Performance sheriffing/Talos/Tests

From MozillaWiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Contents

Talos Tests

Where to get this information

  • Talos tests are defined in test.py
  • Treeherder abbreviations are defined in talos.yml
  • Talos suites are configured for production in talos.json; these names are mapped to Treeherder via regexes: buildbot.py

Talos Test Types

There are two different species of Talos tests:

  • #Startup Tests : start up the browser and wait for either the load event or the paint event and exit, measuring the time
  • #Page Load Tests : load a manifest of pages

In addition we have some variations on existing tests:

  • #Heavy Tests: Run tests with the heavy user profile instead of a blank one
  • #Web Extension Tests: Run tests with a web extension to see the perf impact extension have

Some tests measure different things:

  • #Paint Tests: These measure events from the browser like moz_after_paint, etc.
  • #ASAP Tests: These tests go really fast and typically measure how many frames we can render in a time window
  • #Benchmarks: These are benchmarks that measure specific items and report a summarized score

Startup Tests

Startup tests launch Firefox and measure the time to the onload or paint events. We run this in a series of cycles (default to 20) to generate a full set of data. Tests that currently are startup tests are:

Page Load Tests

Many of the talos tests use the page loader to load a manifest of pages. These are tests that load a specific page and measure the time it takes to load the page, scroll the page, draw the page etc. In order to run a page load test, you need a manifest of pages to run. The manifest is simply a list of URLs of pages to load, separated by carriage returns, e.g.: 

https://www.mozilla.org
https://www.mozilla.com

Example: svgx.manifest

Manifests may also specify that a test computes its own data by prepending a % in front of the line: 

% https://www.mozilla.org
% https://www.mozilla.com

Example: v8.manifest

The file you created should be referenced in your test config inside of test.py. For example, open test.py, and look for the line referring to the test you want to run: 

tpmanifest = '${talos}/page_load_test/svgx/svgx.manifest'
tpcycles = 1 # run a single cycle
tppagecycles = 25 # load each page 25 times before moving onto the next page

Heavy Tests

All our testing is done with empty blank profiles, this is not ideal for finding issues for end users. We recently undertook a task to create a daily update to a profile so it is modern and relevant. It browses a variety of web pages, and have history and cache to give us a more realistic scenario.

The toolchain is documented on github and was added to Talos in bug 1407398.

Currently we have issues with this on windows (takes too long to unpack the files from the profile), so we have turned this off there. Our goal is to run this on basic pageload and startup tests.

Web Extension Tests

Web Extensions are what Firefox has switched to and there are different code paths and APIs used vs addons. Historically we don't test with addons (other than our test addons) and are missing out on common slowdowns. In 2017 we started running some startup and basic pageload tests with a web extension in the profile (bug 1398974). We have updated the Extension to be more real world and will continue to do that.

Paint Tests

Paint tests are measuring the time to receive both the MozAfterPaint and OnLoad event instead of just the OnLoad event. Most tests now look for this unless they are an ASAP test, or an internal benchmark

ASAP Tests

We have a variety of tests which we now run in ASAP mode where we render as fast as possible (disabling vsync and letting the rendering iterate as fast as it can using `requestAnimationFrame`). In fact we have replaced some original tests with the 'x' versions to make them measure. We do this with RequestAnimationFrame().

ASAP Tests are:

Benchmarks

Many tests have internal benchmarks which we report as accurately as possible. These are the exceptions to the general rule of calculating the suite score as a geometric mean of the subtest values (which are median values of the raw data from the subtests).

Tests which are imported benchmarks are:

Row Major vs. Column Major

To get more stable numbers, tests are run multiple times. There are two ways that we do this: row major and column major. Row major means each test is run multiple times and then we move to the next test (and run it multiple times). Column major means that each test is run once one after the other and then the whole sequence of tests is run again.

More background information about these approaches can be found in Joel Maher's Reducing the Noise in Talos blog post.

Page Sets

We run our tests 100% offline, but serve pages via a webserver. Knowing this we need to store and make available the offline pages we use for testing.

tp5pages

Some tests make use of a set of 50 "real world" pages, known as the tp5n set. These pages are not part of the talos repository, but without them the tests which use them won't run.

  • To add these pages to your local setup, download tp5n.zip, and extract it such that `tp5n` ends up as `testing/talos/talos/tests/tp5n`.
  • see also tp5 test.

tp6

the tp6 pageset archives are also stored in their raw html (non-mitmdump archive) format on github here. If you wish to debug with the pagesets outside of mitmproxy then just clone that repo and you'll find them in the /talos-pagesets/tp6 folder.

Talos Test Descriptions

Please keep these in alphabetical order

a11y

  • reporting: test time in ms (lower is better)
Talos test name Description
a11yr Row Major testing with 25 cycles per page

This test ensures basic a11y tables and permutations do not cause performance regressions.

Example data 
0;dhtml.html;1584;1637;1643;1665;1741;1529;1647;1645;1692;1647;1542;1750;1654;1649;1541;1656;1674;1645;1645;1740;1558;1652;1654;1656;1654
1;tablemutation.html;398;385;389;391;387;387;385;387;388;385;384;31746;386;387;384;387;389;387;387;387;388;391;386;387;388

about-preferences

  • contact: :jaws
  • source: [1]
  • type: PageLoader
  • measuring: first-non-blank-paint
  • data: We load 5 urls 1 time each, and repeat for 25 cycles; collecting 25 sets of 5 data points
  • summarization
  • reporting: test time in ms (lower is better)

This test measures the performance of the Firefox about:preferences page. This test is a little different than other pageload tests in that we are loading one page (about:preferences) but also testing the loading of that same page's subcategories/panels (i.e. about:preferences#home).

When simply changing the page's panel/category, that doesn't cause a new onload event as expected; therefore we had to introduce loading the 'about:blank' page in between each page category; that forces the entire page to reload with the specified category panel activated.

For that reason, when new panels/categories are added to the 'about:preferences' page, it can be expected that a performance regression may be introduced, even if a subtest hasn't been added for that new page category yet.

This test should only ever have 1 pagecycle consisting of the main about-preferences page and each category separated by an about:blank between. Then repeats are achieved by using 25 cycles (instead of pagecycles).

Example data 
0;preferences;346;141;143;150;136;143;153;140;154;156;143;154;146;147;151;166;140;146;140;144;144;156;154;150;140
2;preferences#search;164;142;133;141;141;141;142;140;131;146;131;140;131;131;139;142;140;144;146;143;143;142;142;137;143
3;preferences#privacy;179;159;166;177;173;153;148;154;168;155;164;155;152;157;149;155;156;186;149;156;160;151;158;168;157
4;preferences#sync;148;156;140;137;159;139;143;145;138;130;145;142;141;133;146;141;147;143;146;146;139;144;142;151;156
5;preferences#home;141;111;130;131;138;128;133;122;138;138;131;139;139;132;133;141;143;139;138;135;136;128;134;140;135

ARES-6

  • contact: :jandem
  • source: ARES-6
  • type: PageLoader
  • data: 6 cycles of the entire benchmark
  • Lower is better
  • unit: geometric mean / benchmark score

Basic Compositor Video

  • contact: :davidb
  • source: video
  • type: PageLoader
  • data: 12 cycles of the entire benchmark, each subtest will have 12 data points (see below)
  • summarization:
  • Lower is better
  • unit: ms/frame
Talos test name Description
basic_compositor_video
Example data 
;0;240p.120fps.mp4_scale_fullscreen_startup;11.112;11.071;11.196;11.157;11.195;11.240;11.196;11.155;11.237;11.074;11.154;11.282
;1;240p.120fps.mp4_scale_fullscreen_inclip;10.995;11.114;11.052;10.991;10.876;11.115;10.995;10.991;10.997;10.994;10.992;10.993
;2;240p.120fps.mp4_scale_1_startup;1.686;1.690;1.694;1.683;1.689;1.692;1.686;1.692;1.689;1.704;1.684;1.686
;3;240p.120fps.mp4_scale_1_inclip;1.666;1.666;1.666;1.668;1.667;1.669;1.667;1.668;1.668;1.667;1.667;1.669
;4;240p.120fps.mp4_scale_1.1_startup;1.677;1.672;1.673;1.677;1.673;1.677;1.672;1.677;1.677;1.671;1.676;1.679
;5;240p.120fps.mp4_scale_1.1_inclip;1.667;1.668;1.666;1.667;1.667;1.668;1.667;1.667;1.667;1.667;1.668;1.668
;6;240p.120fps.mp4_scale_2_startup;1.927;1.908;1.947;1.946;1.902;1.932;1.916;1.936;1.921;1.896;1.908;1.894
;7;240p.120fps.mp4_scale_2_inclip;1.911;1.901;1.896;1.917;1.897;1.921;1.907;1.944;1.904;1.912;1.936;1.913
;8;480p.60fps.webm_scale_fullscreen_startup;11.675;11.587;11.539;11.454;11.723;11.410;11.629;11.410;11.454;11.498;11.540;11.540
;9;480p.60fps.webm_scale_fullscreen_inclip;11.304;11.238;11.370;11.300;11.364;11.368;11.237;11.238;11.434;11.238;11.304;11.368
;10;480p.60fps.webm_scale_1_startup;3.386;3.360;3.391;3.376;3.387;3.402;3.371;3.371;3.356;3.383;3.376;3.356
;11;480p.60fps.webm_scale_1_inclip;3.334;3.334;3.329;3.334;3.334;3.334;3.334;3.334;3.334;3.335;3.334;3.334
;12;480p.60fps.webm_scale_1.1_startup;3.363;3.363;3.368;3.356;3.356;3.379;3.364;3.360;3.360;3.356;3.363;3.356
;13;480p.60fps.webm_scale_1.1_inclip;3.329;3.334;3.329;3.334;3.333;3.334;3.334;3.334;3.340;3.335;3.329;3.335
;14;480p.60fps.webm_scale_2_startup;4.960;4.880;4.847;4.959;4.802;4.863;4.824;4.926;4.847;4.785;4.870;4.855
;15;480p.60fps.webm_scale_2_inclip;4.903;4.786;4.892;4.903;4.822;4.832;4.798;4.857;4.808;4.856;4.926;4.741
;16;1080p.60fps.mp4_scale_fullscreen_startup;14.638;14.495;14.496;14.710;14.781;14.853;14.639;14.637;14.707;14.637;14.711;14.636
;17;1080p.60fps.mp4_scale_fullscreen_inclip;13.795;13.798;13.893;13.702;13.799;13.607;13.798;13.705;13.896;13.896;13.896;14.088
;18;1080p.60fps.mp4_scale_1_startup;6.995;6.851;6.930;6.820;6.915;6.805;6.898;6.866;6.852;6.850;6.803;6.851
;19;1080p.60fps.mp4_scale_1_inclip;6.560;6.625;6.713;6.601;6.645;6.496;6.624;6.538;6.539;6.497;6.580;6.558
;20;1080p.60fps.mp4_scale_1.1_startup;7.354;7.230;7.195;7.300;7.266;7.283;7.196;7.249;7.230;7.230;7.212;7.264
;21;1080p.60fps.mp4_scale_1.1_inclip;6.969;7.222;7.018;6.993;7.045;6.970;6.970;6.807;7.118;6.969;6.997;6.972
;22;1080p.60fps.mp4_scale_2_startup;6.963;6.947;6.914;6.929;6.979;7.010;7.010245327102808;6.914;6.961;7.028;7.012;6.914
;23;1080p.60fps.mp4_scale_2_inclip;6.757;6.694;6.672;6.669;6.737;6.831;6.716;6.715;6.832;6.670;6.672;6.759

perf-reftest

  • contact: :bholley
  • source: perf-reftest
  • type: PageLoader
  • reporting: intervals in ms (lower is better)
  • data: each test loads 25 times
  • summarization:

Important note: This test now requires an 'opt' build. If the perf-reftest is ran on a non-opt build, it will timeout (more specifically on innertext-1.html, and possibly others in the future).

Style system performance test suite. The perf-reftest suite is a unique talos suite where each subtest loads two different test pages: a 'base' page (i.e. bloom_basic) and a 'reference' page (i.e. bloom_basic_ref), and then compares each of the page load times against eachother to determine the variance.

Talos runs each of the two pages as if they are stand-alone tests, and then calculates and reports the variance; the test output 'replicates' reported from bloom_basic are actually the comparisons between the 'base' and 'reference' pages for each page load cycle. The suite contains multiple subtests, each of which contains a base page and a reference page.

If you wish to see the individual 'base' and 'reference' page results instead of just the reported difference, the 'base_replicates' and 'ref_replicates' can be found in the PERFHERDER_DATA log file output, and in the 'local.json' talos output file when running talos locally. In production, both of the page replicates are also archived in the perfherder-data.json file. The perfherder-data.json file is archived after each run in production, and can be found on the Treeherder Job Details tab when the perf-reftest job symbol is selected.

This test suite was ported over from the style-perf-tests (https://github.com/heycam/style-perf-tests).

Example data 
"replicates": [1.185, 1.69, 1.22, 0.36, 11.26, 3.835, 3.315, 1.355, 3.185, 2.485, 2.2, 1.01, 0.9, 1.22, 1.9,
0.285, 1.52, 0.31, 2.58, 0.725, 2.31, 2.67, 3.295, 1.57, 0.3], "value": 1.7349999999999999, "unit": "ms",

"base_replicates": [166.94000000000003, 165.16, 165.64000000000001, 165.04000000000002, 167.355, 165.175,
165.325, 165.11, 164.175, 164.78, 165.555, 165.885, 166.83499999999998, 165.76500000000001, 164.375, 166.825,
167.13, 166.425, 169.22500000000002, 164.955, 165.335, 164.45000000000002, 164.85500000000002, 165.005, 166.035]}],

"ref_replicates": [165.755, 166.85000000000002, 166.85999999999999, 165.4, 178.615, 169.01, 168.64, 166.465,
167.36, 167.265, 167.75500000000002, 166.895, 167.735, 166.985, 166.275, 166.54000000000002, 165.61, 166.115,
166.64499999999998, 165.68, 167.64499999999998, 167.12, 168.15, 166.575, 166.335],

perf-reftest-singletons

Individual style system performance tests. The perf-reftest-singletons suite runs the perf-reftest 'base' pages (i.e. bloom_basic) test individually, and reports the values for that single test page alone, NOT the comparison of two different pages. There are multiple subtests in this suite, each just containing the base page on its own.

This test suite was ported over from the style-perf-tests (https://github.com/heycam/style-perf-tests).

Example data 
bloombasic.html;88.34000000000003;88.66499999999999;94.815;92.60500000000002;95.30000000000001;
98.80000000000001;91.975;87.73500000000001;86.925;86.965;93.00500000000001;98.93;87.45000000000002;
87.14500000000001;92.78500000000001;86.96499999999999;98.32000000000001;97.485;90.67000000000002;
86.72500000000001;95.665;100.67;101.095;94.32;91.87

cpstartup

  • contact: :mconley
  • measuring: Time from opening a new tab (which creates a new content process) to having that new content process be ready to load URLs.
  • source: cpstartup
  • type: PageLoader
  • bug: bug 1336389
  • data: 20 cycles of the entire benchmark
  • Lower is better
  • unit: ms
Example data 
0;content-process-startup;877;737;687;688;802;697;794;685;694;688;794;669;699;684;690;849;687;873;694;689

DAMP

  • contact: :ochameau
  • source: damp
  • type: PageLoader
  • measuring: Developer Tools toolbox startup, shutdown, and reload performance
  • reporting: intervals in ms (lower is better) - see below for details
  • data: there are 36 reported subtests from DAMP which we load 25 times, resulting in 36 sets of 25 data points.
  • summarization:

To run this locally, you'll need to pull down the tp5 page set and run it in a local web server. See the tp5 section or contact jmaher for more information.

Example data 
0;simple.webconsole.open.DAMP;1198.86;354.38;314.44;337.32;344.73;339.05;345.55;358.37;314.89;353.73;324.02;339.45;304.63;335.50;316.69;341.05;353.45;353.73;342.28;344.63;357.62;375.18;326.08;363.10;357.30
1;simple.webconsole.reload.DAMP;44.60;41.21;25.62;29.85;38.10;42.29;38.25;40.14;26.95;39.24;40.32;34.67;34.64;44.88;32.51;42.09;28.04;43.05;40.62;36.56;42.44;44.11;38.69;29.10;42.00
2;simple.webconsole.close.DAMP;27.26;26.97;25.45;27.82;25.98;26.05;38.00;26.89;24.90;26.61;24.90;27.22;26.95;25.18;24.24;25.60;28.91;26.90;25.57;26.04;26.79;27.33;25.76;26.47;27.43
3;simple.inspector.open.DAMP;507.80;442.03;424.93;444.62;412.94;451.18;441.39;435.83;441.27;460.69;440.93;413.13;418.73;443.41;413.93;447.34;434.69;459.24;453.60;412.58;445.41;466.34;441.89;417.59;428.82
4;simple.inspector.reload.DAMP;169.45;165.11;163.93;181.12;167.86;164.67;170.34;173.12;165.24;180.59;176.72;187.42;170.14;190.35;176.59;155.00;151.66;174.40;169.46;163.85;190.93;217.00;186.25;181.31;161.13
5;simple.inspector.close.DAMP;44.40;42.28;42.71;47.21;41.74;41.24;42.94;43.73;48.24;43.04;48.61;42.49;45.93;41.36;43.83;42.43;41.81;43.93;41.38;40.98;49.76;50.86;43.49;48.99;44.02
6;simple.jsdebugger.open.DAMP;642.59;464.02;540.62;445.46;471.09;466.57;466.70;511.91;424.12;480.70;448.37;477.51;488.99;437.97;442.32;459.03;421.54;467.99;472.78;440.27;431.47;454.76;436.86;453.61;485.59
7;simple.jsdebugger.reload.DAMP;51.65;55.46;225.46;53.32;58.78;53.23;54.39;51.59;55.46;48.03;50.70;46.34;230.94;53.71;54.23;53.01;61.03;51.23;51.45;293.01;56.93;51.44;59.85;63.35;57.44
8;simple.jsdebugger.close.DAMP;29.12;30.76;40.34;32.09;31.26;32.30;33.95;31.89;29.68;31.39;32.09;30.36;44.63;32.33;30.16;32.43;30.89;30.85;31.99;49.86;30.94;44.63;32.54;29.79;33.15
9;simple.styleeditor.open.DAMP;758.54;896.93;821.17;1026.24;887.14;867.39;927.86;962.80;740.40;919.39;741.01;925.21;807.39;1051.47;729.04;1095.78;755.03;888.70;900.52;810.30;1090.09;869.72;737.44;893.16;927.72
10;simple.styleeditor.reload.DAMP;57.32;178.13;59.23;60.82;71.45;78.86;74.35;60.11;66.43;77.41;61.96;69.22;65.97;45.53;67.88;74.76;124.61;60.01;36.66;59.24;65.01;165.68;34.61;69.02;71.42
11;simple.styleeditor.close.DAMP;28.28;56.50;36.18;30.00;36.32;34.85;35.33;36.24;25.45;36.72;26.53;36.90;28.88;30.94;26.56;31.34;47.79;30.90;30.52;27.95;30.75;56.28;26.76;30.25;37.42
12;simple.performance.open.DAMP;444.28;357.87;331.17;335.16;585.71;402.99;504.58;466.95;272.98;427.54;345.60;441.53;319.99;327.91;312.94;349.79;399.51;465.60;418.42;295.14;362.06;363.11;445.71;634.96;500.83
13;simple.performance.reload.DAMP;38.07;33.44;35.99;70.57;64.04;106.47;148.31;29.60;68.47;28.95;148.46;75.92;32.15;93.72;36.17;44.13;75.11;154.76;98.28;75.16;29.39;36.68;113.16;64.05;135.60
14;simple.performance.close.DAMP;23.98;25.49;24.19;24.61;27.56;40.33;33.85;25.13;22.62;25.28;41.84;25.09;26.39;25.20;23.76;25.44;25.92;30.40;40.77;25.41;24.57;26.15;43.65;28.54;30.16
15;simple.netmonitor.open.DAMP;438.85;350.64;318.04;329.12;341.91;352.33;344.05;334.15;514.57;327.95;471.50;334.55;344.94;364.39;727.56;374.48;339.45;344.31;345.61;329.78;325.74;334.74;350.36;342.85;344.64
16;simple.netmonitor.reload.DAMP;59.68;47.50;69.37;61.18;76.89;83.22;68.11;81.24;56.15;68.20;32.41;81.22;81.62;44.30;39.52;29.60;86.07;71.18;76.32;79.93;79.63;82.15;83.58;87.04;82.97
17;simple.netmonitor.close.DAMP;38.42;39.32;52.56;43.37;48.08;40.62;51.12;41.11;59.54;43.29;41.72;40.85;51.61;49.61;51.39;44.91;40.36;41.10;45.43;42.15;42.63;40.69;41.21;44.04;41.95
18;complicated.webconsole.open.DAMP;589.97;505.93;480.71;530.93;460.60;479.63;485.33;489.08;605.28;457.12;463.95;493.28;680.05;478.72;504.47;578.69;488.66;485.34;504.94;460.67;548.38;474.98;470.33;471.34;464.58
19;complicated.webconsole.reload.DAMP;2707.20;2700.17;2596.02;2728.09;2905.51;2716.65;2657.68;2707.74;2567.86;2726.36;2650.92;2839.14;2620.34;2718.36;2595.22;2686.28;2703.48;2609.75;2686.41;2577.93;2634.47;2745.56;2655.89;2540.09;2649.18
20;complicated.webconsole.close.DAMP;623.56;570.80;636.63;502.49;565.83;537.93;525.46;565.78;532.90;562.66;525.42;490.88;611.99;486.45;528.60;505.35;480.55;500.75;532.75;480.91;488.69;548.77;535.31;477.92;519.84
21;complicated.inspector.open.DAMP;1233.26;753.57;742.74;953.11;653.29;692.66;653.75;767.02;840.68;707.56;713.95;685.79;690.21;1020.47;685.67;721.69;1063.72;695.55;702.15;760.91;853.14;660.12;729.16;1044.86;724.34
22;complicated.inspector.reload.DAMP;2384.90;2436.35;2356.11;2436.58;2372.96;2558.86;2543.76;2351.03;2411.95;2358.04;2413.27;2339.85;2373.11;2338.94;2418.88;2360.87;2349.09;2498.96;2577.73;2445.07;2354.88;2424.90;2696.10;2362.39;2493.29
23;complicated.inspector.close.DAMP;541.96;509.38;476.91;456.48;545.48;634.04;603.10;488.09;599.20;480.45;617.93;420.39;514.92;439.99;727.41;469.04;458.59;539.74;611.55;725.03;473.36;484.60;481.46;458.93;554.76
24;complicated.jsdebugger.open.DAMP;644.97;578.41;542.23;595.94;704.80;603.08;689.18;552.99;597.23;584.17;682.14;758.16;791.71;738.43;640.30;809.26;704.85;601.32;696.10;683.44;796.34;657.25;631.89;739.96;641.82
25;complicated.jsdebugger.reload.DAMP;2676.82;2650.84;2687.78;2401.23;3421.32;2450.91;2464.13;2286.40;2399.40;2415.97;2481.48;2827.69;2652.03;2554.63;2631.36;2443.83;2564.73;2466.22;2597.57;2552.73;2539.42;2481.21;2319.50;2539.00;2576.43
26;complicated.jsdebugger.close.DAMP;795.68;616.48;598.88;536.77;435.02;635.61;558.67;841.64;613.48;886.60;581.38;580.96;571.40;605.34;671.00;882.02;619.01;579.63;643.05;656.78;699.64;928.99;549.76;560.96;676.32
27;complicated.styleeditor.open.DAMP;2327.30;2494.19;2190.29;2205.60;2198.11;2509.01;2189.79;2532.05;2178.03;2207.75;2224.96;2665.84;2294.40;2645.44;2661.41;2364.60;2395.36;2582.72;2872.03;2679.29;2561.24;2330.11;2580.16;2510.36;2860.83
28;complicated.styleeditor.reload.DAMP;2218.46;2335.18;2284.20;2345.05;2286.98;2453.47;2506.97;2661.19;2529.51;2289.78;2564.15;2608.24;2270.77;2362.17;2287.31;2300.19;2331.56;2300.86;2239.27;2231.33;2476.14;2286.28;2583.24;2540.29;2259.67
29;complicated.styleeditor.close.DAMP;302.67;343.10;313.15;305.60;317.92;328.44;350.70;370.12;339.77;308.72;312.71;320.63;305.52;316.69;324.92;306.60;313.65;312.17;326.26;321.45;334.56;307.38;312.95;350.94;339.36
30;complicated.performance.open.DAMP;477.99;537.96;564.85;515.05;502.03;515.58;492.80;689.06;448.76;588.91;509.76;485.39;548.17;479.14;638.67;535.86;541.61;611.52;554.72;665.37;694.04;470.60;746.16;547.85;700.02
31;complicated.performance.reload.DAMP;2258.31;2345.74;2509.24;2579.71;2367.94;2365.94;2260.86;2324.23;2579.01;2412.63;2540.38;2069.80;2534.91;2443.48;2193.01;2442.99;2422.42;2475.35;2076.48;2092.95;2444.53;2353.86;2154.28;2354.61;2104.82
32;complicated.performance.close.DAMP;334.44;516.66;432.49;341.29;309.30;365.20;332.16;311.42;370.81;301.81;381.13;299.39;317.60;314.10;372.44;314.76;306.24;349.85;382.08;352.53;309.40;298.44;314.10;315.44;405.22
33;complicated.netmonitor.open.DAMP;469.70;597.87;468.36;823.09;696.39;477.19;487.78;495.92;587.89;471.48;555.02;507.45;883.33;522.15;756.86;713.64;593.82;715.13;477.15;717.85;586.79;556.97;631.43;629.55;581.16
34;complicated.netmonitor.reload.DAMP;4033.55;3577.36;3655.61;3721.24;3874.29;3977.92;3778.62;3825.60;3984.65;3707.91;3985.24;3565.21;3702.40;3956.70;3627.14;3916.11;3929.11;3934.06;3590.60;3628.39;3618.84;3579.52;3953.04;3781.01;3682.69
35;complicated.netmonitor.close.DAMP;1042.98;920.21;928.19;940.38;950.25;1043.61;1078.16;1077.38;1132.91;1095.05;1176.31;1256.83;1143.14;1234.61;1248.97;1242.29;1378.63;1312.74;1371.48;1373.15;1544.55;1422.51;1549.48;1616.55;1506.58

displaylist_mutate

This measures the amount of time it takes to render a page after changing its display list. The page has a large number of display list items (10,000), and mutates one every frame. The goal of the test is to make displaylist construction a bottleneck, rather than painting or other factors, and thus improvements or regressions to displaylist construction will be visible. The test runs in ASAP mode to maximize framerate, and the result is how quickly the test was able to mutate and re-paint 600 items, one during each frame.

