Web Competencies are bundles of Web Skills that allow individuals to ‘level-up’ in their knowledge, skills and understanding. Abdullah, for example, is interested in showing progression through the workshops and sessions he provides through his nonprofit start-up. He might decide to focus on teaching the skills young people need to gain the Web | <strong>By ‘competencies’ we mean collections of skills for pre-defined purposes.</strong> Web Competencies are bundles of Web Skills that allow individuals to ‘level-up’ in their knowledge, skills and understanding. Abdullah, for example, is interested in showing progression through the workshops and sessions he provides through his nonprofit start-up. He might decide to focus on teaching the skills young people need to gain the <strong>Web design basics</strong> competency badge. | ||
Whether someone demonstrates a particular Web Competency depends on their displaying evidence of mastering certain Web Skills in that area. Building in an element of peer assessment at this stage ensures the evidence required stays fresh, current and relevant to what’s required to be effective on the web today. | Whether someone demonstrates a particular Web Competency depends on their displaying evidence of mastering certain Web Skills in that area. Building in an element of peer assessment at this stage ensures the evidence required stays fresh, current and relevant to what’s required to be effective on the web today. | ||
Returning to our learner scenarios, as Leo progresses in his knowledge, skills and understanding around HTML he realises he’s ready to submit some of his work for peer review. He places a mini-portfolio of his work | Returning to our learner scenarios, as Leo progresses in his knowledge, skills and understanding around HTML he realises he’s ready to submit some of his work for peer review. He places a mini-portfolio of his work | ||
online and asks the Webmaker community to look at it. Leo receives 13 up-votes and only 2 down-votes meaning he has received enough peer recognition to be awarded an HTML basics badge. | online and asks the Webmaker community to look at it. Leo receives 13 up-votes and only 2 down-votes meaning he has received enough peer recognition to be awarded an <strong>HTML basics</strong> badge. | ||
In the first instance the organisation awarding Webmaker badges will be Mozilla. As the ecosystem develops, however, we very much welcome and encourage other organisations to contribute tools, content and activities. These organisations will also be able to define the mix of skills that lead to competencies they wish to recognise and badge. Martha, for example, might want to tie the work she’s doing even more closely to the national curriculum or standards she is required to teach. | In the first instance the organisation awarding Webmaker badges will be Mozilla. As the ecosystem develops, however, we very much welcome and encourage other organisations to contribute tools, content and activities. These organisations will also be able to define the mix of skills that lead to competencies they wish to recognise and badge. Martha, for example, might want to tie the work she’s doing even more closely to the national curriculum or standards she is required to teach. | ||
<h3>Web Literacies</h3> | <h3>Web Literacies</h3> | ||
At it’s most basic, ‘literacy’ is the ability to read and write something. As we’re focusing on Web Literacies the ‘thing’ that we’re reading and writing is the web. In addition to this, however, as people become more literate we expect them to think critically and be able to look at the world from more than one perspective. For someone to be ‘literate’ they have to be aware that they are literate and be accepted within a wider community of literate peers. | <strong>At it’s most basic, ‘literacy’ is the ability to read and write something.</strong> As we’re focusing on Web Literacies the ‘thing’ that we’re reading and writing is the web. In addition to this, however, as people become more literate we expect them to think critically and be able to look at the world from more than one perspective. For someone to be ‘literate’ they have to be aware that they are literate and be accepted within a wider community of literate peers. | ||
Let’s take Leo as our example here. He continues attending his Monday HTML classes and starts tinkering with HTML and CSS at home as well. After a few months he gains Web Competencies badges in HTML basics, CSS basics and Web design basics. When a friend asks for help with a website she’s designing, Leo decides start an after-school interest group with her. Soon, he’s creating ‘howto’ videos for the benefit of those in his | Let’s take Leo as our example here. He continues attending his Monday HTML classes and starts tinkering with HTML and CSS at home as well. After a few months he gains Web Competencies badges in <strong>HTML basics</strong>, <strong>CSS basics</strong> and <strong>Web design basics</strong>. When a friend asks for help with a website she’s designing, Leo decides start an after-school interest group with her. Soon, he’s creating ‘howto’ videos for the benefit of those in his nascent community, whilst she’s working towards <strong>Javascript basics</strong> to be able to teach others. Teaching something you’ve recently learned yourself forces self-reflection on your own knowledge, skills and understanding. | ||
nascent community, whilst she’s working towards Javascript basics to be able to teach others. Teaching something you’ve recently learned yourself forces self-reflection on your own knowledge, skills and | |||
understanding. | |||
Literacy is a condition to be obtained not a threshold to cross. We want people not only to self-identify as Webmakers but demonstrate the knowledge, skills and understanding required to be part of one or more | <storng>Literacy is a condition to be obtained not a threshold to cross.</strong> We want people not only to self-identify as Webmakers but demonstrate the knowledge, skills and understanding required to be part of one or more | ||