Dromaeo Tests

Dromaeo suite of tests for JavaScript performance testing. See the Dromaeo wiki for more information.

This suite is divided into several sub-suites.

Each sub-suite is divided into tests, and each test is divided into sub-tests. Each sub-test takes some (in theory) fixed piece of work and measures how many times that piece of work can be performed in one second. The score for a test is then the geometric mean of the runs/second numbers for its sub-tests. The score for a sub-suite is the geometric mean of the scores for its tests.

Dromaeo CSS

  • contact: :bz
  • source: css.manifest
  • type: PageLoader
  • reporting: speed in test runs per second (higher is better)
  • data: Dromaeo has 6 subtests which run internal benchmarks, each benchmark reports about 180 raw data points each

summarization:

  • subtest: Dromaeo is a custom benchmark which has a lot of micro tests inside each subtest, because of this we use a custom dromaeo filter to summarize the subtest. Each micro test produces 5 data points and for each 5 data points we take the mean, leaving 36 data points to represent the subtest (assuming 180 points). These 36 micro test means, are then run through a geometric_mean to produce a single number for the dromaeo subtest. source: filter.py

Each page in the manifest is part of the dromaeo css benchmark. Each page measures the performance of searching the DOM for nodes matching various CSS selectors, using different libraries for the selector implementation (jQuery, Dojo, Mootools, ExtJS, Prototype, and Yahoo UI).

Example data 
0;dojo.html;2209.83;2269.68;2275.47;2278.83;2279.81;4224.43;4344.96;4346.74;4428.69;4459.82;4392.80;4396.38;4412.54;4414.34;4415.62;3909.94;4027.96;4069.08;4099.63;4099.94;4017.70;4018.96;4054.25;4068.74;4081.31;3825.10;3984.20;4053.23;4074.59;4106.63;3893.88;3971.80;4031.15;4046.68;4048.31;3978.24;4010.16;4046.66;4051.68;4056.37;4189.50;4287.98;4390.98;4449.89;4450.20;4536.23;4557.82;4588.40;4662.58;4664.42;4675.51;4693.13;4743.72;4758.12;4764.67;4138.00;4251.60;4346.22;4410.12;4417.23;4677.53;4702.48;4714.62;4802.59;4805.33;4445.07;4539.91;4598.93;4605.45;4618.79;4434.40;4543.09;4618.56;4683.98;4689.51;4485.26;4496.75;4511.23;4600.86;4602.08;4567.52;4608.33;4615.56;4619.31;4622.79;3469.44;3544.11;3605.80;3647.74;3658.56;3101.88;3126.41;3147.73;3159.92;3170.73;3672.28;3686.40;3730.74;3748.89;3753.59;4411.71;4521.50;4633.98;4702.72;4708.76;3626.62;3646.71;3713.07;3713.13;3718.91;3846.17;3846.25;3913.61;3914.63;3916.22;3982.88;4112.98;4132.26;4194.92;4201.54;4472.64;4575.22;4644.74;4645.42;4665.51;4120.13;4142.88;4171.29;4208.43;4211.03;4405.36;4517.89;4537.50;4637.77;4644.28;4548.25;4581.20;4614.54;4658.42;4671.09;4452.78;4460.09;4494.06;4521.30;4522.37;4252.81;4350.72;4364.93;4441.40;4492.78;4251.34;4346.70;4355.00;4358.89;4365.72;4494.64;4511.03;4582.11;4591.79;4592.36;4207.54;4308.94;4309.14;4406.71;4474.46
1;ext.html;479.65;486.21;489.61;492.94;495.81;24454.14;33580.33;34089.15;34182.83;34186.15;34690.83;35050.30;35051.30;35071.65;35099.82;5758.22;5872.32;6389.62;6525.38;6555.57;8303.96;8532.96;8540.91;8544.00;8571.49;8360.79;8408.79;8432.96;8447.28;8447.83;5817.71;5932.67;8371.83;8389.20;8643.44;7983.80;8073.27;8073.84;8076.48;8078.15;24596.00;32518.84;32787.34;32830.51;32861.00;2220.87;2853.84;3333.53;3345.17;3445.47;24785.75;24971.75;25044.25;25707.61;25799.00;2464.69;2481.89;2527.57;2534.65;2534.92;217793.00;219347.90;219495.00;220059.00;297168.00;40556.19;53062.47;54275.73;54276.00;54440.37;50636.75;50833.49;50983.49;51028.49;51032.74;10746.36;10972.45;11450.37;11692.18;11797.76;8402.58;8415.79;8418.66;8426.75;8428.16;16768.75;16896.00;16925.24;16945.58;17018.15;7047.68;7263.13;7313.16;7337.38;7383.22;713.88;723.72;751.47;861.35;931.00;25454.36;25644.90;25801.87;25992.61;25995.00;819.89;851.23;852.00;886.59;909.89;14325.79;15064.92;15240.39;15431.23;15510.61;452382.00;458194.00;458707.00;459226.00;459601.00;45699.54;46244.54;46270.54;46271.54;46319.00;1073.94;1080.66;1083.35;1085.84;1087.74;26622.33;27807.58;27856.72;28040.58;28217.86;37229.81;37683.81;37710.81;37746.62;37749.81;220386.00;222903.00;240808.00;247394.00;247578.00;25567.00;25568.49;25610.74;25650.74;25710.23;26466.21;28718.71;36175.64;36529.27;36556.00;26676.00;30757.69;31965.84;34521.83;34622.65;32791.18;32884.00;33194.83;33720.16;34192.66;32150.36;32520.02;32851.18;32947.18;33128.01;29472.85;30214.09;30708.54;30999.23;32879.51;23822.88;23978.28;24358.88;24470.88;24515.51
2;jquery.html;285.42;288.57;292.66;293.75;294.14;10313.00;10688.20;13659.11;13968.65;14003.93;13488.39;13967.51;13980.79;14545.13;15059.77;4361.37;4488.35;4489.44;4492.24;4496.69;3314.32;3445.07;4412.51;5020.75;5216.66;5113.49;5136.56;5141.31;5143.87;5156.28;5055.95;5135.02;5138.64;5215.82;5226.48;4550.98;4551.59;4553.07;4557.77;4559.16;18339.63;18731.53;18738.63;18741.16;18806.15;1474.99;1538.31;1557.52;1703.67;1772.16;12209.94;12335.44;12358.32;12516.50;12651.94;1520.94;1522.62;1541.37;1584.71;1642.50;57533.00;59169.41;59436.11;59758.70;59872.40;8669.13;8789.34;8994.37;9016.05;9064.95;11047.39;11058.39;11063.78;11077.89;11082.78;6401.81;6426.26;6504.35;6518.25;6529.61;6250.22;6280.65;6304.59;6318.91;6328.72;5144.28;5228.40;5236.21;5271.26;5273.79;1398.91;1450.05;1456.39;1494.66;1519.42;727.85;766.62;844.35;858.49;904.87;9912.55;10249.54;14936.71;16566.50;16685.00;378.04;381.34;381.44;385.67;387.23;5362.60;5392.78;5397.14;5497.12;5514.83;213309.00;318297.00;320682.00;322681.00;322707.00;56357.44;67892.66;68329.66;68463.32;69506.00;418.91;424.49;425.19;425.28;426.40;9363.39;9559.95;9644.00;9737.07;9752.80;33170.83;33677.33;34950.83;35607.47;35765.82;44079.34;44588.55;45396.00;46309.00;46427.30;6302.87;6586.51;6607.08;6637.44;6642.17;9776.17;9790.46;9931.90;10391.79;10392.43;8739.26;8838.38;8870.20;8911.50;8955.15;8422.83;8786.21;8914.00;9135.82;9145.36;8945.28;9028.37;9035.23;9116.64;9137.86;6433.90;6688.73;6822.11;6830.08;6833.90;8575.23;8599.87;8610.91;8655.65;9123.91
3;mootools.html;1161.69;1333.31;1425.89;1500.37;1557.37;6706.93;7648.46;8020.04;8031.36;8049.64;7861.80;7972.40;7978.12;7993.32;7993.88;1838.83;1862.93;1864.11;1866.28;1866.71;1909.93;1921.83;1928.53;1954.07;1969.98;1808.68;1820.01;1821.30;1825.92;1826.91;1849.07;1904.99;1908.26;1911.24;1912.50;1856.86;1871.78;1873.72;1878.54;1929.57;6506.67;6752.73;7799.22;7830.41;7855.18;4117.18;4262.42;4267.30;4268.27;4269.62;2720.56;2795.36;2840.08;2840.79;2842.62;699.12;703.75;774.36;791.73;798.18;11096.22;11126.39;11132.72;11147.16;11157.44;3934.33;4067.37;4140.94;4149.75;4150.38;9042.82;9077.46;9083.55;9084.41;9086.41;4431.47;4432.84;4437.33;4438.40;4440.44;3935.67;3937.31;3937.43;3940.53;3976.68;3247.17;3307.90;3319.90;3323.32;3330.60;1001.90;1016.87;1021.12;1021.67;1022.05;1016.34;1019.09;1036.62;1056.81;1057.76;7345.56;7348.56;7391.89;7393.85;7406.30;374.27;392.53;394.73;397.28;398.26;5588.58;5653.21;5655.07;5659.15;5660.66;9775.41;9860.51;9938.40;9959.85;9968.45;9733.42;9904.31;9953.05;9960.55;9967.20;6399.26;6580.11;7245.93;7336.96;7386.78;7162.00;7245.49;7249.38;7250.75;7304.63;8458.24;8583.40;8651.57;8717.39;8742.39;8896.42;8904.60;8927.96;8960.73;8961.82;7483.48;7747.77;7763.46;7766.34;7773.07;7784.00;7821.41;7827.18;7849.18;7855.49;7012.16;7141.57;7250.09;7253.13;7335.89;6977.97;7015.51;7042.40;7204.35;7237.20;7160.46;7293.23;7321.27;7321.82;7331.16;6268.69;6324.11;6325.78;6328.56;6342.40;6554.54;6625.30;6646.00;6650.30;6674.90
4;prototype.html;237.05;251.94;256.61;259.65;263.52;4488.53;4676.88;4745.24;4745.50;4748.81;4648.47;4660.21;4666.58;4671.88;4677.32;3602.84;3611.40;3613.69;3615.69;3619.15;3604.41;3619.44;3623.24;3627.66;3628.11;3526.59;3589.35;3615.93;3616.35;3622.80;3624.69;3626.84;3628.47;3631.22;3632.15;3184.76;3186.11;3187.16;3187.78;3189.35;4353.43;4466.46;4482.57;4616.72;4617.88;4012.18;4034.84;4047.07;4047.82;4055.29;4815.11;4815.21;4816.11;4817.08;4820.40;3300.31;3345.18;3369.55;3420.98;3447.97;5026.99;5033.82;5034.50;5034.95;5038.97;3516.72;3520.79;3520.95;3521.81;3523.47;3565.29;3574.23;3574.37;3575.82;3578.37;4045.19;4053.51;4056.76;4058.76;4059.00;4714.67;4868.66;4869.66;4873.54;4878.29;1278.20;1300.92;1301.13;1301.17;1302.47;868.94;871.16;878.50;883.40;884.85;3874.71;3878.44;3881.61;3882.67;3886.92;4959.83;4968.45;4969.50;4971.38;4972.30;3862.69;3870.15;3871.79;3873.83;3878.07;2690.15;2711.66;2714.42;2715.39;2715.89;4349.04;4349.63;4351.33;4353.59;4355.46;4950.95;5101.08;5107.69;5120.21;5120.39;4336.63;4360.76;4361.96;4362.28;4365.43;4928.75;4939.41;4939.56;4943.95;4966.78;4869.03;4886.24;4888.85;4889.14;4895.76;4362.39;4362.78;4363.96;4365.00;4365.08;3408.00;3470.03;3476.37;3546.65;3547.34;4905.73;4926.21;4926.70;4926.93;4929.43;4682.88;4694.91;4696.30;4697.06;4699.69;4688.86;4691.25;4691.46;4698.37;4699.41;4628.07;4631.31;4633.42;4634.00;4636.00;4699.44;4796.02;4808.83;4809.95;4813.52;4719.10;4720.41;4722.95;4723.03;4723.53
5;yui.html;569.72;602.22;627.02;647.49;692.84;9978.30;10117.54;10121.70;10129.75;10137.24;9278.68;9291.44;9349.00;9370.53;9375.86;475.79;481.92;606.51;607.42;618.73;617.68;618.89;623.30;626.58;631.85;501.81;649.76;653.22;655.69;656.71;510.62;645.56;657.42;657.88;658.39;475.53;476.77;476.80;476.92;476.96;9895.16;9976.15;9988.25;9989.85;9996.40;9483.15;9545.75;9676.37;9808.51;10360.22;8331.29;8397.87;8538.06;8714.69;8803.78;2748.93;2800.93;2802.59;2857.33;2864.46;33757.16;33804.83;33859.32;33931.00;33991.32;7818.65;7846.92;7892.09;8170.55;8217.75;13691.38;13692.86;13693.25;13698.73;13706.66;5378.70;5517.83;5615.86;5616.16;5624.00;2985.63;3002.97;3003.07;3037.73;3038.87;2459.10;2502.52;2504.91;2507.07;2507.26;396.62;405.78;411.43;412.03;412.56;543.45;550.75;568.50;578.59;592.25;6762.21;6901.72;6984.27;7064.22;7122.29;454.78;519.40;539.29;543.96;566.16;3235.39;3266.13;3453.26;3498.79;3518.54;39079.22;39722.80;41350.59;41422.38;41540.17;34435.14;34606.31;34623.31;34661.00;34672.48;29449.12;29530.11;30507.24;31938.52;31961.52;7449.33;7524.62;7629.73;7712.96;7796.42;22917.43;23319.00;23441.41;23582.88;23583.53;29780.40;30272.55;31761.00;31765.84;31839.36;6112.45;6218.35;6476.68;6603.54;6793.66;10385.79;10471.69;10518.53;10552.74;10644.95;9563.52;9571.33;9617.09;9946.35;9976.80;9406.11;9518.48;9806.46;10102.44;10173.19;9482.43;9550.28;9878.21;9902.90;9951.45;8343.17;8511.00;8606.00;8750.21;8869.29;8234.96;8462.70;8473.49;8499.58;8808.91

Dromaeo DOM (Linux64 only)

  • contact: :bz
  • source: dom.manifest
  • type: PageLoader
  • data: see Dromaeo DOM
  • reporting: speed in test runs per second (higher is better)

Each page in the manifest is part of the dromaeo dom benchmark. These are the specific areas that Dromaeo DOM covers:

DOM Attributes

Measures performance of getting and setting a DOM attribute, both via getAttribute and via a reflecting DOM property. Also throws in some expando getting/setting for good measure.

DOM Modification

Measures performance of various things that modify the DOM tree: creating element and text nodes and inserting them into the DOM.

DOM Query

Measures performance of various methods of looking for nodes in the DOM: getElementById, getElementsByTagName, and so forth.

DOM Traversal

Measures performance of various accessors (childNodes, firstChild, etc) that would be used when doing a walk over the DOM tree.

Please see Dromaeo CSS for examples of data.

glterrain

  • contact: :jgilbert
  • source: glterrain
  • type: PageLoader
  • data: we load the perftest.html page (which generates 4 metrics to track) 25 times, resulting in 4 sets of 25 data points
  • summarization:
Talos test name Description
glterrain Measures average frames interval while animating a simple WebGL scene

This tests animates a simple WebGL scene (static textured landscape, one moving light source, rotating viewport) and measure the frames throughput (expressed as average interval) over 100 frames. It runs in ASAP mode (vsync off) and measures the same scene 4 times - for all combination of antialiasing and alpha. It reports the results as 4 values - one for each combination. Lower results are better.

Example data 
0;0.WebGL-terrain-alpha-no-AA-no;19.8189;20.57185;20.5069;21.09645;20.40045;20.89025;20.34285;20.8525;20.45845;20.6499;19.94505;20.05285;20.316049;19.46745;19.46135;20.63865;20.4789;19.97015;19.9546;20.40365;20.74385;20.828649;20.78295;20.51685;20.97069
1;1.WebGL-terrain-alpha-no-AA-yes;23.0464;23.5234;23.34595;23.40609;22.54349;22.0554;22.7933;23.00685;23.023649;22.51255;23.25975;23.65819;22.572249;22.9195;22.44325;22.95015;23.3567;23.02089;22.1459;23.04545;23.09235;23.40855;23.3296;23.18849;23.273249
2;2.WebGL-terrain-alpha-yes-AA-no;24.01795;23.889449;24.2683;24.34649;23.0562;24.02275;23.54819;24.1874;23.93545;23.53629;23.305149;23.62459;24.01589;24.06405;24.143449;23.998549;24.08205;24.26989;24.0736;24.2346;24.01145;23.7817;23.90785;24.7118;24.2834
3;3.WebGL-terrain-alpha-yes-AA-yes;25.91375;25.87005;25.64875;25.15615;25.5475;24.497449;24.56385;25.57529;25.54889;26.31559;24.143949;25.09895;24.75049;25.2087;25.52385;25.9017;25.4439;24.3495;25.9269;25.734449;26.4126;25.547449;25.667249;25.679349;25.9565

glvideo

  • Lower is better
  • unit: ms/100 ticks
Talos test name Description
glvideo WebGL video texture update with 1080p video. Measures mean tick time across 100 ticks.
Example data 
0;Mean tick time across 100 ticks: ;54.6916;49.0534;51.21645;51.239650000000005;52.44295

This test playbacks a video file and ask WebGL to draw video frames as WebGL textures for 100 ticks. It collects the mean tick time across 100 ticks to measure how much time it will spend for a video texture upload to be a WebGL texture (gl.texImage2D). We run it for 5 times and ignore the first found. Lower results are better.

jetstream

  • contact: :jandem
  • source: [jetstream.manifest] and jetstream.zip from tooltool
  • type: PageLoader
  • measuring: JavaScript performance
  • reporting: geometric mean from the benchmark
  • data: internal benchmark

This is the JetStream javascript benchmark taken verbatim and slightly modified to fit into our pageloader extension and talos harness.

kraken

  • contact: :sdetar
  • source: [kraken.manifest]
  • type: PageLoader
  • measuring: JavaScript performance
  • reporting: Total time for all tests, in ms (lower is better)
  • data: there are 14 subtests in kraken, each subtest is an internal benchmark and generates 10 data points, or 14 sets of 10 data points.
  • summarization:
    • subtest: For all of the 10 data points, we take the mean to report a single number.
    • suite: geometric mean of the 14 subtest results.

This is the Kraken javascript benchmark taken verbatim and slightly modified to fit into our pageloader extension and talos harness.

Example data 
0;ai-astar;100;95;98;102;101;99;97;98;98;102
1;audio-beat-detection;147;147;191;173;145;139;186;143;183;140
2;audio-dft;161;156;158;157;160;158;160;160;159;158
3;audio-fft;82;83;83;154;83;83;82;83;160;82
4;audio-oscillator;96;96;141;95;95;95;129;96;95;134
5;imaging-gaussian-blur;116;115;116;115;115;115;115;115;117;116
6;imaging-darkroom;166;164;166;165;166;166;165;165;165;166
7;imaging-desaturate;87;87;87;87;88;87;88;87;87;87
8;json-parse-financial;75;77;77;76;77;76;77;76;77;77
9;json-stringify-tinderbox;79;79;80;79;78;79;79;78;79;79
10;stanford-crypto-aes;98;97;96;98;98;98;98;98;113;95
11;stanford-crypto-ccm;130;138;130;127;137;134;134;132;147;129
12;stanford-crypto-pbkdf2;176;187;183;183;176;174;181;187;175;173
13;stanford-crypto-sha256-iterative;86;85;83;84;86;85;85;86;83;83

motionmark

  • contact: :davidb
  • source: [source] [manifests]
  • type: PageLoader
  • measuring: benchmark measuring the time to animate complex scenes
  • summarization:
    • subtest: FPS from the subtest, each subtest is run for 15 seconds, repeat this 5 times and report the median value
    • suite: we take a geometric mean of all the subtests (9 for animometer, 11 for html suite)

rasterflood_svg

This page animates some complex SVG patterns in a requestAnimationFrame callback. However, it also churns the CPU during each callback, spinning an empty loop for 14ms each frame. The intent is that, if we consider the rasterization costs to be 0, then the animation should run close to 60fps. Otherwise it will lag. Since rasterization costs are not 0, the lower we can get them, the faster the test will run. The test runs in ASAP mode to maximize framerate. The result is how quickly the browser is able to render 600 frames of the animation.

Improvements (or regressions) to general painting performance or SVG are likely to affect this benchmark.

rasterflood_gradient

This page animates some complex gradient patterns in a requestAnimationFrame callback. However, it also churns the CPU during each callback, spinning an empty loop for 14ms each frame. The intent is that, if we consider the rasterization costs to be 0, then the animation should run close to 60fps. Otherwise it will lag. Since rasterization costs are not 0, the lower we can get them, the faster the test will run. The test runs in ASAP mode to maximize framerate.

The test runs for 10 seconds, and the resulting score is how many frames we were able to render during that time. Higher is better. Improvements (or regressions) to general painting performance or gradient rendering will affect this benchmark.

sessionrestore/sessionrestore_no_auto_restore/sessionrestore_many_windows

  • contact: :mikedeboer, :mconley, :felipe
  • source: talos/sessionrestore
  • bug: bug 936630, bug 1331937, bug 1531520
  • type: Startup
  • measuring: time spent reading and restoring the session.
  • reporting: interval in ms (lower is better).
  • data: we load the session restore index page 10 times to collect 1 set of 10 data points.
  • summarization:

Three tests measure the time spent reading and restoring the session from a valid sessionstore.js. Time is counted from the process start until the sessionRestored event.

In sessionrestore, this is tested with a configuration that requires the session to be restored. In sessionrestore_no_auto_restore, this is tested with a configuration that requires the session to not be restored. Both of the above tests use a sessionstore.js file that contains one window and roughly 89 tabs. In sessionrestore_many_windows, this is tested with a sessionstore.js that contains 3 windows and 130 tabs. The first window contains 50 tabs, 80 remaning tabs are divided equally between the second and the third window.

Example data 
[2362.0, 2147.0, 2171.0, 2134.0, 2116.0, 2145.0, 2141.0, 2141.0, 2136.0, 2080.0]

speedometer

  • contact: :selena
  • source: speedometer.manifest
  • type: PageLoader
  • measuring: responsiveness of web applications
  • reporting: runs/minute score
  • data: there are 16 subtests in Speedometer; each of these are made up of 9 internal benchmarks.
  • summarization:
    • subtest: For all of the 16 subtests, we collect the sum of all their internal benchmark results.
    • suite: geometric mean of the 16 sums

This is the Speedometer javascript benchmark taken verbatim and slightly modified to fit into our pageloader extension and talos harness.