web communities. We’re still in the process of defining the process by which individuals obtain Web Literacies badges, but they’ll contain both elements of peer assessment and self-reflection. | web communities. We’re still in the process of defining the process by which individuals obtain Web Literacies badges, but they’ll contain both elements of peer assessment and self-reflection. | ||
| Line 113: | Line 110: | ||
<ol> | <ol> | ||
<li>Exploring - I navigate the web while learning, questioning and evaluating what it has to offer.</li> | <li><strong>Exploring</strong> - I navigate the web while learning, questioning and evaluating what it has to offer.</li> | ||
<li>Creating - I create things with the web and solve problems while respecting the work of others.</li> | <li><strong>Creating</strong> - I create things with the web and solve problems while respecting the work of others.</li> | ||
<li>Connecting - I communicate and participate appropriately in one or more web communities.</li> | <li><strong>Connecting</strong> - I communicate and participate appropriately in one or more web communities.</li> | ||
<li>Protecting - I protect the web as a public resource for free expression.</li> | <li><strong>Protecting</strong> - I protect the web as a public resource for free expression.</li> | ||
</ol> | </ol> | ||
| Line 185: | Line 182: | ||
create with the web in ever-more powerful ways. They provide a way for Leo to demonstrate his learning, for Martha to motivate her students, and for Abdullah to provide structure to his weekend workshops. | create with the web in ever-more powerful ways. They provide a way for Leo to demonstrate his learning, for Martha to motivate her students, and for Abdullah to provide structure to his weekend workshops. | ||
An example of our thinking (still a work in progress) is the HTML basics badge. This is a Web Competency badge made up of a collection of Web Skills such as: | An example of our thinking (still a work in progress) is the <strong>HTML basics badge</strong>. This is a Web Competency badge made up of a collection of Web Skills such as: | ||
<ol> | <ol> | ||
| Line 202: | Line 199: | ||
</ol> | </ol> | ||
As we’re providing interest-based pathways the idea is that whilst a certain number of web skills would have to be gained to achieve the HTML basics badge, there’s no requirement to gain every skill. | As we’re providing <strong>interest-based pathways</strong> the idea is that whilst a certain number of web skills would have to be gained to achieve the <strong>HTML basics</strong> badge, there’s no requirement to gain every skill. | ||
An example of some interest-based pathways can be seen below. The coloured icons indicate badges that have been gained, with those that are greyed-out yet to be achieved. As indicated in a previous section, we envisage that ‘levelling-up’ to a Web Competency badge requires an element of peer-assessment. Levelling-up to one of the Web Literacies badges requires peer-assessment plus some kind of self-reflection. | An example of some interest-based pathways can be seen below. The coloured icons indicate badges that have been gained, with those that are greyed-out yet to be achieved. As indicated in a previous section, we envisage that ‘levelling-up’ to a Web Competency badge requires an element of peer-assessment. Levelling-up to one of the Web Literacies badges requires peer-assessment plus some kind of self-reflection. | ||
| Line 210: | Line 207: | ||
<h2>Conclusion</h2> | <h2>Conclusion</h2> | ||
We believe that everyone should have the skills, competencies and literacies to be constructive and creative on the web. Not everyone needs to be a fully-fledged programmer, nor does everyone want to be a web designer. However, given the pervasiveness of the web in our lives, everyone certainly needs to feel like it’s a medium to be written and made as well as one to be read and consumed. | We believe that everyone should have the skills, competencies and literacies to be constructive and creative on the web. Not everyone needs to be a fully-fledged programmer, nor does everyone want to be a web designer. However, given the pervasiveness of the web in our lives, everyone certainly needs to feel like it’s a medium to be <em>written</em> and <em>made</em> as well as one to be read and consumed. | ||
This Web Literacies white paper is the beginning of a conversation: we’re not attempting to create a ‘canon’ of knowledge or skills. Instead, we’re looking to create a flexible framework of Web Skills, Competencies and Literacies that can evolve along with the web itself. And we’d very much like it if you could join us in that journey. | This Web Literacies white paper is the beginning of a conversation: we’re not attempting to create a ‘canon’ of knowledge or skills. Instead, we’re looking to create a flexible framework of Web Skills, Competencies and Literacies that can evolve along with the web itself. And we’d very much like it if you could join us in that journey. | ||
| Line 250: | Line 235: | ||
Wing, J.M. (2008) ‘Computational Thinking and Thinking about Thinking,’ Philosophical Transactions of The Royal Society, 366, pp.3717-3725 | Wing, J.M. (2008) ‘Computational Thinking and Thinking about Thinking,’ Philosophical Transactions of The Royal Society, 366, pp.3717-3725 | ||
<h2>Footnotes</h2> | |||
<span id="Foot1"><sup>1</sup> See Mozillian Gervase Markham’s post: | |||
[http://blog.gerv.net/2012/07/mozilla-an-ethical-career http://blog.gerv.net/2012/07/mozilla-an-ethical-career]</span> | |||
<span id="Foot2"><sup>2</sup> Constructivism is, broadly speaking, a learning theory that focuses upon experiential learning, self-direction, creativity, first-hand experience. It posits learning as an active, social process.</span> | |||
<span id="Foot3"><sup>3</sup> Connectivism is a theory of learning that sees learning as a process of practice and reflection. It allows for knowledge to reside in non-human actors and sees learners as 'nodes on a network'.</span> | |||
<span id="Foot4"><sup>4</sup> A state of ‘Flow’ as defined by Csikszentmihalyi, includes an activity with clear goals, clear and immediate feedback, and with a good balance between (perceived) challenges and (perceived) skills.</span> | |||