Example data 
0;VanillaJS-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Sync;153.055;150.4950000000008;149.16500000000087;150.8000000000029;150.92499999998836;147.53000000000003;154.8199999999997;156.20000000000437;147.0749999999971;150.47500000000582;151.63;158.02000000000044;145.54499999999825;156.3050000000003;146.7100000000064;147.505;148.5699999999979;148.9350000000013;147.61000000000058;146.41999999999825;149.64;151.875;189.75500000000466;147.04499999999825;151.0350000000035
1;VanillaJS-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Async;29.99000000000001;17.80500000000029;27.924999999995634;44.51000000000204;23.229999999995925;33.84500000000003;22.600000000000364;60.93999999999505;45.669999999998254;17.235000000000582;22.125;54.36499999999796;69.95000000000437;16.56500000000233;16.52499999999418;26.65500000000003;31.31000000000131;40.7300000000032;18.455000000001746;34.945000000006985;25.029999999999973;28.229999999999563;20.709999999999127;15.940000000002328;15.960000000006403
2;VanillaJS-TodoMVC/Adding100Items;183.04500000000002;168.3000000000011;177.0899999999965;195.31000000000495;174.15499999998428;181.37500000000006;177.42000000000007;217.13999999999942;192.74499999999534;167.7100000000064;173.755;212.3849999999984;215.49500000000262;172.87000000000262;163.23500000000058;174.16000000000003;179.8799999999992;189.6650000000045;166.06500000000233;181.36500000000524;174.66999999999996;180.10499999999956;210.46500000000378;162.98500000000058;166.9950000000099
3;VanillaJS-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Sync;50.01500000000004;50.154999999998836;45.95499999999447;49.95499999999447;49.345000000001164;46.67500000000001;48.17000000000007;50.075000000004366;49.6050000000032;47.5;49.20999999999998;49.86499999999796;45.79000000000087;48.45999999999913;47.27499999999418;46.964999999999975;51.279999999998836;56.42000000000553;47.49000000000524;47.09000000001106;47.66999999999996;46.97999999999956;150.63000000000466;46.42500000000291;46.06500000000233
4;VanillaJS-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Async;15.05499999999995;20.144999999998618;8.50499999999738;14.57499999999709;16.014999999999418;20.524999999999977;42.18000000000029;16.62000000000262;16.735000000000582;18.305000000007567;18.670000000000016;10.06499999999869;15.57999999999447;20.24500000000262;25.460000000006403;20.364999999999952;21.18500000000131;16.310000000004948;21.584999999999127;10.729999999995925;27.314999999999998;28.56499999999869;24.595000000001164;18.9800000000032;14.94999999999709
5;VanillaJS-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems;65.07;70.29999999999745;54.45999999999185;64.52999999999156;65.36000000000058;67.19999999999999;90.35000000000036;66.69500000000698;66.34000000000378;65.80500000000757;67.88;59.92999999999665;61.36999999999534;68.70500000000175;72.73500000000058;67.32999999999993;72.46500000000015;72.73000000001048;69.07500000000437;57.820000000006985;74.98499999999996;75.54499999999825;175.22500000000582;65.40500000000611;61.01499999999942
6;VanillaJS-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems/Sync;46.02499999999998;34.530000000000655;31.715000000003783;34.575000000004366;38.93000000000757;43.485000000000014;33.00500000000102;44.59499999999389;34.38500000000204;33.10000000000582;37.875;34.594999999997526;33.169999999998254;34.974999999998545;35.61999999999534;35.89500000000004;36.159999999999854;38.654999999998836;33.770000000004075;34.904999999998836;42.299999999999955;36.13999999999942;32.56999999999971;37.970000000001164;33.69499999999243
7;VanillaJS-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems/Async;15.475000000000023;11.94000000000051;17.70499999999447;20.19000000000233;9.509999999994761;7.425000000000011;14.040000000000873;10.104999999995925;13.430000000000291;11.985000000000582;6.984999999999957;23.75500000000102;63.45999999999913;8.014999999999418;12.059999999997672;21.40500000000003;13.279999999998836;11.364999999997963;7.864999999997963;33.154999999998836;12.420000000000016;22.409999999999854;8.090000000003783;12.994999999995343;7.125
8;VanillaJS-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems;61.5;46.470000000001164;49.419999999998254;54.765000000006694;48.44000000000233;50.910000000000025;47.04500000000189;54.699999999989814;47.81500000000233;45.0850000000064;44.85999999999996;58.349999999998545;96.62999999999738;42.98999999999796;47.679999999993015;57.30000000000007;49.43999999999869;50.0199999999968;41.63500000000204;68.05999999999767;54.71999999999997;58.54999999999927;40.66000000000349;50.96499999999651;40.81999999999243
9;VanillaJS-TodoMVC;309.615;285.0699999999997;280.9699999999866;314.6050000000032;287.9549999999872;299.48500000000007;314.8150000000023;338.5349999999962;306.90000000000146;278.6000000000204;286.49499999999995;330.6649999999936;373.49499999999534;284.5650000000023;283.6499999999942;298.79;301.78499999999804;312.4150000000118;276.77500000000873;307.2450000000099;304.3749999999999;314.1999999999971;426.3500000000131;279.3550000000032;268.83000000000175
10;Vanilla-ES2015-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Sync;187.5;191.14999999999782;198.6999999999971;196.77500000000146;193.25;192.91499999999996;197.4350000000013;194.09999999999854;193.60499999999593;195.09500000000116;197.52000000000004;200.14500000000044;241.61499999999796;193.61999999999534;191.75500000000466;193.32000000000005;195.8100000000013;200.0699999999997;192.95000000000437;475.40499999999884;192.67999999999995;196.77000000000044;197.66500000000087;194.8550000000032;197.4250000000029
11;Vanilla-ES2015-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Async;22.949999999999932;15.715000000000146;18.2300000000032;30.5199999999968;21.53499999998894;23.80499999999995;34.409999999999854;16.494999999995343;21.619999999995343;19.130000000004657;21.230000000000018;17.354999999999563;22.25;16.18000000000029;21.02499999999418;16.92999999999995;16.280000000002474;19.965000000003783;27.185000000004948;18.630000000004657;27.039999999999964;17.125;16.510000000002037;22.06999999999971;19.514999999999418
12;Vanilla-ES2015-TodoMVC/Adding100Items;210.44999999999993;206.86499999999796;216.9300000000003;227.29499999999825;214.78499999998894;216.7199999999999;231.84500000000116;210.5949999999939;215.22499999999127;214.22500000000582;218.75000000000006;217.5;263.86499999999796;209.79999999999563;212.77999999999884;210.25;212.09000000000378;220.0350000000035;220.1350000000093;494.0350000000035;219.7199999999999;213.89500000000044;214.1750000000029;216.9250000000029;216.94000000000233
13;Vanilla-ES2015-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Sync;54.25999999999999;50.36999999999898;55.58999999999651;52.38500000000204;56.31500000000233;52.174999999999955;50.875;50.349999999998545;56.61000000000058;51.570000000006985;52.495000000000005;50.13000000000102;62.71999999999389;51.18000000000029;53.44999999999709;51.29499999999996;50.66500000000087;87.94000000000233;52.83999999999651;60.330000000001746;51.69500000000005;50.80500000000029;52.70999999999913;54.79000000000087;54.13999999999942
14;Vanilla-ES2015-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Async;27.379999999999995;17.260000000002037;32.075000000004366;11.264999999999418;23.94999999999709;17.154999999999973;13.764999999999418;15.525000000001455;19.63499999999476;16.214999999996508;25.055000000000064;20.340000000000146;22.485000000000582;18.849999999998545;21.829999999987194;16.75999999999999;18.82999999999811;23.034999999996217;19.775000000001455;24.289999999993597;33.664999999999964;18.400000000001455;27.7699999999968;18.450000000004366;17.855000000010477
15;Vanilla-ES2015-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems;81.63999999999999;67.63000000000102;87.66500000000087;63.650000000001455;80.26499999999942;69.32999999999993;64.63999999999942;65.875;76.24499999999534;67.78500000000349;77.55000000000007;70.47000000000116;85.20499999999447;70.02999999999884;75.27999999998428;68.05499999999995;69.49499999999898;110.97499999999854;72.61499999999796;84.61999999999534;85.36000000000001;69.20500000000175;80.47999999999593;73.24000000000524;71.9950000000099
16;Vanilla-ES2015-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Sync;34.174999999999955;42.539999999997235;36.05500000000029;36.06500000000233;47.629999999990105;41.799999999999955;35.669999999998254;45.78500000000349;35.50499999999738;45.53500000000349;39.504999999999995;34.61000000000058;49.24500000000262;44.79500000000553;41.169999999998254;43.86500000000001;35.275000000001455;48.044999999998254;41.51000000000204;44.86500000000524;40.72000000000003;35.04000000000087;35.51499999999942;35.62999999999738;39.90000000000873
17;Vanilla-ES2015-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Async;10.754999999999995;12.934999999997672;12.819999999999709;10.430000000000291;13.205000000001746;14.090000000000032;39.77000000000044;12.014999999999418;12.299999999995634;7.349999999991269;13.724999999999909;11.579999999998108;13.019999999996799;7.219999999993888;14.464999999996508;13.370000000000005;7.424999999999272;7.0350000000034925;11.20499999999447;11.330000000001746;20.844999999999914;6.985000000000582;9.305000000000291;7.255000000004657;12.240000000005239
18;Vanilla-ES2015-TodoMVC/DeletingItems;44.92999999999995;55.47499999999491;48.875;46.49500000000262;60.83499999999185;55.889999999999986;75.43999999999869;57.80000000000291;47.804999999993015;52.88499999999476;53.229999999999905;46.18999999999869;62.26499999999942;52.01499999999942;55.63499999999476;57.235000000000014;42.70000000000073;55.080000000001746;52.71499999999651;56.195000000006985;61.56499999999994;42.025000000001455;44.81999999999971;42.88500000000204;52.14000000001397
19;Vanilla-ES2015-TodoMVC;337.01999999999987;329.9699999999939;353.47000000000116;337.4400000000023;355.8849999999802;341.9399999999998;371.9249999999993;334.2699999999968;339.2749999999796;334.8950000000041;349.53000000000003;334.15999999999985;411.33499999999185;331.8449999999939;343.6949999999779;335.53999999999996;324.2850000000035;386.0900000000038;345.4650000000038;634.8500000000058;366.64499999999987;325.12500000000364;339.47499999999854;333.0500000000102;341.0750000000262
20;Vanilla-ES2015-Babel-Webpack-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Sync;186.9849999999999;192.72999999999956;196.3249999999971;198.64500000000407;204.4100000000035;195.62;357.52999999999884;201.65000000000146;191.4300000000003;199.69500000000698;199.63;200.86000000000058;274.52999999999884;210.28499999999622;196.20500000000175;194.58000000000004;192.73499999999694;212.0550000000003;204.0699999999997;223.20500000000175;196.0999999999999;194.08000000000175;198.52000000000407;224.71500000000378;191.57000000000698
21;Vanilla-ES2015-Babel-Webpack-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Async;19.97499999999991;16.31499999999869;22.955000000001746;27.419999999998254;16.214999999996508;26.11999999999989;16.2300000000032;23.294999999998254;25.089999999996508;19.769999999989523;25.125;20.020000000000437;30.464999999996508;22.110000000000582;16.944999999992433;17.940000000000055;22.455000000001746;25.614999999997963;25.155000000006112;30.044999999998254;33.51499999999987;17.349999999998545;16.6050000000032;18.30500000000029;28.964999999996508
22;Vanilla-ES2015-Babel-Webpack-TodoMVC/Adding100Items;206.9599999999998;209.04499999999825;219.27999999999884;226.06500000000233;220.625;221.7399999999999;373.76000000000204;224.9449999999997;216.5199999999968;219.4649999999965;224.755;220.88000000000102;304.99499999999534;232.3949999999968;213.14999999999418;212.5200000000001;215.1899999999987;237.66999999999825;229.22500000000582;253.25;229.61499999999978;211.4300000000003;215.12500000000728;243.02000000000407;220.5350000000035
23;Vanilla-ES2015-Babel-Webpack-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Sync;52.31000000000017;51.87000000000262;54.81999999999971;60.59499999999389;107.30499999999302;60.569999999999936;59.724999999998545;62.32499999999709;52.86999999999534;52.17499999998836;65.69999999999982;54.22999999999956;56.705000000001746;86.8900000000067;60.57499999999709;53.044999999999845;54.87999999999738;52.54000000000087;61.580000000001746;149.7399999999907;56.49000000000001;53.3650000000016;53.224999999998545;70.97000000000116;51.845000000001164
24;Vanilla-ES2015-Babel-Webpack-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Async;17.24000000000001;18.75;16.349999999998545;9.584999999999127;22.639999999999418;10.330000000000155;13.540000000000873;17.80500000000029;15.205000000001746;17.789999999993597;19.37000000000012;21.68500000000131;9.959999999999127;16.854999999995925;31.464999999996508;18.829999999999927;17.92000000000189;17.344999999993888;18.2699999999968;17.110000000000582;21.3900000000001;27.0099999999984;19.364999999997963;19.924999999995634;18.964999999996508
25;Vanilla-ES2015-Babel-Webpack-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems;69.55000000000018;70.62000000000262;71.16999999999825;70.17999999999302;129.94499999999243;70.90000000000009;73.26499999999942;80.12999999999738;68.07499999999709;69.96499999998196;85.06999999999994;75.91500000000087;66.66500000000087;103.74500000000262;92.0399999999936;71.87499999999977;72.79999999999927;69.88499999999476;79.84999999999854;166.84999999999127;77.88000000000011;80.375;72.58999999999651;90.8949999999968;70.80999999999767
26;Vanilla-ES2015-Babel-Webpack-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Sync;41.649999999999864;48.38999999999942;39.984999999993306;36.25500000000466;44.76499999999942;43.409999999999854;41.56999999999971;35.03500000000349;36.43000000000029;40.05500000000757;41.25;41.08499999999913;40.86000000000058;80.55500000000029;47.75999999999476;37.92000000000007;35.22999999999956;66.125;38.7100000000064;38.48500000000058;46.309999999999945;40.19500000000335;39.7300000000032;36.674999999995634;38.05000000000291
27;Vanilla-ES2015-Babel-Webpack-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Async;12.345000000000027;13.670000000001892;12.884999999994761;14.830000000001746;11.220000000001164;9.495000000000118;11.325000000000728;7.55000000000291;9.055000000000291;7.069999999992433;11.184999999999945;14.785000000003492;25.885000000002037;7.165000000000873;16.36500000000524;9.680000000000064;6.805000000000291;6.870000000002619;13.439999999995052;12.884999999994761;13.634999999999991;11.994999999998981;11.334999999999127;23.784999999996217;12.620000000009895
28;Vanilla-ES2015-Babel-Webpack-TodoMVC/DeletingItems;53.99499999999989;62.06000000000131;52.86999999998807;51.0850000000064;55.98500000000058;52.90499999999997;52.89500000000044;42.5850000000064;45.48500000000058;47.125;52.434999999999945;55.87000000000262;66.74500000000262;87.72000000000116;64.125;47.600000000000136;42.034999999999854;72.99500000000262;52.150000000001455;51.36999999999534;59.944999999999936;52.19000000000233;51.06500000000233;60.45999999999185;50.670000000012806
29;Vanilla-ES2015-Babel-Webpack-TodoMVC;330.5049999999999;341.7250000000022;343.31999999998516;347.33000000000175;406.554999999993;345.54499999999996;499.9200000000019;347.6600000000035;330.07999999999447;336.55499999997846;362.2599999999999;352.6650000000045;438.40499999999884;423.8600000000006;369.3149999999878;331.995;330.0249999999978;380.54999999999563;361.2250000000058;471.4699999999866;367.4399999999998;343.9950000000026;338.7800000000061;394.3749999999927;342.01500000001397
30;React-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Sync;299.2650000000001;299.6800000000003;321.70000000000437;308.51000000000204;313.6149999999907;321.855;306.9500000000007;305.2149999999965;335.4499999999971;338.52999999999884;316.16999999999985;317.7599999999984;312.92000000000553;315.4950000000026;357.29000000000815;311.1600000000001;338.21500000000015;314.3249999999971;335.6449999999968;314.5450000000128;308.28999999999996;309.1949999999997;325.72499999999854;324.3950000000041;316.22000000000116
31;React-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Async;19.685000000000173;23.674999999999272;23.1050000000032;29.470000000001164;21.860000000000582;23.174999999999955;26.100000000002183;21.089999999996508;34.87999999999738;21.919999999998254;23.924999999999955;57.73999999999796;29.94499999999971;23.220000000001164;22.664999999993597;24.52500000000009;32.8949999999968;23.095000000001164;24.8550000000032;38.354999999995925;26.585000000000036;29.56500000000233;50.549999999995634;20.409999999996217;30.554999999993015
32;React-TodoMVC/Adding100Items;318.9500000000003;323.35499999999956;344.80500000000757;337.9800000000032;335.47499999999127;345.03;333.0500000000029;326.304999999993;370.32999999999447;360.4499999999971;340.0949999999998;375.49999999999636;342.86500000000524;338.7150000000038;379.95500000000175;335.6850000000002;371.10999999999694;337.41999999999825;360.5;352.90000000000873;334.875;338.76000000000204;376.2749999999942;344.8050000000003;346.7749999999942
33;React-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Sync;179.42999999999984;183.98500000000058;189.8199999999997;198.58499999999913;198.70500000000175;198.81999999999994;295.0750000000007;192.4449999999997;198.77000000000407;299.9349999999977;197.39999999999986;220.69000000000233;196.75;188.38500000000204;191.0899999999965;206.9849999999999;201.47499999999854;193.12000000000262;208.1800000000003;240.68499999999767;199.67499999999995;219.02499999999782;192.25999999999476;188.15000000000146;197.7850000000035
34;React-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Async;17.795000000000073;15.280000000002474;16.080000000001746;18.264999999999418;15.634999999994761;19.519999999999982;17.11999999999898;18.12999999999738;22.50499999999738;20.66500000000815;16.795000000000073;31.209999999999127;16.94000000000233;16.709999999999127;16.625;20.575000000000045;44.47999999999956;18.139999999999418;17.68000000000029;22.094999999986612;17.97499999999991;22.895000000000437;57.08499999999913;22.529999999998836;17.995000000009895
35;React-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems;197.2249999999999;199.26500000000306;205.90000000000146;216.84999999999854;214.3399999999965;218.33999999999992;312.1949999999997;210.5749999999971;221.27500000000146;320.6000000000058;214.19499999999994;251.90000000000146;213.69000000000233;205.09500000000116;207.7149999999965;227.55999999999995;245.9549999999981;211.26000000000204;225.86000000000058;262.7799999999843;217.64999999999986;241.91999999999825;249.3449999999939;210.6800000000003;215.7800000000134
36;React-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems/Sync;121.0949999999998;114.28499999999985;122.61499999999796;118.03000000000611;115.91500000000815;128.47500000000014;114.81499999999869;113.52500000000146;155.77500000000146;113.59500000000116;123.64499999999975;97.13999999999942;117.53500000000349;117.76499999999942;119.67999999999302;120.27999999999997;137.02500000000146;125.30000000000291;124.55000000000291;119.55500000000757;117.54999999999995;120.625;123.20500000000175;126.48999999999796;126.08999999999651
37;React-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems/Async;7.394999999999982;8.580000000001746;12.364999999997963;6.610000000000582;10.989999999990687;6.735000000000127;9.794999999998254;10.340000000003783;6.625;9.069999999992433;6.654999999999745;8.81000000000131;14.569999999999709;8.619999999995343;218.33000000000175;9.275000000000091;15.8849999999984;6.260000000002037;17.69000000000233;25.835000000006403;13.28500000000031;7.970000000001164;58.229999999995925;10.485000000000582;8.740000000005239
38;React-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems;128.48999999999978;122.8650000000016;134.97999999999593;124.6400000000067;126.90499999999884;135.21000000000026;124.60999999999694;123.86500000000524;162.40000000000146;122.6649999999936;130.2999999999995;105.95000000000073;132.1050000000032;126.38499999999476;338.00999999999476;129.55500000000006;152.90999999999985;131.56000000000495;142.24000000000524;145.39000000001397;130.83500000000026;128.59500000000116;181.43499999999767;136.97499999999854;134.83000000000175
39;React-TodoMVC;644.665;645.4850000000042;685.685000000005;679.4700000000084;676.7199999999866;698.5800000000002;769.8549999999996;660.7449999999953;754.0049999999974;803.7149999999965;684.5899999999992;733.3499999999985;688.6600000000108;670.1949999999997;925.679999999993;692.8000000000002;769.9749999999949;680.2400000000052;728.6000000000058;761.070000000007;683.3600000000001;709.2750000000015;807.0549999999857;692.4599999999991;697.3850000000093
40;React-Redux-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Sync;434.4200000000001;453.82000000000335;714.3499999999985;445.4150000000009;449.7250000000058;480.75999999999976;448.96500000000015;436.7850000000035;446.4799999999959;456.6399999999994;446.56500000000005;434.54499999999825;486.66999999999825;442.75500000000466;444.13000000000466;437.69000000000005;444.40499999999884;453.66999999999825;447.2649999999994;446.32500000001164;441.125;455.244999999999;446.1399999999994;443.4300000000003;485.91999999999825
41;React-Redux-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Async;21.19499999999971;17.854999999999563;18.285000000003492;35.544999999998254;189.95500000000175;27.829999999999927;45.93500000000131;23.00999999999476;20.25;20.22500000000582;26.75;48.29500000000189;23.854999999995925;57.48999999999796;58.42500000000291;20.610000000000127;17.8650000000016;25.535000000003492;26.360000000000582;31.895000000004075;38.89499999999998;29.784999999999854;72.77999999999884;29.99000000000524;18.00999999999476
42;React-Redux-TodoMVC/Adding100Items;455.6149999999998;471.6750000000029;732.635000000002;480.9599999999991;639.6800000000076;508.5899999999997;494.90000000000146;459.79499999999825;466.7299999999959;476.86500000000524;473.31500000000005;482.84000000000015;510.5249999999942;500.2450000000026;502.55500000000757;458.3000000000002;462.27000000000044;479.20500000000175;473.625;478.2200000000157;480.02;485.02999999999884;518.9199999999983;473.42000000000553;503.929999999993
43;React-Redux-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Sync;586.6949999999997;655.2200000000012;728.6900000000023;610.3300000000017;619.2949999999983;603.2900000000004;701.1849999999977;594.1750000000029;610.1949999999997;607.3999999999942;614.3800000000001;690.5900000000001;660.6000000000058;602.8550000000032;619.5099999999948;608.9550000000004;612.0949999999975;620.5999999999985;606.1599999999962;602.7949999999983;609.75;609.8400000000001;615.5;622.4400000000023;691.9250000000029
44;React-Redux-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Async;19.159999999999854;14.919999999998254;20.37999999999738;21.19499999999971;72.06500000000233;30.22499999999991;17.139999999999418;19.06999999999971;22.095000000001164;330.41500000000815;25.050000000000182;41.955000000001746;56.71499999999651;77.06999999999971;68.59500000000116;22.360000000000127;15.390000000003056;17.700000000004366;28.55500000000029;17.75999999999476;61.07500000000027;29.12000000000262;142.95999999999913;29.160000000003492;20.264999999999418
45;React-Redux-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems;605.8549999999996;670.1399999999994;749.0699999999997;631.5250000000015;691.3600000000006;633.5150000000003;718.3249999999971;613.2450000000026;632.2900000000009;937.8150000000023;639.4300000000003;732.5450000000019;717.3150000000023;679.9250000000029;688.1049999999959;631.3150000000005;627.4850000000006;638.3000000000029;634.7149999999965;620.554999999993;670.8250000000003;638.9600000000028;758.4599999999991;651.6000000000058;712.1900000000023
46;React-Redux-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Sync;307.10000000000036;407.27999999999884;301.90499999999884;304.2299999999959;322.7699999999895;305.7249999999999;298.40499999999884;315.1650000000009;312.3950000000041;320.1100000000006;308.3699999999999;289.6349999999984;397.7549999999974;305.20500000000175;314.8099999999977;310.00999999999976;308.1949999999997;307.86999999999534;309.7900000000009;306.6399999999994;313.05999999999995;308.6100000000006;332.34999999999854;317.83000000000175;305.7399999999907
47;React-Redux-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Async;67.1550000000002;149.01000000000204;7.5;9.934999999997672;57.125;7.349999999999909;17.1150000000016;8.505000000004657;9.594999999993888;42.50500000000466;8.2800000000002;14.270000000000437;18.435000000004948;58.92500000000291;59.125;7.7849999999998545;6.400000000001455;6.360000000000582;18.169999999998254;8.095000000001164;20.855000000000018;8.270000000000437;7.049999999995634;8.789999999993597;15.194999999992433
48;React-Redux-TodoMVC/DeletingItems;374.25500000000056;556.2900000000009;309.40499999999884;314.1649999999936;379.8949999999895;313.0749999999998;315.52000000000044;323.67000000000553;321.98999999999796;362.61500000000524;316.6500000000001;303.90499999999884;416.1900000000023;364.13000000000466;373.9349999999977;317.7949999999996;314.59500000000116;314.2299999999959;327.9599999999991;314.7350000000006;333.91499999999996;316.880000000001;339.3999999999942;326.61999999999534;320.9349999999831
49;React-Redux-TodoMVC;1435.725;1698.1050000000032;1791.1100000000006;1426.6499999999942;1710.9349999999977;1455.1799999999998;1528.744999999999;1396.7100000000064;1421.0099999999948;1777.2950000000128;1429.3950000000004;1519.2900000000009;1644.0299999999988;1544.3000000000102;1564.5950000000012;1407.4100000000003;1404.3500000000022;1431.7350000000006;1436.2999999999956;1413.5100000000093;1484.7600000000002;1440.8700000000026;1616.7799999999916;1451.6400000000067;1537.0549999999785
50;EmberJS-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Sync;573.5649999999996;615.864999999998;579.5349999999962;588.4250000000029;588.3950000000041;594.2149999999997;588.3050000000003;572.5450000000055;598.5299999999988;583.4650000000111;587.6000000000004;574.5449999999983;591.25;584.4000000000015;592.8699999999953;610.5000000000005;593.7050000000017;583.4349999999977;608.7149999999965;594.8600000000006;614.6350000000002;580;640.8450000000012;602.8950000000041;592.4750000000058
51;EmberJS-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Async;19.300000000000182;33.465000000000146;44.48500000000058;26.875;56.979999999995925;36.18499999999949;19.534999999999854;70.46500000000378;21.580000000001746;77.61500000000524;75.49499999999989;24.81999999999971;19.07999999999447;21.80999999999767;25.05000000000291;34.89499999999953;21.354999999999563;21.19000000000233;22.205000000001746;30.74000000000524;42.600000000000364;20.724999999998545;25.910000000003492;23.610000000000582;69.11999999999534
52;EmberJS-TodoMVC/Adding100Items;592.8649999999998;649.3299999999981;624.0199999999968;615.3000000000029;645.375;630.3999999999992;607.8400000000001;643.0100000000093;620.1100000000006;661.0800000000163;663.0950000000003;599.364999999998;610.3299999999945;606.2099999999991;617.9199999999983;645.395;615.0600000000013;604.625;630.9199999999983;625.6000000000058;657.2350000000006;600.7249999999985;666.7550000000047;626.5050000000047;661.5950000000012
53;EmberJS-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Sync;241.21999999999935;250.63500000000204;234.49499999999534;250.66999999999825;257.6600000000035;230.34499999999935;254.08000000000175;254.91999999999825;252.30999999999767;240.6750000000029;252.625;239.49499999999898;239.08499999999913;259.1800000000003;248.43000000000757;259.77000000000044;237.9350000000013;242.84999999999854;239.86000000000058;238.9100000000035;260.1950000000006;242.99499999999898;367.45000000000437;248.7800000000061;238.5500000000029
54;EmberJS-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Async;17.145000000000437;47.31000000000131;18.535000000003492;30.69999999999709;22.245000000009895;20.625;30.234999999996944;67.3599999999933;21.360000000000582;273.29499999999825;64.89000000000033;25.74499999999898;15.069999999999709;17.505000000004657;28.735000000000582;40.039999999999964;20.7599999999984;18.150000000001455;22.659999999996217;19.330000000001746;14.860000000000582;20.80500000000029;28.6050000000032;19.470000000001164;71.45999999999185
55;EmberJS-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems;258.3649999999998;297.94500000000335;253.02999999999884;281.36999999999534;279.9050000000134;250.96999999999935;284.3149999999987;322.27999999999156;273.66999999999825;513.9700000000012;317.5150000000003;265.23999999999796;254.15499999999884;276.68500000000495;277.16500000000815;299.8100000000004;258.6949999999997;261;262.5199999999968;258.24000000000524;275.0550000000012;263.7999999999993;396.05500000000757;268.2500000000073;310.00999999999476
56;EmberJS-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Sync;140.9949999999999;259.15999999999985;144.56500000000233;153.38999999999942;152.125;143.3099999999995;160.1150000000016;146.71500000000378;152.93499999999767;146.0500000000029;140.0699999999997;139.61999999999898;141.51499999999942;149.23500000000058;149.72499999999127;151.09999999999945;142.37000000000262;149.84500000000116;144.82999999999447;150.30499999999302;144.23499999999967;147.44000000000233;152.25;143.18999999999505;141.86000000000058
57;EmberJS-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Async;7.585000000000036;17.81999999999971;7.2700000000040745;7.105000000003201;6.654999999998836;7.539999999999964;6.444999999999709;75.83000000000175;7.494999999995343;7.30000000000291;39.409999999999854;6.2849999999998545;6.700000000004366;12.659999999996217;6.915000000008149;14.329999999999927;6.474999999998545;10.844999999993888;12.365000000005239;9.130000000004657;16.81500000000051;6.415000000000873;12.659999999996217;9.470000000001164;62.0399999999936
58;EmberJS-TodoMVC/DeletingItems;148.57999999999993;276.97999999999956;151.8350000000064;160.49500000000262;158.77999999999884;150.84999999999945;166.5600000000013;222.54500000000553;160.42999999999302;153.35000000000582;179.47999999999956;145.90499999999884;148.21500000000378;161.8949999999968;156.63999999999942;165.42999999999938;148.84500000000116;160.68999999999505;157.1949999999997;159.43499999999767;161.05000000000018;153.8550000000032;164.90999999999622;152.65999999999622;203.89999999999418
59;EmberJS-TodoMVC;999.8099999999995;1224.255000000001;1028.885000000002;1057.1650000000009;1084.0600000000122;1032.219999999998;1058.7150000000001;1187.8350000000064;1054.2099999999919;1328.4000000000233;1160.0900000000001;1010.5099999999948;1012.6999999999971;1044.7900000000009;1051.7250000000058;1110.6349999999998;1022.6000000000022;1026.314999999995;1050.6349999999948;1043.2750000000087;1093.340000000002;1018.380000000001;1227.7200000000084;1047.4150000000081;1175.50499999999
60;EmberJS-Debug-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Sync;1462.4049999999997;1356.1599999999999;1356.0099999999948;1344.5;1392.8500000000058;1335.9300000000003;1409.7899999999972;1513.6649999999936;1342.2000000000044;1743.5799999999872;1419.125;1340.6850000000013;1370.5449999999983;1414.4449999999997;1743.75;1373.9099999999999;1337.130000000001;1865.7150000000038;1688.5950000000012;1387.9399999999878;1354.625;1354.5300000000025;1356.2849999999962;1370.6949999999997;1499.270000000004
61;EmberJS-Debug-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Async;30.920000000000073;107.78499999999985;23.82499999999709;83.31499999999505;28.47500000000582;37.8100000000004;31.885000000002037;25.2300000000032;24.18499999999767;25.035000000003492;25.295000000000073;71.46500000000015;37.3949999999968;33.86000000000058;23.379999999990105;28.460000000000036;72.59500000000116;26.99500000000262;22.924999999995634;24.385000000009313;31.954999999999927;71.53999999999724;24.360000000000582;31.584999999999127;33.68499999999767
62;EmberJS-Debug-TodoMVC/Adding100Items;1493.3249999999998;1463.9449999999997;1379.8349999999919;1427.814999999995;1421.3250000000116;1373.7400000000007;1441.6749999999993;1538.8949999999968;1366.385000000002;1768.6149999999907;1444.42;1412.1500000000015;1407.939999999995;1448.3050000000003;1767.12999999999;1402.37;1409.7250000000022;1892.7100000000064;1711.5199999999968;1412.324999999997;1386.58;1426.0699999999997;1380.6449999999968;1402.2799999999988;1532.9550000000017
63;EmberJS-Debug-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Sync;635.4200000000001;721.135000000002;633.885000000002;631.6300000000047;730.1199999999953;622.8800000000001;641.8450000000012;640.25;689.114999999998;642.8450000000012;648.4650000000001;978.3799999999974;629.5750000000044;644.114999999998;655.8399999999965;631.125;612.005000000001;675.560000000005;780.9150000000009;636.1300000000047;671.8450000000003;627.5750000000007;640.8349999999991;632.6600000000035;650.1050000000105
64;EmberJS-Debug-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Async;19.219999999999345;20.219999999997526;14.944999999999709;355.7850000000035;30.05999999999767;14.875;26.845000000001164;38.19999999999709;22.169999999998254;33.8350000000064;12.659999999999854;42.29500000000189;18.31500000000233;19.895000000004075;33.845000000001164;21.449999999999818;292.46000000000276;34.21499999999651;32.46499999999651;18.389999999999418;34.76500000000033;266.02000000000044;27.375;15.400000000001455;21.004999999990105
65;EmberJS-Debug-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems;654.6399999999994;741.3549999999996;648.8300000000017;987.4150000000081;760.179999999993;637.7550000000001;668.6900000000023;678.4499999999971;711.2849999999962;676.6800000000076;661.125;1020.6749999999993;647.8900000000067;664.010000000002;689.6849999999977;652.5749999999998;904.4650000000038;709.7750000000015;813.3799999999974;654.5200000000041;706.6100000000006;893.5950000000012;668.2099999999991;648.060000000005;671.1100000000006
66;EmberJS-Debug-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Sync;796.5100000000002;881.880000000001;839.4449999999997;838.7900000000009;804.2599999999948;822.0099999999993;1158.4050000000025;809.6849999999977;922.9850000000006;837.7299999999959;854.1950000000006;900.8899999999994;814.5950000000012;863.2050000000017;850.3199999999924;801.0650000000005;815.6500000000015;829.364999999998;851.0900000000038;821.9799999999959;838.9949999999999;820.0900000000001;999.2700000000041;793.5199999999968;826.6999999999971
67;EmberJS-Debug-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Async;8.329999999999927;7.240000000001601;18.540000000000873;9.509999999994761;9.77499999999418;16.68499999999949;15.830000000001746;21.985000000000582;14.779999999998836;9.714999999996508;10.454999999999927;7.049999999999272;16.515000000006694;24.239999999997963;9.764999999999418;8.534999999999854;10.385000000002037;8.904999999998836;7.25;18.705000000001746;10.969999999999345;10.095000000001164;176.27500000000146;10.779999999998836;19.97500000000582
68;EmberJS-Debug-TodoMVC/DeletingItems;804.8400000000001;889.1200000000026;857.9850000000006;848.2999999999956;814.0349999999889;838.6949999999988;1174.2350000000042;831.6699999999983;937.7649999999994;847.4449999999924;864.6500000000005;907.9399999999987;831.1100000000079;887.4449999999997;860.0849999999919;809.6000000000004;826.0350000000035;838.2699999999968;858.3400000000038;840.6849999999977;849.9649999999992;830.1850000000013;1175.5450000000055;804.2999999999956;846.6750000000029
69;EmberJS-Debug-TodoMVC;2952.8049999999994;3094.420000000002;2886.649999999994;3263.529999999999;2995.5399999999936;2850.1899999999996;3284.600000000006;3049.014999999992;3015.4349999999977;3292.7399999999907;2970.1950000000006;3340.7649999999994;2886.9400000000096;2999.760000000002;3316.8999999999796;2864.545;3140.2250000000095;3440.7550000000047;3383.239999999998;2907.529999999999;2943.1549999999997;3149.850000000002;3224.4000000000015;2854.6399999999994;3050.7400000000052
70;BackboneJS-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Sync;178.04500000000007;175.88999999999942;185.27500000000146;183.20500000000175;172.60999999998603;177.9300000000003;190.15000000000146;193.98500000000058;174.48500000000058;186.7850000000035;190.6900000000005;189.8199999999997;181.61499999999796;184.1600000000035;175.14999999999418;184.60499999999956;190.16500000000087;185.9300000000003;187.65000000000146;195.61500000000524;180.80499999999847;186.12999999999738;186.80999999999767;184.83499999999913;183.89000000001397
71;BackboneJS-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Async;33.94000000000051;35.13999999999942;35.520000000004075;27.264999999999418;34.729999999995925;25.155000000000655;30.99500000000262;28.44499999999971;40.720000000001164;44.03500000000349;29.139999999999418;36.909999999999854;23.715000000003783;37.43499999999767;42.38999999999942;29.44499999999971;45.95999999999913;39.51000000000204;38.145000000004075;31.460000000006403;25.840000000000146;37.345000000001164;31.81999999999971;24.139999999999418;35.544999999998254
72;BackboneJS-TodoMVC/Adding100Items;211.98500000000058;211.02999999999884;220.79500000000553;210.47000000000116;207.33999999998196;203.08500000000095;221.14500000000407;222.4300000000003;215.20500000000175;230.82000000000698;219.82999999999993;226.72999999999956;205.33000000000175;221.59500000000116;217.5399999999936;214.04999999999927;236.125;225.44000000000233;225.79500000000553;227.07500000001164;206.64499999999862;223.47499999999854;218.62999999999738;208.97499999999854;219.43500000001222
73;BackboneJS-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Sync;78.02499999999964;77.74499999999898;79.38500000000204;80.9800000000032;77.71500000001106;73.79500000000007;78.48500000000058;83.44999999999709;78.04999999999563;78.29499999999825;80.26500000000124;83.8650000000016;75.65999999999622;79.08000000000175;76.41999999999825;76.4950000000008;81.92499999999927;92.11000000000058;82.89999999999418;80.04499999999825;82.36499999999978;83.08499999999913;75.66000000000349;74.625;80.64500000000407
74;BackboneJS-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Async;22.94499999999971;51.60499999999956;59.74000000000524;43.06000000000495;45.23999999999069;29.829999999999927;32.17000000000189;26.69999999999709;49.099999999998545;48.94999999999709;24.219999999999345;40.69499999999971;141.06500000000233;20.9800000000032;47.43499999999767;32.6150000000016;51.91500000000087;31.005000000004657;29.375;33.85000000000582;28.93000000000029;33.27000000000044;23.090000000003783;38.04000000000087;36.25
75;BackboneJS-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems;100.96999999999935;129.34999999999854;139.12500000000728;124.04000000000815;122.95500000000175;103.625;110.65500000000247;110.14999999999418;127.14999999999418;127.24499999999534;104.48500000000058;124.56000000000131;216.72499999999854;100.06000000000495;123.85499999999593;109.1100000000024;133.84000000000015;123.11500000000524;112.27499999999418;113.89500000000407;111.29500000000007;116.35499999999956;98.75000000000728;112.66500000000087;116.89500000000407
76;BackboneJS-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems/Sync;80.18000000000029;79.99500000000262;90.93499999999767;88.20500000000175;87.04499999999825;77.03999999999905;79.93000000000029;91.87000000000262;86.34500000000116;86.5399999999936;92.58500000000095;93.15999999999985;79.00500000000466;85.45999999999913;78.54999999998836;83.94000000000051;81.30500000000029;94.04500000000553;84.15499999999884;95.00999999999476;86.03999999999905;86.375;87.94999999999709;90.36499999999796;92.02000000000407
77;BackboneJS-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems/Async;11.604999999999563;11.270000000000437;12.105000000003201;19.189999999995052;26.95999999999185;15.539999999999054;10.014999999999418;13.319999999999709;37.6449999999968;27.870000000009895;8.25;35.42000000000189;31.68000000000029;10.42000000000553;28.11500000000524;17.485000000000582;7.31000000000131;32.56999999999971;9.349999999998545;8.839999999996508;12.854999999999563;13.489999999997963;11.235000000000582;34.31999999999971;10.94999999999709
78;BackboneJS-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems;91.78499999999985;91.26500000000306;103.04000000000087;107.3949999999968;114.0049999999901;92.57999999999811;89.94499999999971;105.19000000000233;123.98999999999796;114.41000000000349;100.83500000000095;128.58000000000175;110.68500000000495;95.88000000000466;106.6649999999936;101.42500000000109;88.6150000000016;126.61500000000524;93.50499999999738;103.84999999999127;98.89499999999862;99.86499999999796;99.18499999999767;124.68499999999767;102.97000000000116
79;BackboneJS-TodoMVC;404.7399999999998;431.64500000000044;462.9600000000137;441.9050000000061;444.2999999999738;399.28999999999905;421.74500000000626;437.7699999999968;466.3449999999939;472.4750000000058;425.15000000000146;479.8700000000026;532.7400000000052;417.53500000001077;448.0599999999831;424.58500000000276;458.58000000000175;475.1700000000128;431.5749999999971;444.820000000007;416.8349999999973;439.69499999999607;416.5650000000023;446.3249999999971;439.30000000001746
80;AngularJS-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Sync;534.8099999999995;542.2049999999981;530.8900000000067;512.1500000000015;552.2149999999965;522.1750000000011;534.4650000000001;548.7200000000012;528.864999999998;521.6599999999889;551.2250000000004;529.6650000000009;633.2699999999968;536.8500000000058;533.0899999999965;545.8649999999998;543.5349999999999;541.6599999999962;542.6800000000003;579.1549999999988;521.4400000000005;556.6999999999971;521.3050000000003;542.9449999999997;535.8399999999965
81;AngularJS-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Async;26.270000000000437;24.110000000000582;25.56999999999971;33.25999999999476;34.43000000000757;26.69000000000051;67.20000000000073;24.025000000001455;72.19000000000233;25.010000000009313;31.30500000000029;32.42500000000291;22.025000000001455;33.61000000000058;25.81500000000233;31.75;24.854999999999563;25.93499999999767;24.529999999998836;25.955000000001746;32.43499999999949;34.585000000002765;33.154999999998836;24.69499999999971;23.85000000000582
82;AngularJS-TodoMVC/Adding100Items;561.0799999999999;566.3149999999987;556.4600000000064;545.4099999999962;586.6450000000041;548.8650000000016;601.6650000000009;572.7450000000026;601.0550000000003;546.6699999999983;582.5300000000007;562.0900000000038;655.2949999999983;570.4600000000064;558.9049999999988;577.6149999999998;568.3899999999994;567.5949999999939;567.2099999999991;605.1100000000006;553.875;591.2849999999999;554.4599999999991;567.6399999999994;559.6900000000023
83;AngularJS-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Sync;137.70999999999913;129.64500000000044;125.17499999999563;123.04000000000087;136.40000000000873;125.68499999999949;138.84000000000015;128.31499999999505;127.34499999999389;134.2149999999965;126.07500000000073;123.875;130.29499999999825;122.90500000000611;128.7899999999936;133.15500000000065;162.12000000000262;126.34000000000378;127.30000000000291;126.90499999999884;123.61000000000058;130.1349999999984;124.62000000000262;129.3050000000003;135.80499999999302
84;AngularJS-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Async;29.600000000000364;17.400000000001455;15.165000000000873;26.075000000004366;18.654999999998836;19.395000000000437;80.04000000000087;28.639999999999418;184.66500000000087;15.104999999995925;16.974999999998545;21.104999999999563;37.30000000000291;27.75499999999738;15.955000000001746;17.655000000000655;21.125;19.79500000000553;21.015000000006694;16.68499999999767;32.51500000000124;29.49499999999898;17.904999999998836;19.845000000001164;21.839999999996508
85;AngularJS-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems;167.3099999999995;147.0450000000019;140.3399999999965;149.11500000000524;155.05500000000757;145.07999999999993;218.88000000000102;156.95499999999447;312.00999999999476;149.31999999999243;143.04999999999927;144.97999999999956;167.59500000000116;150.6600000000035;144.74499999999534;150.8100000000013;183.24500000000262;146.1350000000093;148.3150000000096;143.5899999999965;156.12500000000182;159.62999999999738;142.52500000000146;149.15000000000146;157.64499999998952
86;AngularJS-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems/Sync;296.66999999999825;300.005000000001;301.68999999999505;311.7450000000026;432.0249999999942;296.8099999999995;302.66999999999825;321.77999999999884;324.04499999999825;310.36500000000524;307.0849999999991;306.28499999999985;422.8050000000003;300.15000000000146;442.3099999999977;517.5999999999985;324.90499999999884;309.09999999999854;309.02999999999884;300.36500000000524;360.6700000000001;313.7549999999974;306.8349999999991;418.5650000000023;318.1750000000029
87;AngularJS-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems/Async;37.100000000000364;15.204999999998108;15.384999999994761;22.544999999998254;16.354999999995925;19.390000000001237;44.340000000000146;12.92500000000291;23.525000000001455;16.220000000001164;17.954999999999927;12.794999999998254;17.290000000000873;23.50499999999738;20.405000000013388;17.74499999999898;13.965000000000146;20.31999999999971;17.039999999993597;23.955000000001746;17.079999999999927;28.770000000000437;23.06500000000233;15.509999999994761;15.360000000000582
88;AngularJS-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems;333.7699999999986;315.2099999999991;317.0749999999898;334.2900000000009;448.3799999999901;316.2000000000007;347.0099999999984;334.70500000000175;347.5699999999997;326.5850000000064;325.03999999999905;319.0799999999981;440.09500000000116;323.65499999999884;462.71500000001106;535.3449999999975;338.869999999999;329.41999999999825;326.06999999999243;324.320000000007;377.75;342.5249999999978;329.90000000000146;434.0749999999971;333.5350000000035
89;AngularJS-TodoMVC;1062.159999999998;1028.5699999999997;1013.8749999999927;1028.8150000000023;1190.0800000000017;1010.1450000000023;1167.5550000000003;1064.4049999999988;1260.6349999999948;1022.5749999999971;1050.619999999999;1026.1500000000015;1262.9850000000006;1044.7750000000087;1166.3650000000052;1263.7699999999986;1090.505000000001;1043.1500000000015;1041.5950000000012;1073.020000000004;1087.7500000000018;1093.439999999995;1026.885000000002;1150.864999999998;1050.8699999999953
90;Angular2-TypeScript-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Sync;151.8700000000008;165.75500000000102;167.17499999999563;156.56500000000233;166.3649999999907;177.4499999999989;159.91499999999724;168.3249999999971;155.2850000000035;161.69499999999243;157.34500000000116;156;170.5699999999997;159.18999999999505;162.8350000000064;178.82999999999993;165.00499999999738;173.05999999999767;166.6999999999971;171.56500000000233;156.51999999999862;152.53499999999985;156.3550000000032;167.18999999999505;162.31000000001222
91;Angular2-TypeScript-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Async;21.670000000000073;30.794999999998254;15.560000000004948;27.5;26.42500000000291;49.414999999999054;18.985000000000582;27.69499999999971;14.845000000001164;30.464999999996508;18.549999999999272;31.69499999999971;26.955000000001746;18.145000000004075;32.75999999999476;19.350000000000364;25.514999999999418;26.580000000001746;21.56999999999971;19.07499999999709;17.039999999999054;16.25500000000102;15.489999999997963;15.854999999995925;17.90000000000873
92;Angular2-TypeScript-TodoMVC/Adding100Items;173.54000000000087;196.54999999999927;182.73500000000058;184.06500000000233;192.7899999999936;226.86499999999796;178.89999999999782;196.0199999999968;170.13000000000466;192.15999999998894;175.89500000000044;187.6949999999997;197.52500000000146;177.33499999999913;195.59500000000116;198.1800000000003;190.5199999999968;199.63999999999942;188.2699999999968;190.63999999999942;173.55999999999767;168.79000000000087;171.84500000000116;183.04499999999098;180.21000000002095
93;Angular2-TypeScript-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Sync;24.655000000000655;26.37000000000262;26.215000000003783;24.525000000001455;25.730000000010477;24.19999999999891;25.665000000000873;25.654999999998836;25.139999999999418;27;27.145000000000437;30.360000000000582;26.20499999999447;29.24000000000524;28.27499999999418;26.045000000000073;27.00499999999738;26.205000000001746;25.409999999996217;26.82499999999709;24.9950000000008;25.18500000000131;25.094999999993888;26.334999999999127;26.739999999990687
94;Angular2-TypeScript-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Async;14.154999999998836;22.1150000000016;15.710000000006403;9.665000000000873;15.805000000007567;21.82499999999891;14.25499999999738;9.875;18.87000000000262;19.644999999989523;16.420000000000073;9.2400000000016;11.209999999999127;24.24000000000524;13.77499999999418;23.86499999999978;24.169999999998254;18.32499999999709;24.56999999999971;19.154999999998836;18.485000000000582;19.010000000002037;19.794999999998254;28.970000000001164;14.85000000000582
95;Angular2-TypeScript-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems;38.80999999999949;48.48500000000422;41.925000000010186;34.19000000000233;41.535000000018044;46.02499999999782;39.919999999998254;35.529999999998836;44.01000000000204;46.64499999998952;43.56500000000051;39.60000000000218;37.4149999999936;53.48000000001048;42.04999999998836;49.909999999999854;51.174999999995634;44.529999999998836;49.979999999995925;45.979999999995925;43.48000000000138;44.19500000000335;44.88999999999214;55.30500000000029;41.58999999999651
96;Angular2-TypeScript-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Sync;62.524999999999636;62.18999999999869;57.23500000000058;51.775000000001455;61.55999999999767;51.585000000000946;60.965000000000146;56.98500000000058;55.200000000004366;63.029999999998836;55.98999999999978;54.030000000002474;68.03500000000349;54.26499999999942;55.20999999999185;62.225000000000364;64.97999999999956;55.41000000000349;63.70999999999913;60.50500000000466;56.469999999999345;61.86999999999898;59.18000000000029;55.23999999999796;55.00500000000466
97;Angular2-TypeScript-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Async;20.05999999999949;20.399999999997817;9.549999999995634;7.2849999999962165;19.910000000003492;10.739999999999782;8.825000000000728;10.780000000006112;8.434999999997672;9.539999999993597;6.8399999999983265;20.95499999999811;19.229999999995925;7.059999999997672;16.729999999995925;10.56500000000051;20.49499999999898;37.36499999999796;13.785000000003492;10.460000000006403;10.715000000000146;9.3849999999984;9.380000000004657;6.169999999998254;6.8549999999959255
98;Angular2-TypeScript-TodoMVC/DeletingItems;82.58499999999913;82.58999999999651;66.78499999999622;59.05999999999767;81.47000000000116;62.32500000000073;69.79000000000087;67.7650000000067;63.63500000000204;72.56999999999243;62.82999999999811;74.98500000000058;87.26499999999942;61.32499999999709;71.93999999998778;72.79000000000087;85.47499999999854;92.77500000000146;77.49500000000262;70.96500000001106;67.18499999999949;71.25499999999738;68.56000000000495;61.40999999999622;61.86000000000058
99;Angular2-TypeScript-TodoMVC;294.9349999999995;327.625;291.445000000007;277.3150000000023;315.7950000000128;335.2149999999965;288.60999999999694;299.3150000000023;277.77500000000873;311.3749999999709;282.28999999999905;302.2800000000025;322.20499999999447;292.1400000000067;309.5849999999773;320.880000000001;327.169999999991;336.9449999999997;315.74499999999534;307.5850000000064;284.22499999999854;284.2400000000016;285.29499999999825;299.7599999999875;283.66000000001804
100;VueJS-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Sync;21.265000000001237;24.090000000000146;21.3949999999968;22.220000000001164;21.464999999996508;20.780000000000655;25.360000000000582;22.43000000000029;21.150000000001455;22.260000000009313;21.715000000000146;22.93499999999767;22.455000000001746;21.255000000004657;24.639999999999418;21.19499999999971;21.6349999999984;20.904999999998836;21.30999999999767;21.86500000000524;21.204999999999927;21.600000000002183;22.474999999998545;22.709999999999127;22.94999999999709
101;VueJS-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Async;98.95000000000073;100.3650000000016;91.74500000000262;102.06999999999971;95.78500000000349;117.88500000000022;111.46500000000015;105.63999999999942;104.54999999999563;98.93499999999767;105.22500000000036;107.55999999999767;123.34000000000378;94.50499999999738;114.52000000000407;94.4950000000008;112.09500000000116;134.85499999999593;104.92500000000291;95.13000000000466;95.39499999999862;91.72000000000116;95.15499999999884;104.37999999999738;105.38999999999942
102;VueJS-TodoMVC/Adding100Items;120.21500000000196;124.45500000000175;113.13999999999942;124.29000000000087;117.25;138.66500000000087;136.82500000000073;128.0699999999997;125.69999999999709;121.19500000000698;126.94000000000051;130.49499999999534;145.79500000000553;115.76000000000204;139.1600000000035;115.69000000000051;133.72999999999956;155.75999999999476;126.23500000000058;116.9950000000099;116.59999999999854;113.32000000000335;117.62999999999738;127.08999999999651;128.3399999999965
103;VueJS-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Sync;7.700000000000728;7.920000000001892;8.084999999999127;7.904999999998836;7.875;7.770000000000437;8.470000000001164;8.239999999997963;9.080000000001746;9.32499999999709;8.199999999998909;11.145000000000437;8.694999999999709;8.05000000000291;7.955000000001746;8.284999999999854;8.755000000001019;13.940000000002328;7.915000000000873;7.724999999991269;8.764999999999418;7.67500000000291;8.230000000003201;9.794999999998254;7.975000000005821
104;VueJS-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Async;76.39500000000044;76.3849999999984;77.89500000000407;74.52999999999884;80.47000000000116;70.84499999999935;83.55500000000029;82.67999999999302;70.48500000000058;89.43000000000757;87.96999999999935;65.97999999999956;69.34500000000116;76.38999999999942;73.79499999999825;77.125;78.13999999999942;70.52500000000146;109.8949999999968;74.17999999999302;90.55999999999949;73.16500000000087;87.32499999999709;74.79499999999825;101.33999999999651
105;VueJS-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems;84.09500000000116;84.30500000000029;85.9800000000032;82.43499999999767;88.34500000000116;78.61499999999978;92.02500000000146;90.91999999999098;79.56500000000233;98.75500000000466;96.16999999999825;77.125;78.04000000000087;84.44000000000233;81.75;85.40999999999985;86.89500000000044;84.46500000000378;117.80999999999767;81.90499999998428;99.32499999999891;80.84000000000378;95.55500000000029;84.58999999999651;109.31500000000233
106;VueJS-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems/Sync;11.359999999998763;17.534999999999854;14.515000000006694;18.864999999997963;12.355000000010477;15.965000000000146;23.279999999998836;12.25;12.775000000001455;10.629999999990105;12.2549999999992;12.534999999999854;10.784999999996217;12.784999999996217;18.69000000000233;10.43499999999949;11.56499999999869;10.569999999999709;11.060000000004948;10.200000000011642;17.375;13.044999999998254;11.74500000000262;14.735000000000582;10.460000000006403
107;VueJS-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems/Async;22.30999999999949;22.849999999998545;22.139999999999418;22.93000000000029;21.92499999998836;23.644999999998618;27.610000000000582;22.839999999996508;36.18499999999767;23.47499999999127;24.05500000000029;40.654999999998836;27.025000000001455;24.885000000002037;34.23500000000058;24.8799999999992;30.8849999999984;22.290000000000873;27.104999999995925;26.569999999992433;27.834999999999127;21.599999999998545;26.375;23.875;22.519999999989523
108;VueJS-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems;33.669999999998254;40.3849999999984;36.65500000000611;41.794999999998254;34.279999999998836;39.60999999999876;50.88999999999942;35.08999999999651;48.95999999999913;34.10499999998137;36.30999999999949;53.18999999999869;37.80999999999767;37.669999999998254;52.92500000000291;35.31499999999869;42.44999999999709;32.86000000000058;38.16500000000087;36.770000000004075;45.20999999999913;34.6449999999968;38.12000000000262;38.61000000000058;32.979999999995925
109;VueJS-TodoMVC;237.98000000000138;249.14500000000044;235.77500000000873;248.5199999999968;239.875;256.8899999999994;279.7400000000016;254.0799999999872;254.22499999999854;254.05499999999302;259.41999999999825;260.80999999999403;261.6450000000041;237.87000000000262;273.8350000000064;236.41499999999905;263.0749999999971;273.0849999999991;282.2099999999991;235.66999999999825;261.1349999999966;228.80500000000393;251.3050000000003;250.2899999999936;270.63499999999476
110;jQuery-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Sync;364.2950000000001;372.13500000000204;326.41999999999825;343.97499999999854;346.06999999999243;349.35000000000036;343.2400000000016;347.3249999999971;343.7099999999991;337.55500000000757;401.91499999999905;339.9850000000006;330.63499999999476;344.8249999999971;339.3099999999977;338.9499999999989;355.02000000000044;356.1800000000003;346.34999999999854;500.0850000000064;334.15999999999985;368.5849999999991;336.5650000000023;338.5900000000038;462.3350000000064
111;jQuery-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Async;25.354999999999563;19.159999999999854;52.104999999995925;18.764999999999418;28.97500000000582;35.68000000000029;29.465000000000146;24.200000000004366;28.640000000006694;35.81500000000233;21.625;18.149999999997817;18.05000000000291;26.084999999999127;26.889999999999418;48;23.020000000000437;18.464999999996508;28.340000000003783;19.07499999999709;37.23499999999876;18.915000000000873;45.6449999999968;21.335000000006403;19.710000000006403
112;jQuery-TodoMVC/Adding100Items;389.64999999999964;391.2950000000019;378.5249999999942;362.73999999999796;375.04499999999825;385.03000000000065;372.70500000000175;371.52500000000146;372.3500000000058;373.3700000000099;423.53999999999905;358.1349999999984;348.6849999999977;370.9099999999962;366.1999999999971;386.9499999999989;378.0400000000009;374.6449999999968;374.6900000000023;519.1600000000035;371.3949999999986;387.5;382.2099999999991;359.9250000000102;482.0450000000128
113;jQuery-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Sync;656.9349999999995;604.6800000000003;593.7649999999994;597.5199999999968;621.6349999999948;606.6700000000001;601.1849999999977;600.9549999999945;617.3400000000038;606.3999999999942;579.9499999999989;576.2250000000022;583.4550000000017;590.2900000000009;653.4099999999889;830.505000000001;640.1500000000015;598.9599999999991;602.9200000000055;594.8450000000012;848.0150000000012;586.7950000000019;609.2299999999959;620.6150000000052;585.179999999993
114;jQuery-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Async;23.94499999999971;31.025000000001455;76.33999999999651;20.334999999999127;19.030000000013388;32.43000000000029;34.18999999999869;22.80000000000291;28.0199999999968;36.4600000000064;19.225000000000364;18.49499999999898;18.195000000006985;32.73500000000058;18.419999999998254;18.405000000000655;17.919999999998254;27.974999999998545;56.395000000004075;18.630000000004657;26.270000000000437;19.474999999998545;70.51499999999942;21.81999999999971;17.55000000000291
115;jQuery-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems;680.8799999999992;635.7050000000017;670.1049999999959;617.8549999999959;640.6650000000081;639.1000000000004;635.3749999999964;623.7549999999974;645.3600000000006;642.8600000000006;599.1749999999993;594.7200000000012;601.6500000000087;623.0250000000015;671.8299999999872;848.9100000000017;658.0699999999997;626.9349999999977;659.3150000000096;613.4750000000058;874.2850000000017;606.2700000000004;679.7449999999953;642.435000000005;602.7299999999959
116;jQuery-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems/Sync;301.5;298.84999999999854;298.86999999999534;306.2150000000038;366.2350000000006;317.85499999999956;339.4350000000013;305.125;326.0599999999977;317.9600000000064;296.65999999999985;299.02999999999884;299.00999999999476;351.54500000000553;327.0199999999895;299.0400000000009;300.0750000000007;311.8700000000026;353.4599999999991;318;407.8850000000002;296.5599999999977;319.70499999999447;381.875;307.4349999999977
117;jQuery-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems/Async;8.530000000000655;10.094999999997526;56.26000000000204;8.590000000003783;12.694999999992433;5.755000000001019;10.030000000002474;7.915000000000873;5.889999999999418;16.430000000007567;7.7849999999998545;6.005000000001019;9.404999999998836;17.755000000004657;10.75;6.3700000000008;10.375;15.770000000004075;6.629999999997381;6.44999999999709;11.139999999999418;13.659999999999854;57.419999999998254;6.099999999998545;10.599999999991269
118;jQuery-TodoMVC/DeletingAllItems;310.03000000000065;308.94499999999607;355.1299999999974;314.80500000000757;378.929999999993;323.6100000000006;349.4650000000038;313.0400000000009;331.9499999999971;334.39000000001397;304.4449999999997;305.03499999999985;308.4149999999936;369.3000000000102;337.7699999999895;305.4100000000017;310.4500000000007;327.6400000000067;360.0899999999965;324.4499999999971;419.02499999999964;310.2199999999975;377.1249999999927;387.97499999999854;318.03499999998894
119;jQuery-TodoMVC;1380.5599999999995;1335.9449999999997;1403.7599999999875;1295.4000000000015;1394.6399999999994;1347.7400000000016;1357.545000000002;1308.3199999999997;1349.6600000000035;1350.6200000000244;1327.159999999998;1257.8899999999994;1258.75;1363.2350000000079;1375.7999999999738;1541.2700000000023;1346.5600000000013;1329.2200000000012;1394.0950000000084;1457.0850000000064;1664.705;1303.989999999998;1439.0799999999872;1390.3350000000137;1402.8099999999977
120;Preact-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Sync;15.204999999999927;24.610000000000582;24.43000000000029;22.330000000001746;26.70999999999185;15.7549999999992;24.389999999999418;20.215000000003783;23.49000000000524;15.22500000000582;14.985000000000582;15.555000000000291;18.325000000004366;25.8949999999968;14.770000000004075;15.525000000001455;21.465000000000146;15.970000000001164;18.94000000000233;16.019999999989523;15.725000000000364;25.885000000002037;14.945000000006985;14.875;24.110000000000582
121;Preact-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Async;58.0049999999992;58.48999999999796;108.47999999999593;60.31499999999505;62.870000000009895;63.85499999999956;57.7599999999984;63.88500000000204;81.09999999999854;63.2899999999936;62.034999999999854;73.15000000000146;77.92500000000291;60.73500000000058;58.53499999998894;58.33499999999913;64.88500000000204;68.36000000000058;61.92000000000553;76.46499999999651;88.75;63.775000000001455;111.65000000000146;71.19499999999971;88.68499999999767
122;Preact-TodoMVC/Adding100Items;73.20999999999913;83.09999999999854;132.90999999999622;82.6449999999968;89.58000000000175;79.60999999999876;82.14999999999782;84.10000000000582;104.59000000000378;78.51499999999942;77.02000000000044;88.70500000000175;96.25000000000728;86.62999999999738;73.30499999999302;73.86000000000058;86.35000000000218;84.33000000000175;80.86000000000786;92.48499999998603;104.47500000000036;89.66000000000349;126.59500000000844;86.06999999999971;112.79499999999825
123;Preact-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Sync;9.610000000000582;9.340000000000146;9.404999999998836;11.009999999994761;10.214999999996508;11.520000000000437;10.18999999999869;9.444999999999709;10.395000000004075;10.845000000001164;10.354999999999563;10.075000000000728;10.494999999995343;10.235000000000582;9.375;10.18999999999869;9.950000000000728;9.764999999999418;9.989999999997963;9.940000000002328;12.574999999998909;9.354999999999563;9.480000000003201;11.569999999999709;12.665000000008149
124;Preact-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Async;35.335000000000946;30.215000000000146;32.42500000000291;43.705000000001746;33.904999999998836;50.94499999999971;42.91500000000087;30.9800000000032;33.31500000000233;35.13499999999476;32.76999999999862;33.340000000000146;30.229999999995925;38.93499999999767;41.625;31.44000000000051;36.75;37.83499999999913;33.17500000000291;27.83499999999185;32.849999999998545;30.600000000002183;28.55999999999767;33.00500000000466;30.19000000000233
125;Preact-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems;44.94500000000153;39.55500000000029;41.830000000001746;54.71499999999651;44.11999999999534;62.465000000000146;53.10499999999956;40.42500000000291;43.7100000000064;45.979999999995925;43.12499999999818;43.41500000000087;40.72499999999127;49.169999999998254;51;41.6299999999992;46.70000000000073;47.599999999998545;43.16500000000087;37.77499999999418;45.42499999999745;39.955000000001746;38.04000000000087;44.575000000004366;42.85500000001048
126;Preact-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Sync;12.155000000000655;6.9099999999998545;6.889999999999418;6.150000000001455;7.319999999992433;14.270000000000437;14.140000000003056;8.020000000004075;7.344999999993888;7.7850000000034925;12.819999999999709;7.31499999999869;7.309999999997672;8.909999999996217;11.135000000009313;6.424999999999272;6.595000000001164;6.290000000000873;12.190000000002328;6.7850000000034925;7.014999999999418;6.229999999999563;6.3950000000040745;10.594999999993888;8.770000000004075
127;Preact-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Async;12.410000000001673;17.700000000000728;67.28000000000611;16.655000000006112;18.470000000001164;17.704999999999927;28.700000000000728;15.00499999999738;16.50499999999738;19.535000000003492;14.350000000000364;15.364999999997963;19.150000000001455;16.205000000001746;11;12.385000000000218;11.770000000000437;12.12000000000262;20.299999999995634;6.809999999997672;6.764999999999418;16.030000000002474;6.440000000002328;11.989999999997963;18.69999999999709
128;Preact-TodoMVC/DeletingItems;24.56500000000233;24.610000000000582;74.17000000000553;22.805000000007567;25.789999999993597;31.975000000000364;42.84000000000378;23.025000000001455;23.84999999999127;27.320000000006985;27.170000000000073;22.679999999996653;26.459999999999127;25.114999999997963;22.135000000009313;18.80999999999949;18.3650000000016;18.410000000003492;32.48999999999796;13.595000000001164;13.779999999998836;22.260000000002037;12.835000000006403;22.58499999999185;27.470000000001164
129;Preact-TodoMVC;142.72000000000298;147.26499999999942;248.9100000000035;160.16500000000087;159.4899999999907;174.04999999999927;178.09500000000116;147.5500000000102;172.15000000000146;151.81500000000233;147.3149999999987;154.79999999999927;163.43499999999767;160.9149999999936;146.44000000000233;134.29999999999927;151.4150000000045;150.34000000000378;156.5150000000067;143.85499999998137;163.67999999999665;151.87500000000728;177.47000000001572;153.22999999999593;183.1200000000099
130;Inferno-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Sync;126.0099999999984;133.8100000000013;139.45499999999447;128.51000000000204;132.47500000000582;135.21999999999935;144.1349999999984;136.52000000000407;130.47000000000116;137.07000000000698;132.65999999999985;134.09999999999854;133.9449999999997;142.1449999999968;145.49000000000524;142.53499999999985;128.76500000000306;139.93499999999767;138.20999999999913;131.15499999999884;130.96500000000015;127.7300000000032;146.9300000000003;136.5300000000061;132
131;Inferno-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Async;16.965000000000146;34.715000000000146;36.424999999995634;21.299999999995634;18.195000000006985;22.854999999999563;27.040000000000873;39.15999999999622;30.614999999997963;32.354999999995925;33.590000000000146;30.589999999996508;29.345000000001164;21.709999999999127;19.389999999999418;25.73999999999978;17.19499999999971;18.125;34.23999999999796;27.504999999990105;27.75;18.724999999998545;17.3949999999968;17.034999999996217;30.10000000000582
132;Inferno-TodoMVC/Adding100Items;142.97499999999854;168.52500000000146;175.8799999999901;149.80999999999767;150.6700000000128;158.0749999999989;171.17499999999927;175.6800000000003;161.08499999999913;169.4250000000029;166.25;164.68999999999505;163.29000000000087;163.85499999999593;164.88000000000466;168.27499999999964;145.96000000000276;158.05999999999767;172.4499999999971;158.65999999998894;158.71500000000015;146.45500000000175;164.3249999999971;153.56500000000233;162.10000000000582
133;Inferno-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Sync;144.375;160.22000000000116;173.22000000000116;152.77999999999884;156.7100000000064;154.8150000000005;129.1899999999987;154.75;130.63500000000204;152.72000000000116;130.91500000000087;149.90499999999884;156.22499999999854;162.76000000000204;145.4649999999965;129.0650000000005;157.0649999999987;154.5699999999997;156.8050000000003;151.60499999999593;129.4449999999997;146.60999999999694;120.52500000000146;159.7699999999968;147.44000000000233
134;Inferno-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Async;24.460000000000946;42.05500000000029;35.12000000000262;129.40499999999884;17.910000000003492;59.75;25.775000000001455;40.45499999999447;19.285000000003492;9.584999999991851;32.30500000000029;31.165000000000873;27.80500000000029;168.125;6.255000000004657;13.364999999999782;12.784999999999854;6.3400000000037835;9.064999999995052;20.414999999993597;13.635000000000218;11.829999999998108;20.935000000004948;23.17500000000291;12.494999999995343
135;Inferno-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems;168.83500000000095;202.27500000000146;208.34000000000378;282.1849999999977;174.6200000000099;214.5650000000005;154.96500000000015;195.20499999999447;149.92000000000553;162.30499999999302;163.22000000000116;181.0699999999997;184.02999999999884;330.88500000000204;151.72000000000116;142.4300000000003;169.84999999999854;160.9100000000035;165.86999999999534;172.01999999998952;143.07999999999993;158.43999999999505;141.4600000000064;182.9449999999997;159.93499999999767
136;Inferno-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Sync;598.1900000000005;566.8400000000001;628.6800000000003;575.2350000000006;556.7149999999965;806.4950000000008;576.1649999999972;602.3050000000003;575.4649999999965;606.6499999999942;790.4950000000008;577.8100000000013;595.8099999999977;599.0749999999971;590.5399999999936;583.6100000000006;564.9550000000017;605.8250000000044;591.7150000000038;586.0399999999936;566.1049999999996;562.375;584.5250000000015;571.695000000007;573.9599999999919
137;Inferno-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Async;38.784999999999854;74.45999999999913;7;43.71499999999651;7.605000000010477;17.295000000000073;10.544999999998254;58.729999999995925;6.365000000005239;35.04000000000815;6.779999999998836;16.770000000000437;21.400000000001455;47.04000000000087;16.105000000010477;7.364999999999782;9.43999999999869;31.81500000000233;10.12999999999738;9.880000000004657;15.295000000000073;36.5;16.459999999999127;37.74499999999534;17.31500000000233
138;Inferno-TodoMVC/DeletingItems;636.9750000000004;641.2999999999993;635.6800000000003;618.9499999999971;564.320000000007;823.7900000000009;586.7099999999955;661.0349999999962;581.8300000000017;641.6900000000023;797.2749999999996;594.5800000000017;617.2099999999991;646.114999999998;606.6450000000041;590.9750000000004;574.3950000000004;637.6400000000067;601.8450000000012;595.9199999999983;581.3999999999996;598.875;600.9850000000006;609.4400000000023;591.2749999999942
139;Inferno-TodoMVC;948.7849999999999;1012.1000000000022;1019.8999999999942;1050.9449999999924;889.6100000000297;1196.4300000000003;912.8499999999949;1031.919999999991;892.8350000000064;973.4199999999983;1126.7450000000008;940.3399999999965;964.5299999999988;1140.854999999996;923.2450000000099;901.6800000000003;890.2050000000017;956.6100000000079;940.1649999999936;926.5999999999767;883.1949999999997;903.7699999999968;906.7700000000041;945.9500000000044;913.3099999999977
140;Elm-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Sync;305.84000000000015;310.3500000000022;312.47000000000116;317.6200000000026;299.5650000000023;304.28000000000065;323.7350000000006;354.11500000000524;312.3050000000003;322.0749999999971;327.6700000000001;357.6650000000009;314.6949999999997;304.36499999999796;308.27999999999884;319.7000000000007;305.7649999999994;314.4650000000038;322.31499999999505;327.8799999999901;319.6399999999994;300.70500000000175;296.4050000000061;309.54499999999825;318.41999999999825
141;Elm-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Async;20.350000000000364;35.904999999998836;47.724999999998545;51.83499999999913;49.104999999995925;43.92500000000109;31.385000000002037;18.729999999995925;22.214999999996508;29.739999999990687;20.290000000000873;25.534999999999854;22.19999999999709;73;38.21499999999651;18.13500000000022;200.40499999999884;23.43000000000029;23.114999999997963;19.64999999999418;20.51000000000022;46.3650000000016;35.18999999999505;29.510000000002037;21.44000000000233
142;Elm-TodoMVC/Adding100Items;326.1900000000005;346.255000000001;360.1949999999997;369.45500000000175;348.66999999999825;348.20500000000175;355.1200000000026;372.84500000000116;334.5199999999968;351.8149999999878;347.96000000000095;383.2000000000007;336.8949999999968;377.36499999999796;346.49499999999534;337.83500000000095;506.16999999999825;337.8950000000041;345.429999999993;347.5299999999843;340.14999999999964;347.07000000000335;331.59500000000116;339.0550000000003;339.8600000000006
143;Elm-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Sync;290.65499999999884;304.84999999999854;376.7350000000006;312.4150000000009;309.61500000000524;301.2999999999993;425.2400000000016;469.5400000000009;318.375;316.54499999999825;421.89000000000124;305.83500000000276;297.90499999999884;309.02999999999884;291.0399999999936;314.1650000000009;299.8099999999977;316.5599999999977;299.09500000000116;338.91999999999825;297.6749999999993;305.6850000000013;416.2450000000026;300.70500000000175;311.2749999999942
144;Elm-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Async;15.274999999999636;41.62999999999738;27.685000000004948;28.19999999999709;36.92500000000291;17.729999999999563;17.095000000001164;20.964999999996508;26.470000000001164;20.729999999995925;18.639999999999418;17.7599999999984;21.68000000000029;77.58499999999185;63.63499999999476;27.05000000000109;54.43999999999869;19.75499999999738;14.440000000002328;27.61500000000524;23.05000000000109;75.04000000000087;18.715000000003783;25.139999999999418;30.45000000001164
145;Elm-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems;305.9299999999985;346.4799999999959;404.42000000000553;340.61499999999796;346.54000000000815;319.02999999999884;442.33500000000276;490.5049999999974;344.84500000000116;337.2749999999942;440.53000000000065;323.59500000000116;319.5849999999991;386.6149999999907;354.67499999998836;341.21500000000196;354.24999999999636;336.31499999999505;313.5350000000035;366.5350000000035;320.72500000000036;380.7250000000022;434.9600000000064;325.84500000000116;341.7250000000058
146;Elm-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Sync;249.29500000000007;267.8899999999994;264.2450000000026;261.1499999999942;282.54999999998836;267.60499999999956;278.6100000000006;262.0049999999974;268.0149999999994;262.63499999999476;256.97999999999956;280.65000000000146;278.5349999999962;271.31999999999243;254.02499999999418;292.1700000000001;260.4750000000022;278.66999999999825;257.79999999999563;296.9100000000035;266.1399999999994;259.3999999999978;442;264.8350000000064;272.5650000000023
147;Elm-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Async;15.635000000000218;14.850000000002183;16.50499999999738;15.275000000008731;10.84000000001106;8.090000000000146;43.93500000000131;9.20499999999447;12.75;18.56500000000233;9.905000000000655;10.24500000000262;8.930000000000291;231;20.570000000006985;13.965000000000146;49.875;10.839999999996508;8.269999999996799;8.19999999999709;13.699999999998909;60.405000000002474;13.544999999998254;15.009999999994761;10.479999999995925
148;Elm-TodoMVC/DeletingItems;264.9300000000003;282.7400000000016;280.75;276.4250000000029;293.3899999999994;275.6949999999997;322.5450000000019;271.20999999999185;280.7649999999994;281.1999999999971;266.8850000000002;290.8950000000041;287.4649999999965;502.31999999999243;274.59500000000116;306.1350000000002;310.3500000000022;289.50999999999476;266.06999999999243;305.1100000000006;279.8399999999983;319.8050000000003;455.54499999999825;279.84500000000116;283.04499999999825
149;Elm-TodoMVC;897.0499999999993;975.4749999999985;1045.3650000000052;986.4950000000026;988.6000000000058;942.9300000000003;1120.0000000000073;1134.5599999999904;960.1299999999974;970.289999999979;1055.3750000000018;997.690000000006;943.9449999999924;1266.299999999981;975.7649999999849;985.1850000000031;1170.7699999999968;963.7199999999939;925.0349999999889;1019.1749999999884;940.7149999999983;1047.6000000000058;1222.1000000000058;944.7450000000026;964.6300000000047
150;Flight-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Sync;136.78000000000065;143.5600000000013;134.66999999999825;138.38000000000466;138.74000000000524;135.96500000000015;131.82500000000437;140.47500000000582;132.15000000000873;132.5850000000064;132.70499999999993;133.35499999999956;134.71500000000378;137.02499999999418;136.7850000000035;132.9300000000003;139.55999999999767;131.11499999999796;139.84000000001106;134.65999999998894;136.50500000000102;142.97000000000116;140.9300000000003;132.61999999999534;139.9100000000035
151;Flight-TodoMVC/Adding100Items/Async;37.56999999999971;23.700000000000728;20.825000000004366;31.185000000012224;44.86000000000058;21.670000000000073;45.76499999999942;28.32499999999709;32.75;18.80999999999767;26.960000000000946;54.659999999999854;20.80500000000029;32.74000000000524;31.56500000000233;22.735000000000582;20.270000000000437;38.63999999999942;18.235000000000582;22.895000000004075;23.23999999999978;17.80999999999767;38.55000000000291;28.904999999998836;18.414999999993597
152;Flight-TodoMVC/Adding100Items;174.35000000000036;167.26000000000204;155.49500000000262;169.56500000001688;183.60000000000582;157.63500000000022;177.59000000000378;168.8000000000029;164.90000000000873;151.39500000000407;159.66500000000087;188.01499999999942;155.52000000000407;169.76499999999942;168.35000000000582;155.66500000000087;159.8299999999981;169.75499999999738;158.07500000001164;157.55499999999302;159.7450000000008;160.77999999999884;179.4800000000032;161.52499999999418;158.3249999999971
153;Flight-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Sync;130.51500000000124;135.38000000000102;115.40499999999884;198.59999999999127;150.05499999999302;123.46500000000015;126.97499999999854;125.84000000000378;130.18499999999767;120.81999999999243;119.02499999999964;129.78499999999985;121.94000000000233;119.05000000000291;129.3000000000029;121.40999999999985;119.27999999999884;121.24500000000262;132.65499999999884;128.9499999999971;126.07500000000073;143.8849999999984;124.23500000000058;126.56000000001222;117.94499999999243
154;Flight-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems/Async;19.484999999998763;60.54000000000087;20.715000000003783;34.07499999999709;30.610000000000582;20.11499999999978;25.95499999999447;21.010000000002037;37.58499999999185;25.375;32.32500000000073;54.095000000001164;32.63500000000204;19.40999999998894;29.645000000004075;22.534999999999854;20.20499999999811;48.359999999993306;21.875;26.57500000001164;24.894999999998618;18.040000000000873;47.65999999999622;27.92500000000291;23.369999999995343
155;Flight-TodoMVC/CompletingAllItems;150;195.9200000000019;136.12000000000262;232.67499999998836;180.6649999999936;143.57999999999993;152.92999999999302;146.85000000000582;167.76999999998952;146.19499999999243;151.35000000000036;183.88000000000102;154.57500000000437;138.45999999999185;158.94500000000698;143.9449999999997;139.48499999999694;169.60499999999593;154.52999999999884;155.52500000000873;150.96999999999935;161.92499999999927;171.8949999999968;154.48500000001513;141.31499999998778
156;Flight-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Sync;104.86499999999978;120.29000000000087;110.06999999999971;107.19999999999709;101.55000000000291;99.44500000000153;108.51499999999942;106.78500000000349;102.66000000000349;107.36500000000524;105.46500000000015;103.22000000000116;109.83499999999913;100.46999999998661;106.92500000000291;100.94499999999971;98.97000000000116;119.27500000000146;96.86500000000524;105.19499999999243;102.6200000000008;110.17499999999927;109.18999999999505;99.49499999999534;113.125
157;Flight-TodoMVC/DeletingItems/Async;11.319999999999709;20.919999999998254;9.834999999999127;16.089999999996508;18.03499999998894;7.440000000000509;9.959999999999127;8.00499999999738;31.070000000006985;7.184999999997672;7.369999999998981;50.099999999998545;10.92500000000291;7.444999999992433;23.264999999999418;12.06500000000051;14.510000000002037;13.180000000000291;8.565000000002328;7.150000000008731;7.4099999999998545;22.349999999998545;18.510000000002037;19.014999999999418;10.134999999994761
158;Flight-TodoMVC/DeletingItems;116.18499999999949;141.20999999999913;119.90499999999884;123.2899999999936;119.58499999999185;106.88500000000204;118.47499999999854;114.79000000000087;133.73000000001048;114.55000000000291;112.83499999999913;153.3199999999997;120.76000000000204;107.91499999997905;130.19000000000233;113.01000000000022;113.4800000000032;132.45500000000175;105.43000000000757;112.34500000000116;110.03000000000065;132.52499999999782;127.69999999999709;118.50999999999476;123.25999999999476
159;Flight-TodoMVC;440.53499999999985;504.39000000000306;411.5200000000041;525.5299999999988;483.84999999999127;408.1000000000022;448.99499999999534;430.4400000000096;466.40000000000873;412.1399999999994;423.85000000000036;525.2150000000001;430.8550000000105;416.1399999999703;457.48500000001513;412.6200000000008;412.79499999999825;471.81499999999505;418.03500000001804;425.4250000000029;420.7450000000008;455.2299999999959;479.0749999999971;434.5200000000041;422.8999999999796

stylebench

tabpaint

  • contact: :mconley
  • source: tabpaint
  • bug: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1253382
  • type: Pageloader
  • measuring:
    • The time it takes to paint the content of a newly opened tab when the tab is opened from the parent (ex: by hitting Ctrl-T)
    • The time it takes to paint the content of a newly opened tab when the tab is opened from content (ex: by clicking on a target="_blank" link)
  • NOT measuring:
    • The time it takes to animate the tabs. That's the responsibility of the TART test. tabpaint is strictly concerned with the painting of the web content.
  • data: we load the tabpaint trigger page 20 times, each run produces two values (the time it takes to paint content when opened from the parent, and the time it takes to paint content when opened from content), resulting in 2 sets of 20 data points.
    • Example:
Example data 
0;tabpaint-from-parent;105;76;66;64;64;69;65;63;70;68;64;60;65;63;54;61;64;67;61;64
1; tabpaint-from-content;129;68;72;72;70;78;86;85;82;79;120;92;76;80;74;82;76;89;77;85
  • summarization:
    • subtest: ignore first data point, then take the median of the remaining 19 data points
    • suite: geometric_mean(subtests)

TART

  • contact: :MattN
  • source: tart
  • type: PageLoader
  • measuring: Desktop Firefox UI animation speed and smoothness
  • reporting: intervals in ms (lower is better) - see below for details
  • data: there are 30 reported subtests from TART which we load 25 times, resulting in 30 sets of 25 data points.
  • summarization:

TART is the Tab Animation Regression Test.

TART tests tab animation on these cases:

  • Simple: single new tab of about:blank open/close without affecting (shrinking/expanding) other tabs.
  • icon: same as above with favicons and long title instead of about:blank.
  • Newtab: newtab open with thumbnails preview - without affecting other tabs, with and without preload.
  • Fade: opens a tab, then measures fadeout/fadein (tab animation without the overhead of opening/closing a tab).
    • Case 1 is tested with DPI scaling of 1.
    • Case 2 is tested with DPI scaling of 1.0 and 2.0.
    • Case 3 is tested with the default scaling of the test system.
    • Case 4 is tested with DPI scaling of 2.0 with the "icon" tab (favicon and long title).
    • Each animation produces 3 test results:
      • error: difference between the designated duration and the actual completion duration from the trigger.
      • half: average frame interval over the 2nd half of the animation.
      • all: average frame interval over all recorded intervals.
      • And the run logs also include the explicit intervals from which these 3 values were derived.

TART can be used as a stand-alone addon:

  • Set the browser to ASAP mode (preferences layout.frame_rate=0, docshell.event_starvation_delay_hint=1). This makes the browser refresh the screen as fast as possible instead of limiting it to 60hz, thus allows higher resolution measurements. Requires restart to take effect.
  • Install the latest addon xpi, or zip the addon dir of the source code, rename the extension to xpi and install.
  • Visit chrome://tart/content/tart.html
  • Select subtests to run. By default the selected tests are all the TART tests.
Example data 
0;simple-open-DPI1.half.TART;2.35;2.42;2.63;2.47;2.71;2.38;2.37;2.41;2.48;2.70;2.44;2.41;2.51;2.43;2.41;2.56;2.76;2.49;2.36;2.40;2.70;2.53;2.35;2.46;2.47
1;simple-open-DPI1.all.TART;2.80;2.95;3.12;2.92;3.46;2.87;2.92;2.99;2.89;3.24;2.94;2.95;3.25;2.92;3.02;3.00;3.21;3.31;2.84;2.87;3.10;3.13;3.10;2.94;2.95
2;simple-open-DPI1.error.TART;33.60;36.33;35.93;35.97;38.17;34.77;36.00;35.01;36.25;36.22;35.24;35.76;36.64;36.31;34.74;34.40;34.34;41.48;35.04;34.83;34.27;34.04;34.37;35.22;36.52
3;simple-close-DPI1.half.TART;1.95;1.88;1.91;1.94;2.00;1.97;1.88;1.76;1.84;2.18;1.99;1.83;2.04;1.93;1.81;1.77;1.79;1.90;1.82;1.84;1.78;1.75;1.76;1.89;1.81
4;simple-close-DPI1.all.TART;2.19;2.08;2.07;2.32;2.65;2.32;2.26;1.96;2.02;2.26;2.05;2.16;2.19;2.11;2.04;1.98;2.05;2.02;2.01;2.11;1.97;1.97;2.05;2.01;2.12
5;simple-close-DPI1.error.TART;21.35;23.87;22.60;22.02;22.97;22.35;22.15;22.79;21.81;21.90;22.26;22.58;23.15;22.43;22.76;23.36;21.86;22.70;22.96;22.70;22.28;22.03;21.78;22.33;22.23
6;icon-open-DPI1.half.TART;2.42;2.33;2.50;2.58;2.36;2.51;2.60;2.35;2.52;2.51;2.59;2.34;3.29;2.63;2.46;2.57;2.53;2.50;2.39;2.51;2.44;2.66;2.72;2.36;2.52
7;icon-open-DPI1.all.TART;3.12;2.94;3.42;3.23;3.10;3.21;3.33;3.14;3.24;3.32;3.46;2.90;3.65;3.19;3.27;3.47;3.32;3.13;2.95;3.23;3.21;3.33;3.47;3.15;3.32
8;icon-open-DPI1.error.TART;38.39;37.96;37.03;38.85;37.03;37.17;37.19;37.56;36.67;36.33;36.89;36.85;37.54;38.46;35.38;37.52;36.68;36.48;36.03;35.71;37.12;37.08;37.74;38.09;35.85
9;icon-close-DPI1.half.TART;1.94;1.93;1.79;1.89;1.83;1.83;1.90;1.89;1.75;1.76;1.77;1.74;1.81;1.86;1.95;1.99;1.73;1.83;1.97;1.80;1.94;1.84;2.01;1.88;2.03
10;icon-close-DPI1.all.TART;2.14;2.14;1.98;2.03;2.02;2.25;2.29;2.13;1.97;2.01;1.94;2.01;1.99;2.05;2.11;2.09;2.02;2.02;2.12;2.02;2.20;2.11;2.19;2.07;2.27
11;icon-close-DPI1.error.TART;24.51;25.03;25.17;24.54;23.86;23.70;24.02;23.61;24.10;24.53;23.92;23.75;23.73;23.78;23.42;25.40;24.21;24.55;23.96;24.96;24.41;24.96;24.16;24.20;23.65
12;icon-open-DPI2.half.TART;2.60;2.60;2.60;2.53;2.51;2.53;2.59;2.43;2.66;2.60;2.47;2.61;2.64;2.43;2.49;2.63;2.61;2.60;2.52;3.06;2.65;2.74;2.69;2.44;2.43
13;icon-open-DPI2.all.TART;3.45;3.22;3.38;3.47;3.10;3.31;3.47;3.13;3.37;3.14;3.28;3.20;3.40;3.15;3.14;3.23;3.41;3.16;3.26;3.55;3.29;3.49;3.44;3.11;3.22
14;icon-open-DPI2.error.TART;40.20;37.86;37.53;41.46;37.03;38.77;37.48;36.97;37.28;37.72;36.09;36.71;38.89;38.21;37.37;38.91;36.79;36.10;37.60;36.99;37.56;35.76;38.92;37.46;37.52
15;icon-close-DPI2.half.TART;2.27;1.97;1.83;1.86;2.08;1.88;1.80;1.90;1.77;1.89;2.06;1.89;1.89;1.86;2.01;1.79;1.78;1.83;1.89;1.85;1.74;1.82;1.84;1.81;1.79
16;icon-close-DPI2.all.TART;2.33;2.13;2.18;2.03;2.33;2.03;1.95;2.06;1.96;2.13;2.25;2.10;2.13;2.03;2.18;2.00;2.05;2.01;2.08;2.05;1.96;2.04;2.10;2.04;2.08
17;icon-close-DPI2.error.TART;22.99;23.02;24.32;23.58;23.05;23.34;22.92;23.22;22.90;23.33;23.33;23.05;22.80;23.45;24.05;22.39;22.14;22.97;22.85;22.13;22.89;22.98;23.69;22.99;23.08
18;iconFade-close-DPI2.half.TART;2.14;1.84;1.78;1.84;1.66;2.07;1.81;3.82;1.68;1.85;1.62;2.54;2.06;1.85;2.17;1.80;1.71;1.67;2.11;1.73;2.94;2.14;1.93;1.72;2.05
19;iconFade-close-DPI2.all.TART;2.17;1.76;1.80;1.89;1.70;1.93;1.80;3.38;1.78;1.90;1.70;2.50;1.94;1.81;2.29;1.82;1.79;1.76;2.23;1.80;2.85;2.06;1.84;1.83;2.09
20;iconFade-close-DPI2.error.TART;4.67;4.11;3.69;4.51;4.46;3.88;4.54;3.68;4.56;3.82;4.32;4.87;4.42;3.72;3.72;4.54;4.93;4.46;4.64;3.39;4.09;3.28;3.58;4.11;3.80
21;iconFade-open-DPI2.half.TART;2.37;2.61;2.37;2.62;2.54;2.84;2.57;2.44;4.33;2.57;2.59;2.67;2.58;2.48;2.38;2.39;2.50;2.39;2.50;2.57;2.52;2.55;2.47;2.69;2.41
22;iconFade-open-DPI2.all.TART;2.45;2.64;2.39;2.60;2.57;2.60;2.61;2.59;3.14;2.55;2.54;2.66;2.57;2.48;2.47;2.46;2.55;2.45;2.51;2.61;2.54;2.58;2.50;2.54;2.40
23;iconFade-open-DPI2.error.TART;3.64;4.67;4.31;5.79;6.43;3.64;4.82;8.68;5.78;4.38;3.80;3.98;4.64;653.63;4.63;3.76;4.23;5.01;5.48;4.99;3.48;5.10;5.02;6.14;5.58
24;newtab-open-preload-no.half.TART;5.02;2.90;3.06;3.03;2.94;2.94;3.08;3.12;3.60;3.19;2.82;2.96;3.67;7.85;2.79;3.12;3.18;2.92;2.86;2.96;2.96;3.00;2.90;2.97;2.94
25;newtab-open-preload-no.all.TART;7.11;4.66;5.03;4.68;4.50;4.58;4.76;4.76;5.67;4.96;4.36;4.51;5.21;11.16;4.38;4.69;4.77;4.45;4.45;4.70;4.51;4.61;4.54;4.69;4.60
26;newtab-open-preload-no.error.TART;40.82;40.85;37.38;37.40;36.30;36.47;36.89;37.63;37.12;38.65;36.73;36.95;36.11;38.59;37.39;37.77;37.93;37.54;37.46;38.29;36.58;38.25;38.32;37.92;36.93
27;newtab-open-preload-yes.half.TART;3.14;2.96;2.97;8.37;2.98;3.00;2.96;3.05;3.12;3.48;3.07;3.23;3.05;2.88;2.92;3.06;2.90;3.01;3.19;2.90;3.18;3.11;3.04;3.16;3.21
28;newtab-open-preload-yes.all.TART;5.10;4.60;4.63;8.94;5.01;4.69;4.63;4.67;4.93;5.43;4.78;5.12;4.77;4.65;4.50;4.78;4.75;4.63;4.76;4.45;4.86;4.88;4.69;4.86;4.92
29;newtab-open-preload-yes.error.TART;35.90;37.24;38.57;40.60;36.04;38.12;38.78;36.73;36.91;36.69;38.12;36.69;37.79;35.80;36.11;38.01;36.59;38.85;37.14;37.30;38.02;38.95;37.64;37.86;36.43

tp5

Talos test name Description
tp5o tp5 with limited pageset (48 pages as others have too much noise)

Tests the time it takes Firefox to load the tp5 web page test set. The web set was culled from the Alexa top 500 April 8th, 2011 and consists of 51 pages.

Here are the broad steps we use to create the test set:

  1. Take the Alexa top 500 sites list
  2. Remove all sites with questionable or explicit content
  3. Remove duplicate site (for ex. many Google search front pages)
  4. Manually select to keep interesting pages (such as pages in different locales)
  5. Select a more representative page from any site presenting a simple search/login/etc. page
  6. Deal with Windows 255 char limit for cached pages
  7. Limit test set to top 100 pages

Note that the above steps did not eliminate all outside network access so we had to take further action to scrub all the pages so that there are 0 outside network accesses (this is done so that the tp test is as deterministic measurement of our rendering/layout/paint process as possible).

Example data 
0;163.com/www.163.com/index.html;1035;512;542;519;505;514;551;513;554;793;487;528;528;498;503;530;527;490;521;535;521;496;498;564;520
1;56.com/www.56.com/index.html;1081;583;580;577;597;580;623;558;572;592;598;580;564;583;596;600;579;580;566;573;566;581;571;600;586
2;aljazeera.net/aljazeera.net/portal.html;688;347;401;382;346;362;347;372;337;345;365;337;380;338;355;360;356;366;367;352;350;366;346;375;382
3;amazon.com/www.amazon.com/Kindle-Wireless-Reader-Wifi-Graphite/dp/B002Y27P3M/507846.html;1392;878;901;852;886;867;877;864;862;877;866;888;3308;870;863;869;873;850;851;850;857;873;869;860;855
4;bbc.co.uk/www.bbc.co.uk/news/index.html;455;271;272;271;279;289;276;285;277;291;281;286;278;286;274;285;276;285;287;286;276;288;279;272;278
5;beatonna.livejournal.com/beatonna.livejournal.com/index.html;290;123;123;129;120;121;124;125;119;125;120;150;121;147;121;121;113;121;119;122;117;112;127;117;139
6;bild.de/www.bild.de/index.html;1314;937;946;931;922;918;920;937;934;930;947;928;936;933;933;928;930;941;951;946;947;938;925;939;938
7;cgi.ebay.com/cgi.ebay.com/ALL-NEW-KINDLE-3-eBOOK-WIRELESS-READING-DEVICE-W-WIFI-/130496077314@pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item1e622c1e02.html;495;324;330;328;321;308;315;308;321;313;327;330;317;339;333;322;312;370;336;327;310;312;312;355;330
8;chemistry.about.com/chemistry.about.com/index.html;238;156;156;154;158;161;152;151;152;167;179;152;154;156;161;161;157;167;151;167;154;149;178;153;160
9;chinaz.com/chinaz.com/index.html;347;223;255;234;245;233;264;234;244;228;260;224;258;223;280;220;243;225;251;226;258;232;258;232;247
10;cnn.com/www.cnn.com/index.html;551;384;436;394;391;375;371;407;371;374;398;372;368;388;376;380;386;377;363;383;384;370;388;381;374
11;dailymail.co.uk/www.dailymail.co.uk/ushome/index.html;984;606;551;561;545;542;576;564;543;560;566;557;561;544;545;576;548;539;568;567;557;560;545;544;578
12;dailymotion.com/www.dailymotion.com/us.html;473;271;286;272;285;288;290;290;280;268;286;269;287;275;289;282;293;287;304;261;289;284;281;277;286
13;digg.com/digg.com/news/story/New_logo_for_Mozilla_Firefox_browser.html;410;321;304;303;322;300;319;321;320;306;323;313;312;305;312;338;317;338;301;325;297;302;309;305;300
14;ezinearticles.com/ezinearticles.com/index.html@Migraine-Ocular---The-Eye-Migraines&id=4684133.html;234;177;163;163;186;176;185;175;167;156;162;199;163;190;173;181;175;178;165;159;182;170;183;169;158
15;globo.com/www.globo.com/index.html;684;468;466;485;482;445;433;467;467;450;487;466;440;484;444;451;511;443;429;469;468;430;485;459;447
16;google.com/www.google.com/search@q=mozilla.html;150;100;102;101;97;104;99;116;107;100;98;137;102;102;99;106;98;112;100;102;105;104;107;96;100
17;goo.ne.jp/goo.ne.jp/index.html;328;125;132;132;143;121;122;120;132;145;166;139;144;125;128;152;128;145;130;132;154;126;142;133;139
18;guardian.co.uk/www.guardian.co.uk/index.html;462;311;296;322;309;305;303;288;301;308;301;304;319;309;295;305;294;308;304;322;310;314;302;303;292
19;homeway.com.cn/www.hexun.com/index.html;584;456;396;357;417;374;376;406;363;392;400;378;378;402;390;373;398;393;366;385;383;361;418;386;351
20;huffingtonpost.com/www.huffingtonpost.com/index.html;811;609;575;596;568;585;589;571;568;600;571;588;585;570;574;616;576;564;598;594;589;590;572;572;612
21;ifeng.com/ifeng.com/index.html;829;438;478;462;448;465;469;470;429;463;465;432;482;444;476;453;460;476;461;484;467;510;447;477;443
22;imdb.com/www.imdb.com/title/tt1099212/index.html;476;337;358;332;414;379;344;420;354;363;387;345;358;371;341;385;359;379;353;349;392;349;358;378;347
23;imgur.com/imgur.com/gallery/index.html;419;205;224;231;207;222;206;231;204;219;209;210;210;208;202;215;203;210;203;212;218;219;202;224;230
24;indiatimes.com/www.indiatimes.com/index.html;530;339;348;384;376;381;353;350;403;333;356;393;350;328;393;329;389;346;394;349;382;332;409;327;354
25;mail.ru/mail.ru/index.html;500;256;308;251;271;270;270;246;273;252;279;249;301;252;251;256;271;246;267;254;265;248;277;247;275
26;mashable.com/mashable.com/index.html;699;497;439;508;440;448;512;446;431;500;445;427;495;455;458;499;440;432;522;443;447;488;445;461;489
27;media.photobucket.com/media.photobucket.com/image/funny%20gif/findstuff22/Best%20Images/Funny/funny-gif1.jpg@o=1.html;294;203;195;189;213;186;195;186;204;188;190;220;204;202;195;204;192;204;191;187;204;199;191;192;211
28;myspace.com/www.myspace.com/albumart.html;595;446;455;420;433;425;416;429;452;411;435;439;389;434;418;402;422;426;396;438;423;391;434;438;395
29;naver.com/www.naver.com/index.html;626;368;338;386;342;377;371;352;379;348;362;357;359;354;386;338;394;330;326;372;345;392;336;336;368
30;noimpactman.typepad.com/noimpactman.typepad.com/index.html;431;333;288;292;285;313;277;289;282;292;276;293;270;294;289;281;275;302;285;290;280;285;278;284;283
31;page.renren.com/page.renren.com/index.html;373;232;228;228;213;227;224;227;226;216;234;226;230;212;213;221;224;230;212;218;217;221;212;222;230
32;people.com.cn/people.com.cn/index.html;579;318;305;339;307;341;325;326;307;309;315;314;318;317;321;309;307;299;312;313;305;326;318;384;310
33;rakuten.co.jp/www.rakuten.co.jp/index.html;717;385;371;388;381;348;394;358;396;368;343;386;348;388;393;388;360;339;398;357;392;378;395;386;367
34;reddit.com/www.reddit.com/index.html;340;254;248;255;241;241;248;275;251;250;250;252;243;274;240;269;254;249;242;257;271;253;243;278;252
35;reuters.com/www.reuters.com/index.html;513;404;355;358;379;343;354;385;379;354;418;363;342;412;355;351;402;375;354;400;362;355;380;373;336
36;slideshare.net/www.slideshare.net/jameswillamor/lolcats-in-popular-culture-a-historical-perspective.html;397;279;270;283;285;283;291;286;289;284;275;281;288;284;280;279;290;301;290;270;292;282;289;267;278
37;sohu.com/www.sohu.com/index.html;727;414;479;414;431;485;418;440;488;431;432;464;442;407;488;435;416;465;445;414;480;416;403;463;429
38;spiegel.de/www.spiegel.de/index.html;543;430;391;380;440;387;375;430;380;397;415;383;434;420;384;399;421;392;384;418;388;380;427;403;392
39;stackoverflow.com/stackoverflow.com/questions/184618/what-is-the-best-comment-in-source-code-you-have-ever-encountered.html;503;377;356;438;370;388;409;367;366;407;375;363;393;360;363;396;376;391;426;363;378;408;400;359;408
40;store.apple.com/store.apple.com/us@mco=Nzc1MjMwNA.html;488;327;344;343;333;329;328;348;361;342;362;332;389;333;382;331;382;343;405;343;326;325;329;323;340
41;thepiratebay.org/thepiratebay.org/top/201.html;412;274;317;260;256;269;266;261;258;289;245;284;256;277;251;302;276;307;268;268;247;285;260;271;257
42;tudou.com/www.tudou.com/index.html;522;304;281;283;287;285;288;307;279;288;282;303;292;288;290;287;311;271;279;274;294;272;290;269;290
43;uol.com.br/www.uol.com.br/index.html;668;387;450;411;395;452;386;431;452;394;385;436;413;414;440;401;412;439;408;430;426;415;382;433;387
44;w3.org/www.w3.org/standards/webdesign/htmlcss.html;225;143;129;151;181;141;147;137;159;179;142;153;136;139;191;140;151;143;141;181;140;154;142;143;183
45;wsj.com/online.wsj.com/home-page.html;634;466;512;463;467;507;461;432;492;494;491;507;466;477;495;455;451;495;461;463;494;468;444;497;442
46;xinhuanet.com/xinhuanet.com/index.html;991;663;727;659;647;639;644;656;666;658;670;648;676;653;652;654;641;636;664;668;655;657;646;674;633
47;xunlei.com/xunlei.com/index.html;802;625;624;636;641;652;659;642;623;635;628;606;667;688;683;694;672;640;628;620;653;626;633;654;643
48;yelp.com/www.yelp.com/biz/alexanders-steakhouse-cupertino.html;752;475;502;472;477;512;489;478;501;472;454;517;487;474;521;467;450;513;491;464;536;507;455;511;481
49;youku.com/www.youku.com/index.html;844;448;498;441;417;497;478;439;467;436;447;465;438;461;466;446;452;496;457;446;486;449;467;499;442
50;youtube.com/www.youtube.com/music.html;443;338;253;289;238;296;254;290;242;302;237;290;253;305;253;293;251;311;244;293;255;291;246;316;249

File IO

Possible regression causes
  • nonmain_startup_fileio opt (with or without e10s) windows7-32 – bug 1274018 This test seems to consistently report a higher result for mozilla-central compared to Try even for an identical revision due to extension signing checks. In other words, if you are comparing Try and Mozilla-Central you may see a false-positive regression on perfherder. Graphs: non-e10s e10s

Xres (X Resource Monitoring)

A memory metric tracked during tp5 test runs. This metric is sampled every 20 seconds. This metric is collected on linux only.

xres man page.

% CPU

Cpu usage tracked during tp5 test runs. This metric is sampled every 20 seconds. This metric is collected on windows only.

Responsiveness

contact: :jimm, :overholt

Measures the delay for the event loop to process a tracer event. For more details, see bug 631571.

The score on this benchmark is proportional to the sum of squares of all event delays that exceed a 20ms threshold. Lower is better.

We collect 8000+ data points from the browser during the test and apply this formula to the results: 

return sum([float(x)*float(x) / 1000000.0 for x in val_list])

tp5o_scroll

Talos test name Description
tp5o_scroll Measures average frames interval while scrolling the pages of the tp5o set

This test is identical to tscrollx, but it scrolls the 50 pages of the tp5o set (rather than 6 synthetic pages which tscrollx scrolls). For each page, the test waits 500ms after the page load event fires, then iterates 100 scroll steps of 10px each (or until the bottom of the page is reached - whichever comes first), then reports the average frame interval.

Example data 
0;163.com/www.163.com/index.html;9.73;8.61;7.37;8.17;7.58;7.29;6.88;7.45;6.91;6.61;8.47;7.12
1;56.com/www.56.com/index.html;10.85;10.24;10.75;10.30;10.23;10.10;10.31;10.06;11.10;10.06;9.56;10.30
2;aljazeera.net/aljazeera.net/portal.html;9.23;7.15;7.50;7.26;7.73;7.05;7.14;7.66;7.23;7.93;7.26;7.18
3;amazon.com/www.amazon.com/Kindle-Wireless-Reader-Wifi-Graphite/dp/B002Y27P3M/507846.html;7.14;6.87;7.18;6.31;6.93;6.71;6.37;7.00;6.59;5.37;7.31;6.13
4;bbc.co.uk/www.bbc.co.uk/news/index.html;7.39;6.33;6.22;7.66;6.67;7.77;6.91;7.74;7.08;6.36;6.03;7.12
5;beatonna.livejournal.com/beatonna.livejournal.com/index.html;5.79;5.79;5.68;5.46;5.55;5.48;5.69;5.83;5.88;5.97;5.93;5.88
6;bild.de/www.bild.de/index.html;8.65;7.63;7.17;6.36;7.44;7.68;8.63;6.71;8.34;7.15;7.82;7.70
7;cgi.ebay.com/cgi.ebay.com/ALL-NEW-KINDLE-3-eBOOK-WIRELESS-READING-DEVICE-W-WIFI-/130496077314@pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item1e622c1e02.html;7.12;6.81;7.22;6.98;7.05;5.68;7.15;6.54;7.31;7.18;7.82;7.77
8;chemistry.about.com/chemistry.about.com/index.html;6.76;6.17;6.41;6.88;5.67;5.47;6.83;6.28;6.16;6.81;6.21;6.75
9;chinaz.com/chinaz.com/index.html;10.72;7.99;7.33;7.10;7.85;8.62;8.39;6.72;6.26;6.65;8.14;7.78
10;cnn.com/www.cnn.com/index.html;7.73;6.80;6.08;8.27;9.24;7.81;7.69;7.05;8.17;7.70;7.90;6.81
11;dailymail.co.uk/www.dailymail.co.uk/ushome/index.html;6.37;8.28;7.19;8.00;8.09;7.43;6.90;7.24;7.77;7.29;7.38;6.14
12;dailymotion.com/www.dailymotion.com/us.html;9.53;9.80;9.29;9.03;9.10;8.64;8.62;8.71;8.77;9.81;9.64;8.96
13;digg.com/digg.com/news/story/New_logo_for_Mozilla_Firefox_browser.html;7.72;7.06;7.60;5.67;6.85;7.32;7.80;5.98;8.27;6.68;7.52;8.39
14;ezinearticles.com/ezinearticles.com/index.html@Migraine-Ocular---The-Eye-Migraines&id=4684133.html;7.14;7.11;8.09;7.17;6.87;7.12;7.65;7.74;7.26;7.36;6.91;6.95
15;globo.com/www.globo.com/index.html;6.71;7.91;5.83;7.34;7.75;8.00;7.73;7.85;7.03;6.42;8.43;8.11
16;google.com/www.google.com/search@q=mozilla.html;6.49;6.23;7.96;6.39;7.23;8.19;7.35;7.39;6.94;7.24;7.55;7.62
17;goo.ne.jp/goo.ne.jp/index.html;8.56;7.18;7.15;7.03;6.85;7.62;7.66;6.99;7.84;7.51;7.23;7.18
18;guardian.co.uk/www.guardian.co.uk/index.html;7.32;7.62;8.18;7.62;7.83;8.08;7.60;8.17;8.47;7.54;7.92;8.09
19;homeway.com.cn/www.hexun.com/index.html;10.18;8.75;8.83;8.64;8.98;8.07;7.76;9.29;8.05;7.55;8.91;7.78
20;huffingtonpost.com/www.huffingtonpost.com/index.html;8.38;7.17;7.03;6.83;6.49;6.47;6.69;7.08;6.81;7.29;7.13;7.70
21;ifeng.com/ifeng.com/index.html;12.45;8.65;8.75;7.56;8.26;7.71;8.04;7.45;7.83;7.14;8.38;7.68
22;imdb.com/www.imdb.com/title/tt1099212/index.html;8.53;5.65;6.94;7.18;6.10;7.57;6.26;8.34;8.16;7.29;7.62;8.51
23;imgur.com/imgur.com/gallery/index.html;8.10;7.20;7.50;7.88;7.27;6.97;8.13;7.14;7.59;7.39;8.01;8.82
24;indiatimes.com/www.indiatimes.com/index.html;8.00;6.74;7.37;8.52;7.03;8.45;7.08;8.47;9.26;7.89;7.17;6.74
25;mail.ru/mail.ru/index.html;7.64;9.50;9.47;7.03;6.45;6.24;8.03;6.72;7.18;6.39;6.25;6.25
26;mashable.com/mashable.com/index.html;7.97;8.03;6.10;7.80;7.91;7.26;7.49;7.45;7.60;7.08;7.63;7.36
27;media.photobucket.com/media.photobucket.com/image/funny%20gif/findstuff22/Best%20Images/Funny/funny-gif1.jpg@o=1.html;290.00;195.00;217.00;199.00;204.00;196.00;198.00;206.00;209.00;208.00;192.00;196.00
28;myspace.com/www.myspace.com/albumart.html;14.40;13.45;13.29;13.62;13.42;14.15;13.86;14.34;14.69;14.10;13.82;14.13
29;naver.com/www.naver.com/index.html;9.15;8.31;9.40;9.89;7.29;8.43;8.87;8.77;8.96;8.24;8.16;8.21
30;noimpactman.typepad.com/noimpactman.typepad.com/index.html;7.27;7.14;7.70;7.86;7.43;6.95;7.30;7.58;7.51;7.95;7.43;7.05
31;page.renren.com/page.renren.com/index.html;7.94;8.13;6.76;7.77;6.93;6.60;7.62;7.61;6.88;7.56;7.55;7.48
32;people.com.cn/people.com.cn/index.html;11.92;9.22;8.49;8.55;8.34;8.49;6.91;9.92;8.69;8.63;7.69;9.34
33;rakuten.co.jp/www.rakuten.co.jp/index.html;11.10;7.13;8.68;7.85;8.37;7.91;6.74;8.27;8.55;8.93;7.15;9.02
34;reddit.com/www.reddit.com/index.html;6.38;7.95;6.84;7.04;6.96;7.15;8.05;7.71;8.13;7.13;6.60;7.53
35;reuters.com/www.reuters.com/index.html;7.51;7.25;6.60;6.98;7.41;6.45;7.61;7.46;6.11;7.15;7.05;6.94
36;slideshare.net/www.slideshare.net/jameswillamor/lolcats-in-popular-culture-a-historical-perspective.html;7.20;6.32;6.80;6.87;6.29;6.45;7.18;6.92;6.57;7.41;7.08;6.51
37;sohu.com/www.sohu.com/index.html;11.72;9.64;8.85;7.12;7.96;9.14;7.76;8.19;7.14;7.68;8.08;7.24
38;spiegel.de/www.spiegel.de/index.html;7.24;7.30;6.64;7.01;6.74;6.70;6.36;6.84;7.86;7.08;7.12;7.40
39;stackoverflow.com/stackoverflow.com/questions/184618/what-is-the-best-comment-in-source-code-you-have-ever-encountered.html;7.39;5.88;7.22;6.51;7.12;6.51;6.46;6.53;6.63;6.54;6.48;6.80
40;store.apple.com/store.apple.com/us@mco=Nzc1MjMwNA.html;6.23;7.17;7.39;8.98;7.99;8.03;9.12;8.37;8.56;7.61;8.06;7.55
41;thepiratebay.org/thepiratebay.org/top/201.html;9.08;8.93;8.09;7.49;7.30;7.80;7.54;7.65;7.91;7.53;8.37;8.04
42;tudou.com/www.tudou.com/index.html;10.06;9.38;8.68;7.37;8.57;9.11;8.20;7.91;8.78;9.64;8.11;8.47
43;uol.com.br/www.uol.com.br/index.html;9.04;9.49;9.48;9.31;8.68;8.41;9.16;8.91;9.49;8.37;9.77;8.73
44;w3.org/www.w3.org/standards/webdesign/htmlcss.html;6.62;5.98;6.87;6.47;7.22;6.05;6.42;6.50;7.47;7.18;5.82;7.11
45;wsj.com/online.wsj.com/home-page.html;7.49;8.57;6.84;8.12;7.60;7.24;8.16;8.22;6.81;8.28;8.11;8.58
46;xinhuanet.com/xinhuanet.com/index.html;13.66;9.21;10.09;9.56;8.99;10.29;10.24;8.91;11.23;10.82;9.64;10.11
47;xunlei.com/xunlei.com/index.html;8.99;8.16;8.82;8.37;7.01;8.48;7.98;8.69;8.10;8.10;7.10;6.41
48;yelp.com/www.yelp.com/biz/alexanders-steakhouse-cupertino.html;8.18;7.45;7.01;8.14;7.12;7.82;8.24;7.13;7.00;6.41;6.85;7.31
49;youku.com/www.youku.com/index.html;12.21;10.29;10.37;10.34;8.40;9.82;9.23;9.91;9.64;9.91;8.90;10.23
50;youtube.com/www.youtube.com/music.html;9.90;9.06;9.29;9.17;8.85;8.77;9.83;9.21;9.29;10.09;9.69;8.64

Possible regression causes

Some examples of things that cause regressions in this test are:

  • Increased displayport size (which causes a larger display list to be built)
  • Slowdown in the building of display list
  • Slowdown in rasterization of content

tp6

  • contact: :rwood, :jmaher
  • source: tp6
  • type: PageLoader
  • reporting: intervals in ms (lower is better)
  • data: we load each of the tp6 pages 25 times
  • summarization:
    • subtest: ignore first five data points, then take the median of the remaining 20; source: test.py
    • suite: identical to subtest; each tp6_* test is reported individually (they're NOT aggregated)

The talos tp6 (also known as 'quantum-pageload') test suite loads various pages and reports their load times. Each test page/URL is reported individually.

Instead of loading the page sets from a local file, a tool called mitmproxy is used to playback page archives via an https proxy. When the tp6 suite is run via ./mach talos-test, mozharness automatically downloads and installs the mitmproxy tool and pageset archives.

The mitmproxy tool is started, the proxy setup in Firefox, and the mitmproxy https security certificate is loaded into Firefox, all automatically. The pagesets are made available for playback via the proxy, at which point each of the tp6 test pages are ready for load and measurement.

Note: For local debugging purposes, you can find the page set here

The tp6 suite currently consists of these individual pageload tests:

Talos test name Description
tp6_amazon Measures page load (first non-blank paint) of an amazon search result for the keyword "laptop"
tp6_facebook Measures page load (first non-blank paint) of a facebook timeline (post-login)
tp6_google Measures page load (hero element) of a google search result for the keywords "barack obama"
tp6_youtube Measures page load (first non-blank paint) of the youtube home page
Example data for tp6_youtube 
https://www.youtube.co/;409;441;354;337;326;375;353;650;354;712;667;336;791;497;342;355;611;334;
692;320;714;434;582;610;333

Recording a tp6 test page

Test pages used for tp6 are mitmproxy recordings that are played back during the tp6 test (and ultimately loaded in Firefox via the local proxy). Each test page is a separate mitmproxy recording (*.mp) file, however all recordings for the tp6 suite are archived in a single zip file on tooltool. When tp6 is run, talos automatically downloads the mitmproxy recording archive for use during the test.

The following process was used to record the tp6 mitmproxy page archives (on Windows 10):

1. Install mitmproxy following the mitmproxy installation instructions

2. Setup a local proxy in Firefox:

  • Start Firefox
  • Preferences => General
  • Network Proxy => Settings
  • On the "Connection Settings" screen, select "Manual proxy configuration"
  • For "HTTP Proxy" type in "127.0.0.1" with port "8080"
  • For "SSL Proxy" use the same "127.0.0.1" with port "8080"
  • Click the "OK" button to save the proxy settings

3. Install the mitmproxy CA certificate:

  • Open a terminal window
  • Startup mitmproxy in host mode:
 mitmproxy --host
  • In Firefox, browse to "mitm.it" and follow the directions on how to accept the CA certificate
  • Shutdown the mitmproxy tool (in terminal hit "Q", then "Y" to quit)

4. Record a new page:

  • Start Firefox with the proxy still enabled
  • Clear the browser history/cache
  • In a terminal window start the mitmdump recording tool:
 mitmdump -w /path/to/save/recording.mp
  • Inside Firefox browse to the URL that you want to record (i.e. www.spacex.com)
  • Wait for the page to be fully loaded and displayed
  • In the mitmdump terminal window press "ctrl + c" to stop the recording

5. To test playing back your recorded page:

  • Start Firefox with the proxy still enabled
  • With mitmproxy NOT running, browse to your recorded URL (i.e. www.spacex.com); you'll just get an error saying that the proxy server is refusing connections
  • In a terminal window, start mitmproxy playback:
 mitmdump -k /path/to/save/recording.mp
  • In Firefox browse to the URL that you recorded already (i.e. www.spacex.com). This time the page will load successfully; it is actually loading the page from the local mitmdump archive file (*.mp) and not the external site
  • In the terminal window press "ctrl + c" to stop the playback

6. When you're finished remember to turn off your Firefox proxy:

  • Preferences => General
  • Network Proxy => Settings
  • Select "No proxy" and click the "OK" button

tpaint

  • contact: :davidb
  • source: [tpaint-window.html]
  • type: Startup
  • data: we load the tpaint test window 20 times, resulting in 1 set of 20 data points.
  • summarization:
Talos test name Description
tpaint twinopen but measuring the time after we receive the MozAfterPaint and OnLoad event.

Tests the amount of time it takes the open a new window. This test does not include startup time. Multiple test windows are opened in succession, results reported are the average amount of time required to create and display a window in the running instance of the browser. (Measures ctrl-n performance.)

Example data 
[209.219, 222.180, 225.299, 225.970, 228.090, 229.450, 230.625, 236.315, 239.804, 242.795, 244.5, 244.770, 250.524, 251.785, 253.074, 255.349, 264.729, 266.014, 269.399, 326.190]

tps

Example data 
0;amazon.com/www.amazon.com/Kindle-Wireless-Reader-Wifi-Graphite/dp/B002Y27P3M/507846.html;66.34;54.15;53.08;55.79;49.12
1;cgi.ebay.com/cgi.ebay.com/ALL-NEW-KINDLE-3-eBOOK-WIRELESS-READING-DEVICE-W-WIFI-/130496077314@pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item1e622c1e02.html;50.85;46.57;39.51;36.71;36.47
2;163.com/www.163.com/index.html;95.05;80.80;76.09;69.29;68.96
3;mail.ru/mail.ru/index.html;66.21;52.04;56.33;55.11;45.61
4;bbc.co.uk/www.bbc.co.uk/news/index.html;35.80;44.59;48.02;45.71;42.58
5;store.apple.com/store.apple.com/us@mco=Nzc1MjMwNA.html;52.98;49.45;58.47;56.79;61.29
6;imdb.com/www.imdb.com/title/tt1099212/index.html;46.51;55.12;46.22;50.60;47.63
7;cnn.com/www.cnn.com/index.html;43.02;50.77;43.88;49.70;50.02
8;sohu.com/www.sohu.com/index.html;74.03;62.89;63.30;67.71;89.35
9;youku.com/www.youku.com/index.html;43.98;52.69;45.80;63.00;57.02
10;ifeng.com/ifeng.com/index.html;88.01;87.54;104.47;94.93;113.91
11;tudou.com/www.tudou.com/index.html;45.32;48.10;46.03;39.26;58.38
12;chemistry.about.com/chemistry.about.com/index.html;38.24;37.07;39.59;39.48;39.60
13;beatonna.livejournal.com/beatonna.livejournal.com/index.html;35.59;50.75;36.17;48.49;52.61
14;rakuten.co.jp/www.rakuten.co.jp/index.html;90.28;71.95;62.66;60.33;67.76
15;uol.com.br/www.uol.com.br/index.html;42.89;48.05;53.77;40.02;42.41
16;thepiratebay.org/thepiratebay.org/top/201.html;40.46;42.46;47.63;57.66;45.49
17;page.renren.com/page.renren.com/index.html;47.61;66.78;47.91;62.78;47.19
18;chinaz.com/chinaz.com/index.html;50.34;58.17;118.43;55.47;63.80
19;globo.com/www.globo.com/index.html;41.34;38.52;42.82;53.14;45.20
20;spiegel.de/www.spiegel.de/index.html;33.60;34.34;36.25;36.18;47.04
21;dailymotion.com/www.dailymotion.com/us.html;37.68;36.13;39.52;37.15;42.79
22;goo.ne.jp/goo.ne.jp/index.html;50.74;47.30;63.04;58.41;58.96
23;stackoverflow.com/stackoverflow.com/questions/184618/what-is-the-best-comment-in-source-code-you-have-ever-encountered.html;44.66;44.40;43.39;47.38;57.65
24;ezinearticles.com/ezinearticles.com/index.html@Migraine-Ocular---The-Eye-Migraines&id=4684133.html;37.38;45.01;40.29;36.26;39.28
25;huffingtonpost.com/www.huffingtonpost.com/index.html;39.57;43.35;55.01;44.13;58.28
26;media.photobucket.com/media.photobucket.com/image/funny%20gif/findstuff22/Best%20Images/Funny/funny-gif1.jpg@o=1.html;39.77;42.46;75.54;42.38;47.72
27;imgur.com/imgur.com/gallery/index.html;34.72;37.37;46.74;40.93;37.08
28;reddit.com/www.reddit.com/index.html;42.47;39.89;51.54;51.51;41.68
29;noimpactman.typepad.com/noimpactman.typepad.com/index.html;54.28;47.40;52.38;52.15;50.97
30;myspace.com/www.myspace.com/albumart.html;48.97;64.12;61.66;48.32;68.53
31;mashable.com/mashable.com/index.html;36.76;40.95;35.30;53.86;42.76
32;dailymail.co.uk/www.dailymail.co.uk/ushome/index.html;42.06;40.64;44.24;37.32;61.35
33;whois.domaintools.com/whois.domaintools.com/mozilla.com.html;34.73;35.23;39.25;48.24;35.72
34;indiatimes.com/www.indiatimes.com/index.html;52.67;55.51;46.29;52.69;58.82
35;reuters.com/www.reuters.com/index.html;32.92;33.08;36.95;39.23;39.27
36;xinhuanet.com/xinhuanet.com/index.html;125.85;102.56;138.89;130.34;147.45
37;56.com/www.56.com/index.html;63.89;75.00;61.45;62.20;58.67
38;bild.de/www.bild.de/index.html;35.61;43.74;34.79;33.45;31.83
39;guardian.co.uk/www.guardian.co.uk/index.html;38.91;55.93;62.34;42.63;45.99
40;naver.com/www.naver.com/index.html;78.10;89.07;127.67;75.18;109.32
41;yelp.com/www.yelp.com/biz/alexanders-steakhouse-cupertino.html;42.54;46.92;39.19;49.82;50.43
42;wsj.com/online.wsj.com/home-page.html;46.43;55.51;44.16;81.79;48.78
43;google.com/www.google.com/search@q=mozilla.html;35.62;36.71;44.47;45.00;40.22
44;xunlei.com/xunlei.com/index.html;67.57;60.69;83.83;85.53;85.08
45;aljazeera.net/aljazeera.net/portal.html;65.03;51.84;73.29;64.77;69.70
46;w3.org/www.w3.org/standards/webdesign/htmlcss.html;53.57;58.50;72.98;66.95;55.62
47;homeway.com.cn/www.hexun.com/index.html;105.59;117.32;108.95;116.10;70.32
48;youtube.com/www.youtube.com/music.html;40.53;41.48;59.67;40.81;40.07
49;people.com.cn/people.com.cn/index.html;96.49;103.64;115.12;66.05;117.84

tresize

  • contact: :jimm
  • source: [tresize-test.html]
  • type: StartupTest
  • measuring: Time to do XUL resize, in ms (lower is better).
  • data: we run the tresize test page 20 times, resulting in 1 set of 20 data points.
  • summarization:

A purer form of paint measurement than tpaint. This test opens a single window positioned at 10,10 and sized to 300,300, then resizes the window outward |max| times measuring the amount of time it takes to repaint each resize. Dumps the resulting dataset and average to stdout or logfile.

In bug 1102479 tresize was rewritten to work in e10s mode which involved a full rewrite of the test.

To run resize locally without talos, please install the addon to run the test locally.

Example data 
[23.2565333333333, 23.763383333333362, 22.58369999999999, 22.802766666666653, 22.304050000000025, 23.010383333333326, 22.865466666666677, 24.233716666666705, 24.110983333333365, 22.21390000000004, 23.910333333333316, 23.409816666666647, 19.873049999999992, 21.103966666666686, 20.389749999999978, 20.777349999999984, 20.326283333333365, 22.341616666666667, 20.29813333333336, 20.769600000000104]

Possible regression causes

  • slowdown in the paint pipeline
  • resizes also trigger a rendering flush so bugs in the flushing code can manifest as regressions
  • introduction of more spurious MozAfterPaint events - see bug 1471961

ts_paint

  • contact: :davidb
  • source: tspaint_test.html
  • Perfomatic: "Ts, Paint"
  • type: Startup
  • data: 20 times we start the browser and time how long it takes to paint the startup test page, resulting in 1 set of 20 data points.
  • summarization:

Starts the browser to display tspaint_test.html with the start time in the url, waits for MozAfterPaint and onLoad to fire, then records the end time and calculates the time to startup.

Example data 
[1666.0, 1195.0, 1139.0, 1198.0, 1248.0, 1224.0, 1213.0, 1194.0, 1229.0, 1196.0, 1191.0, 1230.0, 1247.0, 1169.0, 1217.0, 1184.0, 1196.0, 1192.0, 1224.0, 1192.0]

Possible regression causes

  • (and/or maybe tpaint?) will regress if a new <panel> element is added to the browser window (e.g. browser.xul) and it's frame gets created. Fix this by ensuring it's display:none by default.

tscrollx

  • contact: :jrmuizel
  • source: [scroll.manifest]
  • type: PageLoader
  • measuring: Scroll performance
  • reporting: Average frame interval (1/FPS). Lower is better.
  • data: we load 6 pages 25 times each, collecting 6 sets of 25 data points
  • summarization:
Talos test name Description
tscrollx Replacing tscroll,tsvg with tscrollx,tsvgx


This test scrolls several pages where each represent a different known "hard" case to scroll (* needinfo), and measures the average frames interval (1/FPS) on each. The ASAP test (tscrollx) iterates in unlimited frame-rate mode thus reflecting the maximum scroll throughput per page. To turn on ASAP mode, we set these preferences: 

preferences = {'layout.frame_rate': 0, 'docshell.event_starvation_delay_hint': 1}
Example data 
0;tiled.html;5.41;5.57;5.34;5.64;5.53;5.48;5.44;5.49;5.50;5.50;5.49;5.66;5.50;5.37;5.57;5.54;5.46;5.31;5.41;5.57;5.50;5.52;5.71;5.31;5.44
fixed.html;10.404609053497941;10.47;10.66;10.45;10.73;10.79;10.64;10.64;10.82;10.43;10.92;10.47;10.47;10.64;10.74;10.67;10.40;10.83;10.77;10.54;10.38;10.70;10.44;10.38;10.56
downscale.html;5.493209876543211;5.27;5.50;5.50;5.51;5.46;5.58;5.58;5.51;5.49;5.49;5.47;9.09;5.56;5.61;5.50;5.47;5.59;5.47;5.49;5.60;5.61;5.58;5.40;5.43
downscale.html;10.676522633744854;10.82;10.79;10.41;10.75;10.91;10.52;10.61;10.50;10.55;10.80;10.17;10.68;10.41;10.42;10.41;10.58;10.28;10.56;10.66;10.68;10.47;10.60;10.61;10.26
4;iframe.svg;13.82;14.87;14.78;14.35;14.73;14.50;14.15;14.46;14.80;14.48;15.10;14.93;14.77;14.52;14.08;15.01;14.58;14.52;15.23;14.35;14.72;14.28;14.30;14.27;14.96
5;reader.htm;10.72;10.62;10.23;10.48;10.42;10.64;10.40;10.40;10.14;10.60;10.51;10.36;10.57;10.41;10.52;10.75;10.19;10.72;10.44;9.75;10.49;10.07;10.54;10.46;10.44

tsvgr_opacity

  • contact: :jwatt, :dholbert
  • source: [2]
  • type: PageLoader
  • data: we load the 2 svg opacity pages 25 times, resulting in 2 sets of 25 data points
  • summarization:
Talos test name Description
tsvgr_opacity Row Major and 25 cycles/page.

Renders many semi-transparent, partially overlapping SVG rectangles, and measures time to completion of this rendering.

Note that this test also tends to reflect changes in network efficiency and navigation bar rendering issues:

  • Most of the page load tests measure from before the location is changed, until onload + mozafterpaint, therefore any changes in chrome performance from the location change, or network performance (the pages load from a local web server) would affect page load times. SVG opacity is rather quick by itself, so any such chrome/network/etc performance changes would affect this test more than other page load tests (relatively, in percentages).
Example data 
0;big-optimizable-group-opacity-2500.svg;170;171;205;249;249;244;192;252;192;431;182;250;189;249;151;168;209;194;247;250;193;250;255;247;247
1;small-group-opacity-2500.svg;585;436;387;441;512;438;440;380;443;391;450;386;459;383;445;388;450;436;485;443;383;438;528;444;441

tsvg_static

  • contact: :jwatt, :dholbert, :neerja
  • source: svg_static
  • type: PageLoader
  • data: we load the 5 svg pages 25 times, resulting in 5 sets of 25 data points
  • summarization:
Talos test name Description
tsvg_static An svg-only number that measures SVG rendering performance of some complex (but static) SVG content.
Example data 
0;gearflowers.svg;262;184;184;198;197;187;181;186;177;192;196;194;194;186;195;190;237;193;188;182;188;196;191;194;184
1;composite-scale.svg;69;52;48;49;57;51;52;87;52;49;49;51;58;53;64;57;49;65;67;58;53;59;56;68;50
2;composite-scale-opacity.svg;72;53;91;54;51;58;60;46;51;57;59;58;66;70;57;61;47;51;76;65;52;65;64;64;63
3;composite-scale-rotate.svg;70;76;89;62;62;78;57;77;79;82;74;56;61;79;73;64;75;74;81;82;76;58;77;61;62
4;composite-scale-rotate-opacity.svg;91;60;67;84;62;66;78;69;65;68;62;73;68;63;64;71;79;77;63;80;85;65;82;76;81

tsvgx

  • contact: :jwatt, :dholbert
  • source: svgx
  • type: PageLoader
  • data: we load the 7 svg pages 25 times, resulting in 7 sets of 25 data points
  • summarization:
Talos test name Description
tsvgx SVG-ASAP Replacing tscroll,tsvg with tscrollx,tsvgx

An svg-only number that measures SVG rendering performance, with animations or iterations of rendering. This is an ASAP test -- i.e. it iterates in unlimited frame-rate mode thus reflecting the maximum rendering throughput of each test. The reported value is the overall duration the sequence/animation took to complete. To turn on ASAP mode, we set these preferences: 

preferences = {'layout.frame_rate': 0, 'docshell.event_starvation_delay_hint': 1}
Example data 
0;hixie-001.xml;562;555;508;521;522;520;499;510;492;514;502;504;500;521;510;506;511;505;495;517;520;512;503;504;502
1;hixie-002.xml;510;613;536;530;536;522;498;505;500;504;498;529;498;509;493;512;501;506;504;499;496;505;508;511;503
2;hixie-003.xml;339;248;242;261;250;241;240;248;258;244;235;240;247;248;239;247;241;245;242;245;251;239;241;240;237
3;hixie-004.xml;709;540;538;536;540;536;552;539;535;535;543;533;536;535;545;537;537;537;537;539;538;535;536;538;536
4;hixie-005.xml;3096;3086;3003;3809;3213;3323;3143;3313;3192;3203;3225;3048;3069;3101;3189;3251;3172;3122;3266;3183;3159;3076;3014;3237;3100
5;hixie-006.xml;5586;5668;5565;5666;5668;5728;5886;5534;5484;5607;5678;5577;5745;5753;5532;5585;5506;5516;5648;5778;5894;5994;5794;5852;5810
6;hixie-007.xml;1823;1743;1739;1743;1744;1787;1802;1788;1782;1766;1787;1750;1748;1788;1766;1779;1767;1794;1758;1768;1781;1773;1765;1798;1805

Possible regression causes

  • Did you change the dimensions of the content area? Even a little? The tsvgx test seems to be sensitive to changes like this. See bug 1375479, for example. Usually, these sorts of "regressions" aren't real regressions - they just mean that we need to re-baseline our expectations from the test.

xperf

  • contact: :aklotz, :jmaher
  • source: xperf instrumentation
  • type: Pageloader (tp5n) / Startup
  • measuring: IO counters from windows (currently, only startup IO is in scope)
  • reporting: Summary of read/write counters for disk, network (lower is better)

Talos will turn orange for 'x' jobs on windows 7 if your changeset accesses files which are not predefined in the [whitelist] during startup; specifically, before the "sessionstore-windows-restored" Firefox event. If your job turns orange, you will see a list of files in Treeherder (or in the log file) which have been accessed unexpectedly (similar to this): 

* TEST-UNEXPECTED-FAIL : xperf: File '{profile}\secmod.db' was accessed and we were not expecting it. DiskReadCount: 6, DiskWriteCount: 0, DiskReadBytes: 16904, DiskWriteBytes: 0
* TEST-UNEXPECTED-FAIL : xperf: File '{profile}\cert8.db' was accessed and we were not expecting it. DiskReadCount: 4, DiskWriteCount: 0, DiskReadBytes: 33288, DiskWriteBytes: 0
* TEST-UNEXPECTED-FAIL : xperf: File 'c:\$logfile' was accessed and we were not expecting it. DiskReadCount: 0, DiskWriteCount: 2, DiskReadBytes: 0, DiskWriteBytes: 32768 TEST-UNEXPECTED-FAIL : xperf: File '{profile}\secmod.db' was accessed and we were not expecting it. DiskReadCount: 6, DiskWriteCount: 0, DiskReadBytes: 16904, DiskWriteBytes: 0
* TEST-UNEXPECTED-FAIL : xperf: File '{profile}\cert8.db' was accessed and we were not expecting it. DiskReadCount: 4, DiskWriteCount: 0, DiskReadBytes: 33288, DiskWriteBytes: 0
* TEST-UNEXPECTED-FAIL : xperf: File 'c:\$logfile' was accessed and we were not expecting it. DiskReadCount: 0, DiskWriteCount: 2, DiskReadBytes: 0, DiskWriteBytes: 32768

In the case that these files are expected to be accessed during startup by your changeset, then we can add them to the whitelist.

Xperf runs tp5 while collecting xperf metrics for disk IO and network IO. The providers we listen for are:

The values we collect during stackwalk are:

Build Metrics

These are not part of the Talos code, but like Talos they are benchmarks that record data using the graphserver and are analyzed by the same scripts for regressions.

Number of Constructors (num_ctors)

This test runs at build time and measures the number of static initializers in the compiled code. Reducing this number is helpful for startup optimizations.

Platform Microbenchmark Tests

IsASCII and IsUTF8 gtest microbenchmarks

Test whose name starts with PerfIsASCII test the performance of the XPCOM string IsASCII function with ASCII inputs if different lengths.

Test whose name starts with PerfIsUTF8 test the performance of the XPCOM string IsUTF8 function with ASCII inputs if different lengths.

Possible regression causes

  • The --enable-rust-simd accidentally getting turned off in automation.
  • Changes to encoding_rs internals.
  • LLVM optimizations regressing between updates to the copy of LLVM included in the Rust compiler.


Microbench

  • contact: :bholley
  • source: [MozGTestBench.cpp]
  • type: Custom GTest micro-benchmarking
  • data: Time taken for a GTest function to execute
  • summarization: Not a Talos test. This suite is provides a way to add low level platform performance regression tests for things that are not suited to be tested by Talos. See the [Microbench Sheriffing Policy] for some notes on how to treat regressions.

PerfStrip Tests

PerfStripWhitespace - call StripWhitespace() on 5 different test cases 20k times (each)

PerfStripCharsWhitespace - call StripChars("\f\t\r\n") on 5 different test cases 20k times (each)

PerfStripCRLF - call StripCRLF() on 5 different test cases 20k times (each)

PerfStripCharsCRLF() - call StripChars("\r\n") on 5 different test cases 20k times (each)

Stylo gtest microbenchmarks

  • contact: :bholley, :SimonSapin
  • source: [4]
  • type: Microbench
  • reporting: intervals in ms (lower is better)
  • data: each test is run and measured 5 times
  • summarization: take the median of the 5 data points; source: MozGTestBench.cpp


Servo_StyleSheet_FromUTF8Bytes_Bench parses a sample stylesheet 20 times with Stylo’s CSS parser that is written in Rust. It starts from an in-memory UTF-8 string, so that I/O or UTF-16-to-UTF-8 conversion is not measured.

Gecko_nsCSSParser_ParseSheet_Bench does the same with Gecko’s previous CSS parser that is written in C++, for comparison.

Servo_DeclarationBlock_SetPropertyById_Bench parses the string "10px" with Stylo’s CSS parser and sets it as the value of a property in a declaration block, a million times. This is similar to animations that are based on JavaScript code modifying Element.style instead of using CSS @keyframes.

Servo_DeclarationBlock_SetPropertyById_WithInitialSpace_Bench is the same, but with the string " 10px" with an initial space. That initial space is less typical of JS animations, but is almost always there in stylesheets or full declarations like "width: 10px". This microbenchmark was used to test the effect of some specific code changes. Regressions here may be acceptable if Servo_StyleSheet_FromUTF8Bytes_Bench is not affected.

Retrieved from "https://wiki.mozilla.org/index.php?title=Performance_sheriffing/Talos/Tests&oldid=1209144"